9 ms·
Reddit: can anyone clean up the mess behind 'the front page of the internet'?
- killerninjacat 12y agoNope they can't. Reddit is too much full of bullshit, hate, and things like that.
- darkstar999 12y agoThe mainstream subreddits can be, but get into hobby subreddits and it is a great community. /r/startups, /r/homebrewing, /r/malefashionadvice. Even /r/personalfinance got front paged is still going strong.
- stefantalpalaru 12y agoInternet: can anyone clean up the mess behind 'the world wide web'?
- StephenFalken 12y agoThat makes me remember the now famous quote: The Internet was done so well that most people think of it as a natural resource like the Pacific Ocean, rather than something that was man-made. When was the last time a technology with a scale like that was so error- -free? The Web, in comparison, is a joke. The Web was done by amateurs. -- Alan Kay
- raldi 12y agoWhat year is that quote from?
- mirkules 12y ago2012: the full interview is here: http://www.drdobbs.com/architecture-and-design/interview-with-alan-kay/240003442?pgno=1 http://www.drdobbs.com/architecture-and-design/interview-wit... The complete quote: Binstock: One thing about jazz aficionados is that they take deep pleasure in knowing the history of jazz. Kay: Yes! Classical music is like that, too. But pop culture holds a disdain for history. Pop culture is all about identity and feeling like you're participating. It has nothing to do with cooperation, the past or the future — it's living in the present. I think the same is true of most people who write code for money. They have no idea where [their culture came from] — and the Internet was done so well that most people think of it as a natural resource like the Pacific Ocean, rather than something that was man-made. When was the last time a technology with a scale like that was so error-free? The Web, in comparison, is a joke. The Web was done by amateurs. Edit to add some context: Kay: Go to a blog, go to any Wiki, and find one that's WYSIWYG like Microsoft Word is. Word was done in 1984. HyperCard was 1989. Find me Web pages that are even as good as HyperCard. The Web was done after that, but it was done by people who had no imagination. They were just trying to satisfy an immediate need. There's nothing wrong with that, except that when you have something like the Industrial Revolution squared, you wind up setting de facto standards — in this case, really bad de facto standards. Because what you definitely don't want in a Web browser is any features.
- nickstefan12 12y agoIt's amazing how much harder a decent wysiwyg is to make in web technologies than you'd think. Content editable was supposed to get us there, but needs a ton of override. Grouping key and click events into actions the way youd expect ms word to function is again not easy!
- mirkules 12y agoIt is difficult, I agree. But that's not really the point Kay is trying to make. Why should we implement these things in the web browser? Further in the interview, Kay remarks that that is exactly the problem - that we are reinventing technologies that were around for decades (reinventing them poorly to boot, as he puts it "reinventing a flat tire"). I happen to agree with him in theory: I think it's a huge missed opportunity to force the browser to be an application delivery mechanism instead of a content-delivery mechanism (or "object"-delivery as he puts it). But of course in practice, there are historical and political reasons as to why web-as-an-app-delivery-mechanism happened, not least of which - if we took Kay's example of MS Word - is Microsoft's unwillingness to open up the platform (or proprietary software, in general). So we had to re-solve these problems in non-proprietary ways, while forcing proprietary app providers to conform to web standards that would ultimately and perhaps knowingly cannibalize their software sales.
- bootload 12y ago@raldi, "Interview with Alan Kay", 2012JUL10 ~ http://www.drdobbs.com/architecture-and-design/interview-with-alan-kay/240003442 http://www.drdobbs.com/architecture-and-design/interview-wit... and another on ars that talks around this quote ~ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/06/parsing-the-difference-between-the-internet-and-the-web-according-to-alan-kay/ http://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/06/parsin...
- nadams 12y agoPerhaps someone should call a plumber? It is after all - only a series of tubes![1] (or so I hear...) [1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_of_tubes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Series_of_tubes
- data_spy 12y agoAs long as there are clear guidelines, they can use text, image, and behavioral algorithms to do some serious clean up. I doubt it will ever be perfect
- StavrosK 12y agoBut reddit isn't a single thing, it's a place for communities. Surely, it can't all be messy, let alone equally messy.
