11 ms·
Why parking spaces shouldn't always be wasted on cars
- goblin89 12y agoIn Chiang Mai near Chang Phueak Gate a sizeable paved area in front of a few mini-stores and a Ford dealership every day after 6 PM turns from parking space into busy street food market. Struck me as efficient use of space.
- eli 12y agoI think it's pretty common to use downtown parking lots for events on weekends. I know DC also has "rush hour lanes" -- parking spots that turn into a lane of traffic during rush hour.
- moron4hire 12y agoIt also doesn't help that Philadelphia's property taxes are based on decades-old property value assessments, and instead of reassessing buildings, they just jack up the property tax rate. If you build a new building today, you'll get murdered in taxes. That's assuming you don't get murdered on the union labor, or murdered by the unions if you try to avoid using union labor. So in DC, there isn't as much residential property in the city proper. It's a lot of grandiose buildings meant more for showing off the might of the empire than for fitting in lots of people. Also, the housing tends to be newer, more vertically scaled, with their own parking garages. In Philadelphia, people hold rallies to block construction of parking garages.
- eli 12y agoNot sure what "city proper" means in this context, but something like 600,000 people live in the District, which is not a terribly large city. Very few of them live in grandiose buildings like you might see around the Mall. In fact, there are pretty strict height restrictions, which means there aren't any highrise apartments and vertical development is limited.
- moron4hire 12y agoThat's the point I was trying to make. The ratio between the available street space for parking and the people who need to park in the District is much higher than the in Philadelphia.
- hoprocker 12y agoIt's nice that this is getting some press, but my sense is that it's no longer news that pedestrianism has been on the rise in dense urban areas for a tick[0]. Thanks to edward for posting this, though! [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Urbanism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Urbanism
- jrells 12y ago> Other research suggests that cyclists may actually spend more than drivers at some kinds of businesses because it's easier for them to pop in often and unplanned. This is probably due to a shortage of parking spots.
- Shivetya 12y agoand much more weather dependent. As long as the businesses if the affected area do not mind the change I see little reason to not do it.
- BrainInAJar 12y agoVancouver in the winter is rainy and cold, but a refusal to cater to motorists (most of whom are from the suburbs anyway) hasn't negatively impacted businesses, and if anything has positively impacted them
- arethuza 12y agoSimilarly Edinburgh - which is pretty damp, chilly and dark over the winter has had quite a few bars and restaurants invest in outside seating areas in tents on the street - particularly on George Street (where I work).
- joedrew 12y agoIt's impossible to have 'enough' parking spots. Induced demand shows that cars, like goldfish, always grow to fill the space they're given. It's politically difficult process, but just refusing to try to solve this problem (which leads to more New Urbanism-friendly locations) is often the right solution.
- saosebastiao 12y agoIt is possible to have enough parking spots. It is impossible to have enough free parking spots.
- chc 12y agoIt seems like roughly the same goal could have been achieved by condemning a comic book store and turning the space into a park. Is there anything to this article that isn't just the observation "People like to go where parks are" repurposed into anti-car propaganda?
- bradleyjg 12y agoThe city already owns the parking spots. No need to condemn anything. Just change the use. It isn't anti-car propaganda to point out that huge swaths of valuable public real estate are dedicated to providing free storage for empty cars, and to suggest that there are other uses that would be more beneficial to more people.
- chc 12y ago> The city already owns the parking spots. No need to condemn anything. Just change the use. OK, I'll be more explicit: I don't see any evidence that parking lots are special here. It sounds like you could build a park in the place of just about anything else and get the same benefit. It's not clear that this has anything to do with parking lots per se. > It isn't anti-car propaganda to point out that huge swaths of valuable public real estate are dedicated to providing free storage for empty cars, and to suggest that there are other uses that would be more beneficial to more people. How is that not an expression of anti-car sentiment? Are you not suggesting making it less convenient to drive cars?
- TeMPOraL 12y ago>> It isn't anti-car propaganda to point out that huge swaths of valuable public real estate are dedicated to providing free storage for empty cars, and to suggest that there are other uses that would be more beneficial to more people. > How is that not an expression of anti-car sentiment? Are you not suggesting making it less convenient to drive cars? Because it's not a sentiment, the anti-car idea here emerges straight from a rational cost/benefit analysis. There are many strong arguments for reducing the use of cars in cities - useful space lost to parking is just one of them.
