3 ms·
Meerkat legitimately broke Twitter rules with their autotweeting of replies to in-app comments without consent: https://support.twitter.com/articles/76915-autom
by minimaxir 12y ago
Meerkat legitimately broke Twitter rules with their autotweeting of replies to in-app comments without consent: https://support.twitter.com/articles/76915-automation-rules-and-best-practices https://support.twitter.com/articles/76915-automation-rules-...
> "The @reply and Mention functions are intended to make communication between users easier, and automating these processes in order to reach many users is considered an abuse of the feature. If you are automatically sending @reply messages or Mentions to many users, the recipients must request or approve this action in advance. For example, sending automated @replies based on keyword searches is not permitted. Users should also have an easy way to opt-out of your service (in addition to the requirement that all users must opt-in before receiving the messages)"
Although this behavior is still in the app I believe. Regardless, this, along with the [LIVE NOW] spam, has resulted in me unfollowing/muting everyone who uses Meerkat on Twitter, which has significantly reduced the effectiveness of Twitter for me, and which is why I think Twitter is in the right for wanting to restrict content.
- gojomo 12y agoMeerkat makes it fairly clear that "everything that happens on Meerkat also happens on Twitter" – and the comments on a stream only go to Twitter as replies to the original invite tweet. That's not 'automatically… to many users" but specifically to those viewing a thread, and only when individual users compose individual replies. It's not a clear violation of the quoted policy… if at all. And as you note, that's not the behavior Twitter has started.
- minimaxir 12y ago> That's not 'automatically… to many users" but specifically to those viewing a thread, and only when individual users compose individual replies. Correct, but due to the Twitter mechanic where replies are shown in your feed if you are following both people (which was the case for me as the initial users are techies), it can still be a mess.
- frandroid 12y ago> "everything that happens on Meerkat also happens on Twitter" That doesn't /mean/ anything.
- gojomo 12y agoSeems to me that the most obvious interpretation of that statement – that each action on Meerkat generates a Tweet – is also the correct one.
- xasos 12y agoI agree. Something like a "Streams" tab in the app would be awesome. Once Twitter (most likely) rolls out this feature natively with its Persicope acquisition, it would make it a lot less spammy than the way Meerkat handles it. I want to be able to differentiate between tweets and live streams.