5 ms·
I cannot fathom how this is a trap. If the resident can afford to move elsewhere, then it's certainly not a trap. And if they can't afford to move, then removin
by wpietri 12y ago
I cannot fathom how this is a trap. If the resident can afford to move elsewhere, then it's certainly not a trap. And if they can't afford to move, then removing rent control doesn't "free" them. They're just fucked.
I know many people who have moved out of rent-controlled apartments for one reason or another. I've done it myself. I don't know a single one who says, "Whew! Thank goodness I escaped that terrible trap of being able to afford living in a place I liked!"
- philipwalton 12y agoThe assumption is that without rent control, average prices would be lower. Therefore someone who couldn't afford to move previously now could.
- hkmurakami 12y agoOr if the intent is to provide a subsidy, to have a system where the tenant can receive the same relative amount of subsidy no matter where she may choose to reside.
- ubernostrum 12y agoThe assumption is that without rent control, average prices would be lower. So... the assumption is that left to itself, a good which is incredibly scarce in a market full of wealthy, fiercely competitive customers would see a price decline? I mean, I can sort of see a long-term argument for it (the people who would occupy the housing are dependent on a much larger and much less wealthy serving class for their food and other necessaries and luxuries, and as that serving class was priced out of being able to live anywhere within an increasingly-large radius, housing would begin to become less attractive and thus prices would finally come down at least a bit). But I highly doubt that's the argument attempting to be made here, as one of the goals of rent control is to shortcut to the end of that cycle (where costs have come down enough that the serving class can afford to live nearby again).
- nindalf 12y agoI wonder if you read the article at all or went straight to the comments. Your comment reminded me of the "banana" experiment that Ars Technica ran a while ago.
- ubernostrum 12y agoThe article is so ludicrously oversimplified that I didn't feel it merited the dignity of a rebuttal, but if you can find an argument that doesn't rely on the frictionless-spherical-humanoids assumptions of efficient markets, feel free to bring it up.
- dasil003 12y agoMeanwhile your argument is super hand-wavy. There is not an infinite quantity of rich people wanting to live in San Francisco. I don't think it's reasonable to assume a priori that demand can not decrease absent rent control.
- hyperpape 12y agoI'd challenge you to accurately state the efficient market hypothesis then state the assumption in the article that is comparable. Spoiler: I don't think there is one. You're using the term as a catch all for "economic arguments I don't believe".
- stephenbez 12y agoThis article goes into a lot of depth on the effects of rent control: http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html http://www.econlib.org/library/Enc/RentControl.html "Economists are virtually unanimous in concluding that rent controls are destructive. In a 1990 poll of 464 economists published in the May 1992 issue of the American Economic Review, 93 percent of U.S. respondents agreed, either completely or with provisos, that “a ceiling on rents reduces the quantity and quality of housing available.” Similarly, another study reported that more than 95 percent of the Canadian economists polled agreed with the statement."
- wpietri 12y agoThis strikes me as an illusion based on conflating two different someones. The someone who feels trapped under rent control would often have been driven to move elsewhere years before if rent control didn't exist. The someone in the non-controlled apartment who doesn't feel trapped is likely to have a higher income.
- transitorykris 12y agoI've witnessed a couple in a SF 1 bedroom rent controlled apartment (of many years) fret over when to have a child. A 2 bedroom at market rate is a non-trivial change. It certainly feels like a trap to them.
- bmmayer1 12y agoIt's a liquidity problem for the whole marketplace. There's only a limited amount of space to rent in the first place. When people get older and don't need as much space, they don't move to a smaller unit to free up space for people who need more space for growing families. So you end up with one person living in a space for four people and four people living in a space for one person.