5 ms·

We moved to Gogs. GitLab was too slow, and started giving us random 500 errors (fatal bug). Overall, it's been more enjoyable than Gitlab. Things I don't like:

by izolate 12y ago

We moved to Gogs. GitLab was too slow, and started giving us random 500 errors (fatal bug). Overall, it's been more enjoyable than Gitlab. Things I don't like: * No pull requests / issues * No deploy keys * It's a full on GitHub replacement in the sense that anybody can sign up to your Gogs instance and use it. Who's using it that way? Would be much better if it were built for one organization with a way to group repos into projects.

apetresc 12y ago
"No pull requests" and "It's a full on GitHub replacement" seem like incompatible statements.
- mangoman 12y ago
  I think what he meant was "Why can anyone signup for my Gogs server?" It'd still be nice to have pull requests across teams, or even just as a place for code reviews.
- timtadh 12y ago
  You can always use another code review tool to do pull requests. You can also do it the way Linus does with pull request emails (git request-pull). It isn't really a deal breaker to not have it built in. There are other ways to use git than following rigidly to the current github model.
- taylorlapeyre 12y ago
  Yeah, no pull requests is an instant deal breaker.
  - izolate 12y ago
    They'll be included in some near future release. See this: https://github.com/gogits/gogs/issues/5 https://github.com/gogits/gogs/issues/5
sytse 12y ago
GitLab CEO here, I'm sorry to hear you experienced 500 errors. That shouldn't happen. Did you use our Omnibus packages? https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ Anyway, if you want to look into it email me at sytse@gitlab.com
- lifty 12y ago
  I have to say, I appreciate your willingness and approach in solving problems and improving your product. Keep up the good work!
  - sytse 12y ago
    Thanks lifty!
the_angry_angel 12y ago
> anybody can sign up to your Gogs instance and use it. It's possible to turn off the registration feature. I've got it integrated into our Active Directory. It's possible to get project "groups" by creating an organisation per project.

by izolate 12y ago

apetresc 12y ago

"No pull requests" and "It's a full on GitHub replacement" seem like incompatible statements.

mangoman 12y ago
I think what he meant was "Why can anyone signup for my Gogs server?" It'd still be nice to have pull requests across teams, or even just as a place for code reviews.
timtadh 12y ago
You can always use another code review tool to do pull requests. You can also do it the way Linus does with pull request emails (git request-pull). It isn't really a deal breaker to not have it built in. There are other ways to use git than following rigidly to the current github model.
taylorlapeyre 12y ago
Yeah, no pull requests is an instant deal breaker.
- izolate 12y ago
  They'll be included in some near future release. See this: https://github.com/gogits/gogs/issues/5 https://github.com/gogits/gogs/issues/5

sytse 12y ago

GitLab CEO here, I'm sorry to hear you experienced 500 errors. That shouldn't happen. Did you use our Omnibus packages? https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ https://about.gitlab.com/downloads/ Anyway, if you want to look into it email me at sytse@gitlab.com

lifty 12y ago
I have to say, I appreciate your willingness and approach in solving problems and improving your product. Keep up the good work!
- sytse 12y ago
  Thanks lifty!

the_angry_angel 12y ago

> anybody can sign up to your Gogs instance and use it. It's possible to turn off the registration feature. I've got it integrated into our Active Directory. It's possible to get project "groups" by creating an organisation per project.