- mcantelon 12y agoThe "clean up Reddit" campaign is likely an effort to get Reddit to impose ideologically-driven authoritarian administration (more so than already exists). 4chan was subjected to a similar campaign and eventually yielded. Reddit's traditional approach has, for the most part, been to err on the side of freedom of speech with minimal rules. Aside from the core rules, subreddit fiefdoms are allowed to manage their domains as moderators see fit.
- exo762 12y agoGuardian call for censorship, with primary source being SRS mod which goes by moniker Dworkin, which happens to be a nod to Andrea Dworkin - very radical and men-hating person. Good job, Guardian!
- toxicFork 12y ago“That’s more than double the population of the entire UK, so it makes about as much sense as generalising every single person in the UK, if the UK had twice as many people.” Great quote. One thing I have noticed with subreddits is that whenever a subreddit passes a threshold of subscribers and gets more frontpage exposure, the quality gets worse and worse until everyone starts hating it, unless moderators take serious action. It happened to many of them, from /r/atheism to /r/gaming, to /r/adviceanimals. As you get more people into any community, it needs more policing and moderation. AskReddit and some others have stricter rules and seem to be doing better.
- StevenRayOrr 12y ago> unless moderators take serious action And even then, when moderators do take serious action, there is often an accompanying backlash against them. As if the very degradation of quality is a feature rather than a bug.
- mkr-hn 12y agoAskScience and AskHistorians are two of my favorite subreddits due to the strict rule enforcement.
- wlkr 12y agoThis is so true. I frequent a wide variety of online communities and the same can be said of any of them. Any increase in the rate of new posts always leads to a degradation in post quality until 'stream rate' is reached and people are posting without the expectation of their posts even being read. Maintaining a healthy post rate is crucial but, as you say, quality also needs to be enforced by some form of moderation with unambiguous rules. Evolutions of a community can be tied strongly to post-rate fluctuations over time and most long term users are well aware of these iterations. On forums, large communities can be splintered for the benefit of quality and discussion.
- qznc 12y agoThe phenomenon is quite old. See e.g. "eternal september" [0]. The sad thing is that nobody has any better idea than strict rules enforced without mercy. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- StavrosK 12y agoI love how there's a "[sic]" after "penes", even though that's the correct plural.
- tomjen3 12y agoI tried to take the article serious until it classified all NSFW subreddits as reddits dark side. Yeah because collections of pictures of naked women are now so horrible they must be "cleaned up".
- ncza 12y agoNaked *people! There are tons of sexual subreddits that have no women but whatever you like. Gay, trans, pony, dragon/car, your choice.
- Vaskivo 12y agoThey don't need to be nude. /r/gentlemanboners, a subreddit for tasteful, non-nude celebrity pictures, is considered "Bad Reddit"
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- monksy 12y agoI've got some news for them. Everyone is naked under their clothes. Its horrible.
- therealdrag0 12y ago"Clothes make the man. Naked people have little or no influence on society." - Mark Twain
- mkr-hn 12y agoThat depends on what they're doing while naked.
- belovedeagle 12y ago> it classified all NSFW subreddits as reddits dark side. That's funny; I took the article seriously until it didn't classify, e.g., /r/ladybonersgw (male nudes mostly for a female audience) as "Reddit's dark side". Granted, they didn't list a thousand other NSFW subs, but to it still seemed like a pretty blatant omission and spin to only list NSFW subs with female nudes for a male audience. (See also Vaskivo's comment.) And I needn't tell you what the majority of Redditors would say about an SRS mod speaking for Reddit.
- rriepe 12y agoThe subreddit infographic is terrible on its own, but the underlying logic (moderator connections) is just abysmal. There was a time (maybe now, even, if they haven't fixed it) where any subreddit could add anyone as a moderator without their permission. Here's Zach Braff's actual reddit profile, for a fun example: https://www.reddit.com/user/zachinoz https://www.reddit.com/user/zachinoz
- seany 12y agoI don't think anyone involved in SRS can be taken seriously enough to be cited as an authority on anything. Yikes
- intortus 12y agoOn the contrary, good satire is often founded upon deep insights.
