5 ms·
Littler-known fact: if you are serious about protecting that message, then web based email can't really do it. So long as the server has access to your plainte
by SilasX 12y ago
Littler-known fact: if you are serious about protecting that message, then web based email can't really do it.
So long as the server has access to your plaintext as you compose it, the security is compromised and a third party has it. And then if the recipient views the plaintext from a browser...
If you want the email to be secret, it must be in it's encrypted form before the browser even knows about it ... but at that point, why not just use a different, well vetted client program for email?
- EC1 12y ago> but at that point, why not just use a different, well vetted client program for email? Anyone have any names?
- moe 12y agoMutt and Thunderbird come to mind.
- jvehent 12y agoGPG in Mutt is fantastically well integrated. Now, of course, you have to get used to Mutt first :)
- middleclick 12y agoThunderbird with Enigmial also works quite well. I use it everyday.
- ekianjo 12y agoClawsmail as well :)
- barnaby 12y agoWhiteout.io is a chrome app for email, plus an android app with key-synch between the two. It's still early stages, so it has some issues (like indexing all your emails, since forever, and overheating your computer). But it's very promising. Most people want to continue using webmail though. That's why Mailvelope is so awesome. Continue using webmail, but just have an extra button added which opens up an editor with a bit "encrypt" button. Pretty easy, and pretty safe.
- owly 12y agoThere's also protonmail.ch tutanota.de and several others in early stages.
- throwawayaway 12y agohttps://crypto.cat/ https://crypto.cat/ I thought that the google thing would be implemented along the lines of the above service. I didn't realise the server still has access to the plaintext as it it composed?
- utnick 12y agoThe way these end to end plugins work, the website never has access to the plaintext message, it all goes through your browser extension first.
- hurin 12y agoWhat GP is saying is not directly correct, but if the third-party service is compromised they could force you to leak the unencrypted message? More than that if the third-party service is compromised they can MiTM your encrypted communications anyways.
- magicalist 12y agoNo, it's encrypted client-side in the extension. A MITM would only see the already encrypted message that your email provider would have seen.
- hurin 12y agoThat wasn't the point I was making - you're still relying on Yahoo providing the public key which corresponds to a given email-address, nothing prevents Yahoo (or whichever third-party service you use) from decoding your messages under those conditions. You're also relying that the third-party extension used for encryption hasn't been tampered with on their end.
- magicalist 12y agoSorry, I may have misunderstood based on which kind of MITM you were talking about here :) For the points you bring up, at least in the current nerfed extension they aren't really an issue. Key exchange does not happen through the extension or through yahoo, it has to happen out of band. In addition, since this is just the developer preview, AFAIK there is no extension distribution except through github (and so no updates to auto-download). You have to build and install the extension yourself. Key exchange and extension verification are still two difficult remaining problems, but they are hopefully not insurmountable.
- magicalist 12y agoIt's in an iframe the page has no access to. (please read about things before taking it on yourself to educate others...)
- SilasX 12y agoSure, so long as a) the extension uses a sandboxed one, and b) you can assume your browser and c) extension implementation don't leak iframe information. It just seems like an unnecessary and avoidable risk.
- magicalist 12y agoIt's a cross-domain iframe, so there is no access to it by the page. Security is subject to browser exploits, that's true, but that has nothing to do with what you were saying above.
- progress 12y agoBecause it's hard to MITM that :P