5 ms·
It seems to me this list, while having positive ideas, reeks of condescendence. it's mostly about how you are "much better than everybody, that's why you have t
by raverbashing 12y ago
It seems to me this list, while having positive ideas, reeks of condescendence. it's mostly about how you are "much better than everybody, that's why you have to play cool with everybody"
What is missing is a healthy dose of "why do you think your ideas are better than everybody else's?"
Readability is mostly subjective. Code quality, maintainability, etc, are mostly subjective as well.
So don't give me that BS "I'm just trying to get the best code possible" when it's your opinion
Sure, I'm not saying that something like xx = strinvcatpfr(yy * zky_eng) can't be improved, but beyond a certain point it's mostly about taste and endless nitpicking
- mhomde 12y agoI wouldn't say that those things are "mostly" subjective, that sounds like a defensive argument. I'm pretty sure there are good objective metrics both for readability and maintainability, they might not be the only aspects but calling it subjective is going too far. For instance maintainable code could be said to minimize side effects, be somewhat modularized and be as compact as possible while being readable. I find it hard that anyone could claim the opposite and be right "as a matter of taste"
- raverbashing 12y ago"I'm pretty sure there are good objective metrics both for readability and maintainability, they might not be the only aspects but calling it subjective is going too far." I think you explained better what I mean. I'm not denying the good objective metrics (for example, one of the aspects would be following Pep8 in Python) But beyond that it's mostly about subjectivity. So, evaluate on the objective metrics as much as possible, but don't waste my time saying that "A is better than B" when it's mostly a subjective aspect
- i_s 12y agoThis is very true. My brother just told me about a class he took on C# in which the teacher gave him a C on an assignment because of 2 things: 1) he had a using statement that reached far into a library, and 2) he used the "var" keyword. The program was correct otherwise.
- i_s 12y agoThere are some things about software that are objective, such as simplicity. Rich Hickey talks a lot about this. http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy
- raverbashing 12y agoSimplicity is never simple And is most often ruined by the real world and its exceptions