12 ms·
By San Francisco, I suspect they mean the San Francisco Bay area. While building in SF proper would decrease rents there, we can't have everyone who wants to m
by mc32 12y ago
By San Francisco, I suspect they mean the San Francisco Bay area. While building in SF proper would decrease rents there, we can't have everyone who wants to move to the Bay Area live in San Francisco proper.
Keeping this in mind, SF proper has a natural and inherent economic rent. So there is only so much pressure more building could relieve in SF proper. That said, I don't think many people would have much issue with being able to afford a place in San Mateo, Mountain View or San Jose, even Fremont. The problem is the whole bay area is averse to build up. So the only current option for those not able to afford the housing, is to commute two hours each way --South from Gilroy, East from Livermore/Tracy, northeast Coco county, etc. or doubling, tripling up and sharing rent. But that's not an option for many families.
It'd be physically difficult to have more than 6 million people living in San Francisco, no matter what density we built. So there would be some limit, just not the current approximate 800 odd thousand. The solution is to have an integrated Bay Area plan to accommodate as many people as the area can support. We must also keep in mind the ecological impact of sustaining more people in a semi arid region so perhaps desalination plants to offset water demand. Most of all, a regional government capable of making hard decisions rather than one which gives in to boisterous interest groups (rent control, height & shade restrictions, prop 13, and the adversity to pubic transit.
- wozniacki 12y agoThe problem is the whole bay area is averse to build up. Mostly true. However, that somewhat diminishes the degree by which SF especially is averse to construction, and more worryingly is averse to outsiders of all kinds - not just culturally misplaced Midwestern-ers - which is quite telling. Its a special brand of NIMBYism not found elsewhere. The following comment is also from the Economist piece and sheds light on the kind of jaundiced eyes - I don't know what else one would call it - that long time SF residents view outsiders with. This sentiment is something I highly identify with and is rarely talked about, when the issue of SF housing is hotly debated. The author is a Kansas City native who has moved to SF to wait tables : 2) San Francisco can be elitist and exclusionary towards outsiders. Some San Francisco residents look any non-Brooklyn part of the country with dismissal and/or disdain, creating a distinct form of self-defeating snobbery. I also felt this elitism when I would look at all the row houses in the Richmond and Sunset and how few where being torn down to build more efficient apartment buildings. The message was, and is,- we have ours and we don't care about your struggles. I also felt this excluding elitism when I would learn about legacy apartment dwellers who live in great locations and pay a fraction of the market price because of government controls. The government kept rental prices artificially low for established renters and rental prices artificially high for outsiders looking to move in and rent. The casual snobbery, the lack of new construction, and a preference for established renters made the city feel unwelcoming to outsiders. Which is ironic, because most people I met in San Francisco were born and raised elsewhere. [1] The rest of his comment is eminently readable too; I've truncated it because I felt I've hijacked this thread enough. http://www.economist.com/comment/2360736#comment-2360736 http://www.economist.com/comment/2360736#comment-2360736
- mblakele 12y agoI think of it as parochialism, but there may be a better word.
- Kalium 12y agoI've started using the word privilege to describe it to San Franciscans. The reactions this gets are interesting.
- nerfhammer 12y agonativism
- mc32 12y agoI don't know why, but there are a great many SFers who like to think of themselves as progressives (in the modern liberal sense) and have this weird affectation where they like to let you know what nth generation SFer they are. Like it makes a difference or as if I cared. What i can't parse is that these are the same people who say they are for more immigrant rights --whatever one thinks of immigrant rights, I can't square their desire to tell you how genuine a San Franciscan they are and the proof is in their being nth generation. So a 6th gen SFer has more status than a 5th gen SFer and so on. SF is the only place I've seen where people feel compelled to tell you their gen as if it were status in and of itself somehow.
- davidw 12y agoI spent a year there during the dot com boom, and was frankly pretty happy to move to Italy. I'm somewhat liberal politically, but San Fran always felt like a different kind of 'progressive' than back home in relatively egalitarian, fairly moderate and generally well-run Oregon. When I got to Padova, it felt like coming back to the real world. I'd go downtown and see young and old, wealthy and the not-so-well off. These days, thanks to immigration, it's also acquired some ethnic diversity: my daughter goes to a public school with children whose parents are quite varied. The economy isn't great here though, and it really makes you wonder... Most of the planet would absolutely love to have the bay area's problems, as you can see by how many places try and ape it with their Silicon Alley, Prairie, Forest, Meadows, Fjord, Barren Wasteland, Cwm, Bog and so on.