- ngoel36 12y agoI wish valet parking was more prevalent. Does the additional real estate space from efficient parking lots/structures justify the labor cost of providing free valet to customers? Of course, the real solution lies in eliminating personal car usage altogether (e.g. Uber)
- checker 12y agoI'm still waiting on that self-driving car to go park itself.
- BrainInAJar 12y ago> Of course, the real solution lies in eliminating personal car usage altogether (e.g. Uber) eg bicycles and walking
- killdill 12y agoor public transport
- TeMPOraL 12y agoOr buses, trams and trains.
- blhack 12y agoOr a combination of all of these things! There are definitely times when it would be inappropriate to take a bike over an uber, and times when it would be extremely inconvenient to walk. For instance: tonight. St. Patrick's day will be my girlfriend and I going to a brewery about 10 miles from our house to try a beer they are brewing especially for today. It would be irresponsible of us to bike home after drinking, and inconvenient to walk that far. We will almost certainly be taking an uber.
- brc 12y agoTry taking 3 kids to a restaurant on a bicycle in a city. People who think cars are just plain evil need to realize why they are popular.
- geebee 12y agoOn a closely related note, I read a very interesting piece about "curb cuts" in San Francisco. http://www.spur.org/publications/article/2008-06-01/eye-street http://www.spur.org/publications/article/2008-06-01/eye-stre... The image showing the difference between Park Slope (without curb cuts) and a stretch of Dolores street in San Francisco (with curb cuts) is really eye-opening. It's a bummer, because a lot of SF really is small and walkable, but you know, we really do spend a lot of time dodging cars on the sidewalk. I didn't notice as much this until I had kids, because while you can dodge the cars coming and going across the sidewalk as an adult (or the cars just parked on the sidewalk, which is common here but nearly impossible without curb cuts), for a kid, it actually is dangerous. It's a shame that SF allows curb cuts to render even the sidewalks a hazardous place for people (esp kids) to walk, cause let's face it, SF likes to tout itself as a more urban city with a vibrant pedestrian life. The irony is that curb cuts - the bit of concrete cut out of a curb so a car can get out of the driveway and onto the street, doesn't even increase parking much, since it divides the street up into tiny bits of actual curb too small to fit a car! What it does is take a spot from the public and turns it into a private "reserved" street space. In fact, one study estimated that 50% of garages in the mission are unusable for parking (used instead for storage or other purposes), so really, this is just a reserved parking spot on the street.
- sliverstorm 12y agoHas SF ever been considered or even wanted to be considered a kid/family-friendly place? Watching from the sidelines, it's never seemed like a priority.
- antr 12y agoTwo talks worth watching regarding this very issue: Enrique Peñalosa, former Mayor of Bogota: "In no constitution, parking is a constitutional right." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3YjeARuilI&feature=youtu.be&t=6m50s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j3YjeARuilI&feature=youtu.be... Bruno Moser, Head of Urban Design at Foster + Partners: The amount of space a car requires isa problem yet to be solved: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rUH63c1n0c&feature=youtu.be&t=2m20s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0rUH63c1n0c&feature=youtu.be...
- moron4hire 12y agoPhiladelphia does not have a very good public transit system. It's fine if all you want to do is get to the center of the city, but to actually travel around the city it sucks. And parts of Philadelphia have a severe parking problem. I'm convinced that the only reason South Philadelphia works is because 1/4 to 1/2 of its population isn't at home at any one point in time. It's like sailors hot-bedding on a submarine. So if you're going to be an urbanite in Philadelphia, you have to live your entire life in Philadelphia, in your neighborhood. Which is probably why so many of the people I knew there hadn't even been out of the state, say nothing about to other countries. For some people, that's all they want, a provincial life. It's not for me. I grew up surrounded by people with that very same attitude, in a rural environment, that attitude of "why would you ever even want to go somewhere else?" I really don't see the difference of it in an urban setting and I really just don't like being around it. But I'm getting sick and tired of being treated like I'm a complete waste of a person for that reason. Seriously, the title is "Why parking spaces shouldn't always be wasted on cars", meaning the other times it's still wasted on cars, but it's somehow ok. It's just a smug sort of attitude.
- linkregister 12y agoSouth Philly parking works because double- and triple- parking is practiced (and permitted by the parking authorities in neighborhoods). Just write your cell phone number on a piece of paper, place it on your dash, and go inside. It's amazing how little this is practiced in other cities that should utilize available parking to its maximum. Thankfully, my city has a better public transit system than SEPTA. At the very least, I don't have to buy a copper subway token from a machine that only takes paper money.
