3 ms·
Feedback: Browser crypto is unreliable. This has been debated to death, but here's a plain and simple fact: Your project delivers crypto software via your webs
by peterwwillis 12y ago
Feedback:
Browser crypto is unreliable. This has been debated to death, but here's a plain and simple fact: Your project delivers crypto software via your website to the user's browser, so this connection is absolutely critical for your site to be worth anything at all. And yours is not secure.
First off, your root domain has no SSL server (https://bitjournal.io/ https://bitjournal.io/), so it's vulnerable to HSTS hijacking. Basically, if you use HSTS, someone can MITM the initial connection to http://bitjournal.io/ http://bitjournal.io/ every time because you don't have an SSL server on that hostname to negotiate HSTS. Fix: set up HSTS and an HTTP redirect on http://bitjournal.io/ http://bitjournal.io/ to https://bitjournal.io/ https://bitjournal.io/, set up HSTS and an HTTP redirect on http://www.bitjournal.io/ http://www.bitjournal.io/ to https://www.bitjournal.io/ https://www.bitjournal.io/, and then HTTP redirect from https://bitjournal.io/ https://bitjournal.io/ to https://www.bitjournal.io/ https://www.bitjournal.io/.
Slightly more pressing problem: you aren't using HSTS at all. Anyone can mitm your site and screw with your users.
Additional problem: your SSL site supports weak encryption, and is potentially vulnerable to secure renegotiation DoS.
My suggestion is to do a lot more research into security in general before you get into making crypto software. You can fix the problems I mention above in a weekend, but that doesn't mean you won't make other mistakes which could expose your users' private data.
- sasas 12y agoExactly my thoughts too. You would have thought that basic xss would be handled [1]. Downright irresponsible to tout a security product without due diligence. [1] http://imgur.com/DKmfic0 http://imgur.com/DKmfic0
- logicallee 12y agogee, I'd hate to see what you have to say to the guy in this thread who made secretdiary.org which "was basically the same idea but implemented server-side", using php. in other words, relax, this is obviously a joke and not actually meant to be secure in any way, shape, or form.
- akerl_ 12y ago"Keep your thoughts, ideas, and other confidential information protected from prying eyes with your own BitJournal. Each entry is encrypted with a symmetric key cipher, and only you have the key." Hopefully the author can comment, but this doesn't look like a joke.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]