9 ms·
> Conversation I know barely any adults (late 20s, early 30s) who know how to do this. The concept of "conversationalist" is lost in modern society, you have t
by zamalek 12y ago
> Conversation
I know barely any adults (late 20s, early 30s) who know how to do this. The concept of "conversationalist" is lost in modern society, you have to be watching whatever junk is on TV in order to communicate with people - god forbid you want to talk about something genuinely interesting.
- gavazzy 12y agoThe problem is one of feedback. One who is extremely bad at conversation would likely be too socially unaware to recognize s/he is.
- creshal 12y agoI wouldn't say that. I know I'm bad at conversation, and I'm always mildly awed when I see e.g. my parents striking up a half-hour long conversation with random strangers in trains. I still have no idea how they do it, and I don't see many people in my age range (20-30) able to do the same.
- zamalek 12y agoThe trick is to know a little about everything, which can be acquired by: * Reading from a variety of sources (HN does provide a lot of this, click on more than just the tech articles). * People in our age group seem to have more interest in being heard than interest in listening. Don't do that. Ask questions (which is in itself a good way to hold a conversation), even about things you wouldn't think you would be interested in. * Learn to at least listen to opinions that differ from your own. Big bonus if you can dedicate energy to contemplating those opinions. In addition: * Nobody wants to hear about Game of Thrones or the latest computer game that you play. Entertainment media rarely makes for good conversation unless you share the specific entertainment piece in question (mostly sport); however, you are doing little for your future conversation ability by participating in an echo chamber. * If you screw up people will probably forget about you, not remember you as an idiot. Don't be scared to practice on strangers. * Keep your bloody phone in your pocket and ignore it.
- maroonblazer 12y ago>Ask questions (which is in itself a good way to hold a conversation), even about things you wouldn't think you would be interested in. This is really the only trick. People love to talk about themselves. As the saying goes: "Interested people are interesting."
- rustynails 12y agoI find the people who interest me the most are those whose view differs from others but is well thought out. If everyone listened but did not talk, the world would be a boring place. I'm a fringe dweller at HN. Someone mentioned relevant conversation and that's very true. I find some great things on HN that make me think. I used to frequent Ars Technica, but it became too sexist, so I now frequent a variety of non-mainstream sites for varying views of the world. I'm lucky enough to have very interesting and diverse friends off the Internet.
- desireco42 12y agoThank you for writing this. I use to be good and patient listener, yet at one point it is like a switch and now I am very impatient and even though I am aware I am doing it, I still can't wait to tell you :) what I think. Anyhow, thanks for writing it out.
- beat 12y agoKnowing a little about everything is helpful. But being interested in what you can learn from others is even more helpful! Get other people talking, and just encourage and steer them so you get value from it. When people complain about uninteresting conversations, they often mean, "I wish that other dude would shut up so I could talk about the stuff I like!" They're not listening. If they were listening and interacting with what the other person has to say, they wouldn't be bored and frustrated.
- eitally 12y agoThat's not the only trick, but it does help. A much more important factor is the openness/candidness with which you present yourself, and the amount of perceived empathy & compassion you have for the person you're engaging with. A one sided conversation is not a conversation at all.
- kaybe 12y agoThe biggest trick is to find someone who would like to have a conversation (most people would rather not). The most important sign here is eye contact and whether they're actively observing their surroundings as opposed to reading a book, talking with friends, staring into nothing. Then you have a good chance if you use an icebreaker, e.g. talk about things they have on them. (A monosyllable answer and avoiding body language means they do not want to talk, find someone else.) Some people won't shut up at all, especially older ones. If you want to hear interesting things you might have to steer the conversation a little, so eg you can hear about how the city used to be in the past as opposed to how their doctor's visit this morning went. However, the most important part is to find the ones that want to talk and broadcast the same intent. (There is better luck when it's not just people going to/from work, those usually want to be left alone.)
- tjradcliffe 12y agoAge is a big part of this. Your parents are competing in a very different social landscape than people in the 20-30 range are. People in their 20's are engaged primarily in mate selection an career building. Those are very focused and somewhat desperate endeavours, where random conversations with strangers are high risk and low payoff, particularly when talking with people in your own age group who are likely to want something from you, just as you are likely to want something from them. It's like being at one of those networking events where everyone is there to make connections that can help them but aren't able to offer much in return: an unpleasant waste of time. Older people are much more pro-social. Their investment in their offspring will be enhanced by a more friendly, connected world, and they can afford to indulge themselves in random social connections. Human society is fundamentally kept intact by grandparents. The reason we have these ridiculously long lives is most likely because troops of early humans who had more grandparents around were better at transmitting culture to new generations. I'm putting this in brutally evolutionary terms, and there is obviously much more to the story, but the evolutionary forces are always there, under the surface, and we can't just wish them away (however much we might like to.)
