3 ms·
> The same thing can happen with any BSD licensed software. Anyone can do 25% of the work and create a proprietary version which is 25% better than the original
by davidw 12y ago
> The same thing can happen with any BSD licensed software. Anyone can do 25% of the work and create a proprietary version which is 25% better than the original and use it to cart off with most of the original's user base.
I'd actually use Sun and BSD as an example, but yeah, it is a possibility, which is why I am not some kind of anti-GPL zealot. I think it's less likely these days, because the effort required to really run away with a big project is considerable.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> I think it's less likely these days, because the effort required to really run away with a big project is considerable. Is it? Obviously the proprietary version has to be enough better to make a difference, but it still actually happens. Look at Konquerer. KHTML was LGPL, so Apple and Google have to release their changes to the engine itself, but not GPL, so Safari and Chrome are proprietary and nobody has even heard of Konquerer.
- millstone 12y ago"KTHL is not GPL, so Safari and Chrome are proprietary" gets the consequent wrong. Apple did not decide to fork KHTML and then pick a license. If KHTML were GPLed, Apple would have forked a different project, or perhaps even started from scratch. The end result would have been the same.
- AnthonyMouse 12y ago> Apple did not decide to fork KHTML and then pick a license. If KHTML were GPLed, Apple would have forked a different project, or perhaps even started from scratch. The end result would have been the same. You're making a baseless assertion. Apple ships an enormous amount of GPL software with OS X. It makes no sense for them to write an entire browser from scratch just to avoid the GPL when they're perfectly happy shipping bash, emacs, samba, etc.