- moron4hire 12y agoI think you've just gotten lucky, because I've gotten plenty of tickets in South Philly for being one inch past the "park between these signs" signs. I got a ticket once because I was parked [ here ] [ ] and the parking enforce had the order of the signs screwed up and thought I should be parked [ ] here [ ]
- 12y ago
- wahsd 12y agoHere we go with privatizing public resources and assets again. It galls me to hear moronic, self-serving corrupt things like "...the growing economic case for deploying our streets differently, for use by more than cars." In a capitalist predatory economy and society like ours public resources and assets should almost never be used for private purposes, especially not for private profit, gain, or benefit of any kind. Whether it is clogging up the city of Austin for the monkey shit show that SXSW has turned into, or taking over public parking spaces for private enterprise profit it's corrupt misappropriation and misuse of public resources and funds. It's simply corrupt and the government, on all levels, should not be engaged in commercial revenue generation precisely because it invites corruption.
- icebraining 12y agoIn a capitalist predatory economy and society like ours public resources and assets should almost never be used for private purposes So, in non-capitalist economies, they should? :) I find your rant misguided. Parking spaces are public resources being used for private benefits, i.e., for car owners. As a member of the "inferior" class of transit and foot travelers, I see no reason why your private use trumps any other.
- fraserharris 12y agoThe only galling statement is that it's "moronic" and "corrupt" for public lands to be used for anything other than the purpose of moving & storing your private car. It is public land, like any other, and can have many purposes that benefit the public. On a municipal level, those uses are decided by the democratically elected leaders. The economics of such a place are orthogonal to the use of public lands. If you are unhappy with the utilization of roads in your jurisdiction, take it up with your local leaders.
- Doctor_Fegg 12y ago"In a capitalist predatory economy and society like ours public resources and assets should almost never be used for private purposes" Right. I wish people would stop leaving their metallic private property on the public road outside my house.
- 12y ago
- avelis 12y agoOne of the cities this is popular in is San Francisco. And the data the article suggests is correct. If you don't have to worry about taking a car to park, you are more likely to spend more time in a local area with businesses available to spend your disposable income. The second benefit is creating a sense of place. The place to see or the place to hangout in. This personal behavior of a local population can transform a regional neighborhood into a vibrant culture and/or community. Great post!
- digikata 12y agoIt makes for interesting speculation for when automated cars come along and you don't need to park. Of course you don't need automation of you're willing to forgo parking via other services. Which leads to the many cities with adequate public transit/taxi service which already have areas configured with less parking. e.g. many European cities & New York city I would guess...
- rafavega 12y agoKind of related. This week in Medellín, people got fed up of car dealerships parking in sidewalks and made fun interventions like practicing yoga and setting up beach furniture (article in spanish). http://www.semana.com/nacion/articulo/en-medellin-se-cansaron-de-que-los-concesionarios-invadieran-el-anden/421201-3 http://www.semana.com/nacion/articulo/en-medellin-se-cansaro...
- softbuilder 12y agoThat reminds me of this in Mexico: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMPBlZMQhgo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iMPBlZMQhgo
- aluhut 12y agoWouldn't that just cause the clients that came by car (because of distance, health, whatever) to go somewhere else because there is no parking space? It looks to me like just another gentrification result. The new hip clients never needed those parking spots.
- wmil 12y agoThe problem with parking spots is that with single occupancy vehicles you're allocating 170 sq feet per customer for a few dollars. That's a terrible deal given real estate prices downtown. Also very few people are going to drive a significant distance for tacos or ice cream. These shops only cater to foot traffic.
- aluhut 12y agoYes few people are going to drive significant distances for tacos or ice cream but people drive distances to shop and buy then tacos and ice cream. Those are also cars with a whole family in it. Try to park your van with 3 kids in it in that gentrificated area for some ice cream. But hell...you don't want those loud suckers in your fancy eco-cafe. Upper class gentrification people don't need to drive to shop. They eat in restaurants or order online. Because they can afford it. You are causing a separation of classes here again. The whole argument runs on it and the arrogant way this class handles that by writing such 1st world problem articles is disgusting.
- aluhut 12y agoDownvoting without comments. Great.
- scottmcdot 12y agoThat parklet-sidewalk interface looks like an obvious trip hazard.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]