3 ms·
> What I assumed and is true is that healthcare is more private in the US than in Scandinavia, which it is. You're ignoring the fact that US poor get govt heal
by anamax 17y ago
> What I assumed and is true is that healthcare is more private in the US than in Scandinavia, which it is.
You're ignoring the fact that US poor get govt healthcare. Unless you want to argue that said govt healthcare is better than the private healthcare that the rest of us get, the US has "govt healthcare or better" and more stuff. By cohort, our poor people have govt healthcare and more stuff than yours and our richer people have better than govt healthcare and even more stuff.
Which gets us to the question of how our govt and private healthcare compares to yours, because the "more stuff" conclusion seems pretty solid.
> Retail spending however will not as you don't buy healthcare as a retail good.
What is the basis for your claim that healthcare can not be a retail good? You may not think of healthcare as being available as a retail good, but I see it in stores and the like. I happen to received an advertisement for a "get an MRI to see anything interesting is happening inside you" service in the mail today, and that sort of thing is reasonably common.
Surely you're not going to argue "necessity", as food, clothing, and shelter are both necessities and retail goods.
> if you get continuous preventive medicine you won't get as much cancer
Oh really? We just started to see vaccines for a common form of cervical cancer, and that was a first. How about some supporting evidence. Be precise - what types of cancer and what kind of healthcare. (Note - precancerous growths are not really pre-cancerous - they're early stage, as evidenced by the fact that the success in treating them is evaluated the same way that we evaluate other cancer treatments.)
> The other flaw in the whole "cancer survival is higher so healthcare must be better" argument is that although cancer is a very important illness it is far from the only important one and not even the major cause of death.
I didn't say that cancer survival rates were a decisive argument. I said that they were more relevant to the healthcare quality argument. I'd be happy to see more and better data, but see no reason to assume anything about that data before it shows up.