- falcolas 12y agoI don't find SRS to be satirical in the least. Hateful, sometimes. Aggressive, frequently. Strongly biased? Their bias is spelled out in the subreddit name. The reason they bubble to the top of so many news articles is because SRS' brand of equality is so strongly polarized in a way which makes for great soundbites. Want to know what's "wrong" with Reddit? Grab a headline out of SRS. Want a view on how to "improve" Reddit? Talk to a SRS moderator. If you're looking for satire, check out /r/circlejerk/. They do a great job at finding what's so wrong with the posts that hit the front page and satirizing them.
- eertami 12y agoCirclejerk is now just as bad and modded by mostly SRSers - anything or anything that would be go against the SRS ideology is deleted/banned.
- mcantelon 12y agoCriticism of SRS comes from their online mobbing, not their satire. They have a reputation for brigading and harassing ideological opponents.
- monksy 12y agoDon't forget doxxing, harassing, taking over subs, etc.
- dennisnedry 12y ago
- minimaxir 12y agoReddit can't clean itself up, which is actually the primary reason why it's looking into alternative business models outside of advertising (Reddit TV, RedditMade, Reddit Coin), since advertisers may not be willing to sponsor a website with such material. The fact that all of those models have failed miserably is a separate issue.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- elchief 12y agoCensorship of things you find offensive is not a great answer.
- WorldWideWayne 12y agoI would like a comment system that lets me choose my own moderators either directly or indirectly based on comments that i upvote. Then, if enough of my moderators downvote a comment, i wouldn't see it.
- therealdrag0 12y agoInteresting idea. But, echo-chamber much?
- WorldWideWayne 12y agoPossibly, but I think it would be easy to engineer solutions to make an echo-chamber less likely. I would still be in control and able to see hidden comments like reddit where the hive-mind basically censors things but still allows them to be accessed if you dig. I guess that I just want something where I have a little more control as a user. Many times on reddit there is a huge thread of jokes or puns that is totally off-topic and I'd like to avoid them if I choose to. Many times I want zero moderation so I can see what everybody is saying without having to click "load more comments" on every sub-thread. I can think of lots of variations on the basic idea of picking your own moderators. I like the idea of untying a subject from a specific set of moderators. So a sub-reddit would just be a subject, but not a set of moderators. There could be a moderator marketplace where individuals or teams of moderators who advertise their style and specify things like no-jokes, no-puns, etc. There could be robot moderators as well. I would also like to give my team of personal comment-curators more controls than just up and down-vote like tagging or like the slashdot system where you could mark things as funny/off-topic/etc. (Crowd voting is a type of moderation too and I'd like to be able to ignore them because I don't always trust the alleged majority.)
- eertami 12y ago>SRS moderator: "but there are hate movements that use Reddit as a propaganda organ… and someone needs to step up and get rid of them.” Well yeah... like SRS. These people are oblivious to irony.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mcantelon 12y agoHow do you talk about Reddit without talking about the communities and factions that shape Reddit?
- smtucker 12y agoI personally like the mess. If Reddit ever got "cleaned up" I don't think I would ever return.
- DanBC 12y agoNSFW also images of deliberate self harm Interesting that they mention goatsac. He helps moderate /r/cuttersgonewild - a sub reddit that reposts images from /r/selfharmpics and adds sexual language. Admins have been told, many times. They don't care. On Reddit it is fine to take a vulnerable person's image, add sexualising language, and repost it to a different sub. To view /r/selfharmpics you need to change your settings to stop subs showing you custom CSS. For some reason /r/selfharmpics blanks the display. See this example: Original post to /r/selfharmpics http://www.reddit.com/r/selfharmpics/comments/2zbipf/nsfw_bruise/ http://www.reddit.com/r/selfharmpics/comments/2zbipf/nsfw_br... Repost to /r/cuttersgonewild http://www.reddit.com/r/CuttersGoneWild/comments/2zef7c/daddy_spanked_her_but_its_self_harm_because_she/ http://www.reddit.com/r/CuttersGoneWild/comments/2zef7c/dadd... (The Imgur header text is confusing. It's a bug[1] caused by /r/selfharmpics blanking the display in CSS.) I've seen users send multiple PMs to suicidal young people telling them to just kill themselves. The users report the PMs; they block the account; they take screenshots and message the admins -- nothing happens, even if that account has messaged multiple people telling them to kill themselves. Ask someone to upvote a post in a different thread? Fucking instaban.