5 ms·
Why Our Brains Love High Ceilings
- danieltillett 12y agoWhat I find more interesting given how much people love high ceilings why they won’t pay the extra cost of having them? What is stopping the market supplying what people want?
- aklemm 12y agoCost. Everybody wants steak, too, but only hamburger can be afforded every day.
- danieltillett 12y agoIt must be more than straight cost since properties with high ceilings sell for a premium over those with a low ceiling. The demand is there and customers seem willing to pay, but the market does not seem to be meeting that demand (at least in Australia).
- Spooky23 12y agoLow ceilings in nice houses started in the 70s when energy costs went up and building styles changed to boxy, "sealed" environments. Low ceilings are more efficient from an HVAC POV. People like high ceilings, but it's a "nice to have" for most people. Also that like changes from time to time -- in the 80s, old buildings with high ceilings were looked down upon. Also, new construction costs have escalated so much that new homes are stripped to the bone in most cases. Your $500k house will have a $50 "builder grade" faucet, for example.
- danieltillett 12y agoIn Australia it has created houses that did not need AC to houses that are unliveable without AC. I know in my area a property with high ceilings will sell for a premium over one with low ceiling. It is really interesting to see this effect in properties built around the change over time where the older property is 5% more expensive than a similar property a few years younger but with low ceilings.
- Spooky23 12y agoThe way we do certain things is pure madness. Commercial buildings are the same way. I had the pleasure of working in a refurbished school converted into offices... Being able to open a window in a room with 15' ceilings was amazing.
- empressplay 12y agoOne of the things I loved about moving to Australia was all of the houses with 10 or 12 foot ceilings. I live in a place with 12 foot ceilings now and I love it. I definitely find I feel more calm and relaxed.
- danieltillett 12y agoThese are almost only ever found in old houses (pre 1970). The reason for high ceilings is cooling - Australia in general is a pretty warm place and cooling is ever a problem. I live in a property that was built in 1929 and it has 11 foot ceiling and is cool enough in summer that I don’t have air conditioning. After 1970 the regulations were changed and all the houses were built with 8 foot ceilings to save money. I hate these low ceilings as they feel totally oppressive.
- ars 12y ago> 8 foot ceilings to save money. Does that really save all that much money? Seems like it would be only a percent or two extra.
- ams6110 12y agoSaves nearly 30% on drywall/plaster and paint, at least.
- ars 12y agoSure, but drywall/plaster and paint are a tiny tiny fraction of the cost of a house.
- bengoodger 12y agoHaving just raised the ceiling in my house, there are a variety of things. Taller walls tend to come with taller windows. Not just more glass... sometimes whole extra windows (transoms) which cost almost as much as the much larger ones below. Taller cabinets or soffit details to receive them. More elaborate trim work. etc. For a flipper or a production builder every dollar is saved because it adds up in the end. If there's a high ceiling it's because it's been determined to command a good profit.
- cma 12y agoIf low ceilings were more expensive than high ceilings, and photos/videos of creative people in their high-end design studios working on marketing campaigns, feature film, graphic design, and photography were always in low-ceiling'ed spaces rather than wide open exposed beam converted warehouses, etc. that we see today, the study might observe the opposite effect. And the same article might be written saying low ceilings are better for creativity because they are cozy and bring potent genetic memories of the kind of small hand built shelters early humanity evolved with. Probably not, but just a thought.
- fractaled 12y agoSo, to paraphrase, "if things were not as they are we could come to a different conclusion". Yes, that is a thought, it was not worth writing down though.
- _greim_ 12y ago> ...it was not worth writing down though. I disagree. Nature versus nurture is a difficult but interesting topic. Is our preference for high ceilings caused by culture and experience, or is it something we're genetically predisposed to? It seems like it would be a hard question to answer, but that doesn't mean it isn't worth thinking about.
- dang 12y agoPlease don't say rude things to other users on HN, even when you consider a comment bad. It only makes the site worse for all of us.
- cma 12y agoI was basically saying maybe the cause for the creativity increase in test subjects is due to a cultural association of high-status creative occupations rather than because the extra head-space tingles our neural spatial exploration networks. In the alternate "high ceiling'ed places yield lower creativity" world, maybe we would say of the same exact fMRI study that obviously the neural spatial exploration networks are being overloaded by processing the tall room, hindered from devoting neural energy to the creative tasks at hand like they can so efficiently in the low-ceiling rooms, or some other story.
- ttty 12y agoNow relationate the ceiling height in countries with something like creativity, open mind...
- wrongc0ntinent 12y agoAlways thought there might be an evolutionary link to preference for literal headroom. Won't speculate which direction a study on this might go, but there are plenty of reasons to suspect a link.
- MiguelVieira 12y agoThis was covered in "A Pattern Language" decades ago, under Ceiling Height Variety: > the mere fact that the ceiling heights vary, allows people to move from high rooms to low rooms, and vice versa, according to the degree of intimacy they seek — because they know that everyone correlates intimacy with ceiling height. > According to this theory, the effect of the ceiling height is not direct; there is instead a complex interaction between people and space, in which people read the different ceiling heights in a building as messages, and take up positions according to these messages. They are comfortable or uncomfortable according to whether they can take part in this process, and can then feel secure in the knowledge that they have chosen a place of appropriate intimacy.
- mhomde 12y ago"A Pattern language" is such a great book, its' a shame its kinda forgotten by many these days. Whenever I talk to an architect I ask them if they've read it and I've yet to get a "yes". Anyways, highly recommended, if nothing else to get insight in human patterns regarding living spaces and communities
- err4nt 12y agoMy dad isnt a giant, but he's 6‘4“ and he sometimes feels the need to duck when going through doorways. I'm not as tall as him, but watching him reflexively stoop below obstacles hanging from the ceiling has made me think around headroom a lot. Headroom and legroom were also deciding factors in every single car purchase we ever made. What good is a car you dont fit into?
- xahrepap 12y agoI'm 6'7". I would say I like tall ceilings because I'm sick of hitting my head on chandeliers and ceiling fans. :) The funny thing is, I've noticed it doesn't matter how tall the ceilings are, but they always screw up the stairways in homes. I always have to duck to go down stairs. My house has 8 1/2 foot ceilings in the basement. I have to duck just as much as I do in houses with shorter ceilings. Or so it seems.
- vq 12y agoI'm 1.95 and I almost always duck slightly when passing a door, even when there is space and no threshold. Its like a bad habit. I'm lucky when it comes to cars, most cars I've driven has been alright when pushing the seat all the way back, if I'd been slightly taller it would've been a different story.
- nullc 12y agoOh it has FMRI results. I wonder what dead salmon think of high ceilings? ( http://prefrontal.org/files/posters/Bennett-Salmon-2009.pdf http://prefrontal.org/files/posters/Bennett-Salmon-2009.pdf )
- agumonkey 12y agoIs it the ceiling or the closed environment ? As a kid I loved to be tucked in the smallest space, it felt like a nest (some times, very weirdly, I even fantasized about sleeping in a big drawer, inside a cupboard). All dimensions mattered. Would people relax in a low ceiling with a very very long (or large or both) room ? Ceilings bring me to our relationship with verticality. We don't experience large vertical dimensions the same way we do with horizontal ones. IIRC system theorists argued we were wired differently to perceive dimensions because of gravity.