9 ms·
This is essentially a fundamentalist view of property rights. It seems like that for any X, you can find people to assert that X is obviously the most important
by wpietri 12y ago
This is essentially a fundamentalist view of property rights. It seems like that for any X, you can find people to assert that X is obviously the most important thing in the world, so anything else doesn't matter. Fundamentalisms are mentally satisfying, because you always have clear answers. But they're practically dangerous, because the ignored concerns don't actually go away.
Land, of course, does not work like you imagine it does. See, e.g.,:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_tenure#Modes_of_ownership_and_tenure http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_tenure#Modes_of_ownership_...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adverse_possession
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reform http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reform
In addition to all that, you ignore that concepts like "trade" and "law" and even "earned" are all intrinsically social concepts. No man is an island. That doesn't mean that property rights aren't useful and important, but if you want everybody to agree on a particular set of rights, you'll have to make a case that is more compelling than, "my particular moral code says you must abide by my particular moral code".
- shaftoe 12y agoProperty rights aren't "useful and important." Property rights are the fundamental basis for any other right. What right to life does anyone have if not because they "own" their own life? What right to free speech do they have if they do not "own" their own speech? Thievery doesn't become acceptable because someone makes a compelling case or a pretty argument. Justice doesn't become "fundamentalism" because it won't compromise with injustice.
- ForHackernews 12y agoNo! Collective ownership is fundamental, and individual property rights are just a convenient legal fiction. See, I can make sweeping, unsupported assertions, too!
- eridius 12y ago> What right to life does anyone have if not because they "own" their own life? Congratulations, you just justified slavery.
- eridius 12y agoI was absolutely serious about that comment. Am I being downvoted because people disagree, or just because the Libertarians here don't like being told that treating lives as property ownership is the basis for slavery? Either way, I'm open to discussion on this point.
- wpietri 12y agoThat you have found a way to construct all the rights you can think of based on a specific construction chattel property rights is interesting. But it doesn't it make it the only way to think about rights (or ethics or morals), or even a particularly good one. Your fixation on one thing and your refusal to compromise or even to admit the validity of other views is exactly what fundamentalists do.
- maxharris 12y agomy particular moral code says you must abide by my particular moral code It's not merely an arbitrary moral code that I'm asserting. What other way is there to live than to use your mind as best you can to make the most of your limited time? What other way is there to live than to treat others neither as masters nor slaves, but as trading partners (in love, friendship, mentorship, business)?
- kelnos 12y agoArbitrariness isn't the issue. Agreement between various moral codes -- often in harmony, often conflicting -- is what matters. And often that means compromising on some things. You don't appear willing to compromise on what seems like an advocation for absolute property ownership rights.
- maxharris 12y agoSo how would you compromise on the points I raised? What would you advocate for instead? Stating these openly might help clarify the issue.
- kelnos 12y agoOne thing in your post really stood out to me: What other way is there to live than to treat others neither as masters nor slaves, but as trading partners (in love, friendship, mentorship, business)? You're advocating the opposite of that. As a landlord -- assuming a world with absolute property rights -- you have a significant power advantage over your tenant. A 3x-4x rent increase is not treating your tenant as a "trading partner", it's using your status as landowner to your enrichment and their detriment. Further up you suggest: A group that votes to dictate what I can do with my property might be doing it by the letter of the law, but that doesn't make it morally right Not inherently, no. That's only the case if you believe that the voting-majority group is immoral. That certainly can be the case, but I don't believe it's the case often enough to abandon the idea of democracy. Personally, I'm definitely in favor of limiting property rights. Property is in general not a fungible "product", and its supply is limited. I consider land to be a public good. The state grants you some property rights, but reserves to place some restrictions on what you can do with the property in the name of the public good. I don't think we have the balance down perfectly yet, but I would absolutely not advocate giving property owners carte blanche to do whatever they want with that property. It's a matter of drawing the line somewhere: I think you might agree that some restrictions are good. Disallowing renting decisions based on discrimination of protected classes is something we might agree is a good thing (sorry, I don't mean to state your position for you, but I don't know you, so I'm just stating a hope, a guess, as to somewhere we might find common ground). If we can take that as a given, then we can agree that the state restricting property owners to some extent does indeed make sense. And from there it's finding a list of things that it's ok to restrict, and it's not ok to restrict. From this discussion I'd guess that my list of things that it's ok to restrict is a bit longer than yours. And that's ok, but at least it's a starting point from which to find a compromise. The final list has more on it than you want, and less on it than I want. Business deals and compromise are rarely about making one or the other party (or both) 100% happy. I believe there's "common wisdom" floating around that the best deal is one that both sides are slightly uncomfortable with, and I believe that to be pretty true. If, on the other hand, you do truly believe in giving property owners absolute power and free reign to do whatever they want with it, then I don't know that we can actually have a productive discussion, because our viewpoints may just be too different. That's unfortunate, but that happens sometimes.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]