36 ms·
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding basic economics here, but: The 20 people who originally couldn't find houses in SF (who formerly would have needed to bid $4), can
by Karunamon 12y ago
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding basic economics here, but:
The 20 people who originally couldn't find houses in SF (who formerly would have needed to bid $4), can bid $2 on some of the formerly rent controlled houses. They get leases.
If the market rent is $4, and the control is $1, and the control disappears, why on earth wouldn't the landlords in possession of the formerly-controlled properties immediately raise their prices to the market price?
- stephencanon 12y agoBecause there aren't 100 people in the model city willing/able to pay $4 rent. The landlords might attempt to do what you suggest, but as they fail to rent their properties month after month, they will gradually drop the rent they are asking until equilibrium is reached.
- hiou 12y agoHere are a few reasons[0] you might want to look into about this fabled "equilibrium" in commercial real estate. [0] http://www.ezracompany.com/2012/04/30/why-do-landlords-let-spaces-remain-vacant-2/ http://www.ezracompany.com/2012/04/30/why-do-landlords-let-s...
- sefu 12y agothis assumes a perfect system, with specific conditions. the real estate market tends to be neither. apartments go vacant all the time waiting for the $4 swm.
- astrodust 12y agoThis highly simplified example doesn't have sufficient information to calculate what the equilibrium will be. Obviously it will be lower than $4, but what?
- endtime 12y agoIf supply goes up and demand is fixed, prices go down.
- Karunamon 12y ago..in an ideal system with completely rational actors. People will sit on properties that are not selling and not touch the price.
- stephencanon 12y agoAnd those people will eventually go bankrupt and the rental rates on their properties will reset. The market can stay irrational for arbitrarily long times, but not forever.
- dragonwriter 12y ago> The market can stay irrational for arbitrarily long times, but not forever. Civilization, OTOH, cannot exist for arbitrarily long times (the heat death of the universe presents a pretty firm outer boundary), so the fact that the market can stay irrational for arbitrarily long times, but not forever, should not be seen as reassuring, or even meaningful. Or, to quote Keynes, "In the long run we are all dead. Economists set themselves too easy, too useless a task, if in tempestuous seasons they can only tell us, that when the storm is long past, the ocean is flat again."
- Karunamon 12y agoThe time it takes that to happen may be so long as to be effectively meaningless. A rational person holding out for the "right" renter willing to pay the higher price would lower their prices sooner, but as previously established, people are not rational. Given the landlords that are holding multiple properties, they may just let the surplus profit soak up the loss from leaving the place without tenant. Hiou linked a few good (and actually rational) reasons why this may happen, as well: http://www.ezracompany.com/2012/04/30/why-do-landlords-let-spaces-remain-vacant-2/ http://www.ezracompany.com/2012/04/30/why-do-landlords-let-s... The end result is that it's not as simple as ECON101 supply and demand.
- x0x0 12y agoProp 13 means carrying costs can be extraordinarily low.
- nickstefan12 12y agoBecause the old market price was $4 due to there only being 20 houses that could freely move on price. If there's 100 houses there will more supply and the market rate will drop. Basically market rent is simply the price at the available margin.
- gravity13 12y agoAnd here I have no doubt that there's sufficient demand to account for the increase in supply. There's probably not 120 people, and 100 houses. I think it's 500 people and 100 houses. Higher rent has driven a lot of people out who would have preferred to stay but couldn't because of the price. Rent control is the only thing keeping some of them here. - written from my cold, moldy dying home in the Sunset.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- metaphorm 12y agothey are free to ask for $4. if the market is working efficiently then the renters in the market will start a bidding war between landlords to lower their price. as soon as one landlord reduces the asking price below $4 its all over, and the $4 "market price" is proved to no longer be the market price.