5 ms·
Freeness in of itself is not a goal. Dirt is free. Air is free. I can put a "hello world" app out there and release it under GPL, but is it useful? Does it act
by Karunamon 12y ago
Freeness in of itself is not a goal. Dirt is free. Air is free.
I can put a "hello world" app out there and release it under GPL, but is it useful? Does it actually solve any problems?
- marrs 12y agoSurely "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a copyleft licence since its purpose is to teach you how to get started with the language it demonstrates. In any case, freeness is a goal for me as a user of software. I choose Gimp over Photoshop, for example, because I care more about still being able to access my photos in 20 years time than I do about having access to certain feature sets.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Surely "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a copyleft licence since its purpose is to teach you how to get started with the language it demonstrates. I would argue that "hello world" is useful only if you release it under a very permissive non-copyleft free software license or, better, as public domain, for exactly that reason. Copyleft is excessively restrictive for this purpose.
- Karunamon 12y agoThat is a practical concern, not a political one. The purely political stance I rail against is, in effect, "X fits my use case and is objectively better in every way, but Y is free, so I'll use Y." For what it's worth, I can still open PSD's created way back in the 90's, and the format is well documented.[1] Adobe could disappear in a puff of logic tomorrow and their format wouldn't become unreadable. [1]: https://www.adobe.com/devnet-apps/photoshop/fileformatashtml/