- andrewfong 12y ago> While building in SF proper would decrease rents there I'm not sure that's a given. Building lots of luxury housing in SF might actually decrease rent in Oakland and other parts of the Bay Area but not have an appreciable effect on rent in SF proper, at least in the short term. In fact, you could even argue that because of network effects and gentrification, building more luxury housing in SF would actually increase rents locally, even as it decreased rents regionally. And that actually could explain why it's rational for some low-income residents of SF to oppose (or impose conditions on) new construction in SF itself. Increasing the geographic segregation between rich and poor can impact tax revenue, crime, education, transit, and regional politics in ways that particularly hurt the poor.
- jmckib 12y agoThe point they make in the article is that the rich are going to move to SF anyway, but without available luxury housing they will have to buy up cheaper housing and have it remodeled. So you still get gentrification and network effects, but even higher prices for non-luxury housing than if you'd have just built more luxury housing in the first place.
- andrewfong 12y ago> The point they make in the article is that the rich are going to move to SF anyway That's what I'm actually unsure about. The article states it as a given without data or addressing regional effects. There are at least some well-to-do individuals who would purchase non-luxury housing in the North Bay, Berkeley, and the Peninsula rather than SF proper. You can obviously point to activity in places like the Mission and Bernal Heights, but at least some of the demand for unbuilt SF waterfront condos is going to go to the Oakland waterfront rather than something more inland. You can re-model your home, but you can't re-model your neighborhood. Even if gentrification is a given though, the timing isn't. SF interest groups are pretty good at slowing things down (whether that's new development or a purchase and re-model). Presumably there's some difference in utility to the rich of buying luxury housing and buying non-luxury housing and remodeling it (otherwise there wouldn't be much demand for luxury housing). That's leverage the poor have in extracting some kind of negotiated benefit, like better public transit, education rights, re-distributive taxes, and so forth.
- yummyfajitas 12y agoThe area of Manhattan is 90km^2. The population is 1.62 million, double that of SF. The area of SF is 600km^2. So yes, while there is some theoretical limit to the population that could be fit into SF, we are not even remotely close to it. We could triple the population of SF if we simply increased the density to that of Pune, a city with a small town feel that fits 2.5M people into 700km^2. (I.e., it's not remotely like Manhattan.) Pune has also experienced a tech boom and huge population growth, yet has not suffered from real estate issues the way SF does. The secret? Our underpopulated areas look like this: https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B8cMeVTIMAEMyzk.jpg:large https://pbs.twimg.com/media/B8cMeVTIMAEMyzk.jpg:large
- blfr 12y agoHow is transportation and other city services there? I have been listening to Econtalk episodes on urban growth[1][2] and apparently cities in the developing world experiencing quick expansion get completely clogged with traffic. The transaction costs are too high for developments to come to some agreement on providing city-wide transport. Some places don't have a proper sewage system, or rely on diesel power because they could not build an efficient power plant. [1] http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/01/alex_tabarrok_o.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/01/alex_tabarrok_o.htm... [2] http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/03/paul_romer_on_u.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2015/03/paul_romer_on_u.htm...
- tormeh 12y agoI've heard New York is the only city in the US with excellent public transport. But yes, a proper underground metro requires a fair bit of planning and coordination, and if SF can't manage that then it will eventually end up like LA.
- blfr 12y agoI don't necessarily mean public transportation. Any transportation. Employer-provided buses, cabs, rickshaws, or even just roads where you can drive your own vehicle. Whatever is appropriate.
- Shivetya 12y agoYou really don't sound much different than those who seek to prevent people from moving in, let alone building to accommodate them. Meaning, come up with a neutral sounding reason to block undesirables from coming into the neighborhood. Density would be too high, we must preserve cultural heritage, green space laws, restrictions on building heights, builds designated as heritage sites, and on and on and on. If you build up or down you can accommodate a larger number of people. The key word here is "build". This activity is prevented by an amazing number of rules, regulations, and laws, all of which have nice sounding names but the end result is the same. Zoning boards and those involved in creating political districts all need to be managed by as neutral groups as possible. All work needs to be as public as possible as well. Preventing someone from building more housing is not really different than the government condemning the land and taking it.
- mc32 12y agoI would disagree with that. I'm for building and renewal. Too many SFers want to keep SF preserved as if it was the turn of the past century. They want a small town bucolic feel. But reality is that the sleepy town is in the midst of a metropolis but many residents resist the notion, even those affected by the policies restricting growth. Renters and owners alike bristle at the possibility of their neighborhood changing its look and feel. They use words like gentrification, manhattanizatioon,; they also support restrictions on building as ridiculous as the ones which state that the shadow from new buildings shall not block the sun on a public park between specific hours. So its couched as nature friendly, in the meantime it is strictly anti building. People want to eat their cakes and have them too.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]