- beat 12y agoI have no idea why this is being downvoted. That's a fantastic insight.
- v3rt 12y agoProbably because it's a just-so story not based on reality. Building a career and finding a mate surely must be more influenced by the breadth of your social network than is your ability to help your children and grandchildren. Think about how many people you know who have gotten jobs or met their significant others through friends or acquaintances. I think anyone who sees interactions with strangers as adversarial should take a closer look at why their own stance is so suspicious. Getting to know new people definitely isn't easy, but it's incredibly rewarding in itself and opens so many doors.
- beat 12y ago
- GotAnyMegadeth 12y agoOn the other hand some people are too socially aware and are worried that they are bad at conversation when they are not.
- j2kun 12y agoThis is definitely something I have been deliberately practicing over the last few years.
- nickysielicki 12y agoSounds like you're the one that struggles with conversation.
- astrodust 12y agoYou just shut the conversation down. Congratulations.
- saiya-jin 12y agonah, I presume like in everything else, one should strive for quality, not quantity. this being highly subjective, one does not want to be one of those people desperate to talk at all costs, just to avoid moments of silence. people write here about being good listener, and encourage your counterparts to talk about them. this might be OK if you are trying at all costs to be liked by somebody else (ie find new friend). otherwise, be yourself, find interesting people that share your view with. and don't be desperate, worthy friendships take time to build, and are not meant to be had with everybody out there
- nickysielicki 12y agoI agree with you and I'm the same way. I look at it in a different light, though. It's not a deficiency in their ability to have a conversation, it's a trait of the way that we are. We don't waste our time on people that don't interest us. That's bad in some ways and good in others, but it does make us the bad conversationalists, not them.
- beat 12y agoAs one of the proponents of active listening... well, motivations vary. Personally, I think the purpose of listening is to learn. Being liked for it is a useful side effect, but not the end itself. Just about everyone I meet knows something interesting and potentially useful that I don't know. I'm not sure I agree that the purpose of conversation is to create "worthy friendships", either. Often, it's just to pass the time, or be polite, or to discover if there's a common ground for future business. Conversation is what you do with other people, not just with friends. So how do we strive for quality? What makes a "quality" conversation? Is it what we talk about, or who we talk with?
- beat 12y agoWhy else do you think "conversationalist" is lost in modern society? I know countless people who are wonderful conversationalists. Something to consider... the first step to good conversation is being genuinely interested in other people's interests. If they're talking about something you don't know, take it as an opportunity to learn. Sneering at the values of others is poor attitude, which leads to poor conversation. If you really believe people only want to discuss "junk on TV", and that it's not "genuinely interesting", you're forgetting that it's interesting to them. Declaring an objective view that makes you superior and them inferior is, well, rude. A little more about tv, weather, and other "uninteresting" subjects here - conversation is about finding common ground, something to talk about. We talk about the weather, or tv, because it's a place to start. It gets the conversation rolling, to help us discover bits about each other, and eventually find that "genuinely interesting" common ground.
- cssmoo 12y agoCan't say I've experienced that. It always seems to decline into the size of a celebrity's arse. Even one of my friends, an ex-physicist and current private jet pilot has nothing to say past the size of an arse. I just go and read a book now.
- zamalek 12y ago> It always seems to decline into the size of a celebrity's arse That's the type of issue I typically encounter. You can only talk one subject for so long, especially if the conversation has more than two participants (as diving too deep into a specific subject risks boring everyone else).
- beat 12y agoIf you can have a deep conversation, I'm a big fan of boring the other people so they'll go away and leave us to our conversation! Unless they have no way to escape. Then it's rude.
- beat 12y agoCelebrities are an important part of generic conversation... they give us someone to gossip about that neither of us actually know. Public shaming is an important (if offensive) social ritual. That said, just about anyone can talk about something other than Kim Kardashian. No one actually cares about her. Talking about something like a celebrity's arse is a way of avoiding talking about stuff we actually care about - as someone else noted in this thread, the fear of being seen as uninteresting, or weird, or an outsider, if you talk about stuff that matters to you. The way to get people to talk about what they care about is to ask them. Your friend the physicist/pilot? Ask him about physics. Ask him about airplanes. Ask him about his clients as a pilot. Pretty soon, he'll be talking about much more interesting things - interesting to him, and probably interesting to you. And all you have to do is listen, and he'll think you're awesome.
- buckbova 12y agoI agree and would add others along the lines of . . . - a hobby-skill (playing piano, ping-pong, billiards, surfing) - playing a team sport - telling a joke - defending one's self / fighting / disarming with humor All the above designed to build confidence.
- amyjess 12y agoIf you dismiss people's interests as "junk" and as not "genuinely interesting", don't be surprised when nobody wants to have a conversation with you. Nobody wants to have a conversation with somebody so condescending.