4 ms·
Thank god...Of the big cities I've visited as a tourist, Rome was the one that most quickly lost my interest. The architecture and history is of course amazing.
by danso 12y ago
Thank god...Of the big cities I've visited as a tourist, Rome was the one that most quickly lost my interest. The architecture and history is of course amazing...but after more than two days of seeing the same architecture, over and over...I just had to get out. I don't know how many other Italians feel like this, but what one resident told me stuck with me: "Yes, we have thousands of years of architecture and art, but very little of it is ours [i.e. created by the current generation]"...I know the OP discusses a project that is on the outskirts of the old city, but if it becomes a successful reality, maybe it'll spur additional creativity and development.
In New York, it's always distressing to see landmark buildings get paved over for condos, and even the High Line has lost a small bit of its appeal with all the new high-rise condos sprouting around it...but after visiting Rome, I had a much bigger appreciation for the vitality that comes with change...and in the five years I was there, the good seemed to at least even out the bad. The High Line was probably the best change. There was a time when 7-11s threatened to take over the city, but when I left, the location on St. Marks Place was shuttered after less than a couple or so years. Hell, even the Apple Store in Grand Central ended up being a good thing...until it opened, that part of the Terminal was inaccessible to anyone who wasn't a guest of the overpriced restaurant that was there.
- yulaow 12y agoThe problem is, here in Italy, we are over-defensive towards the "artistic soul" of a city, often refusing to modernize some areas just because a lot of people think it could "ruin" the artistic soul of the whole place. Another example is in Turin where there was a battle to try to stop the build of the first skyscraper because it could be higher than the Mole Antonelliana, the main monument of the city. In the end the skyscraper was built but they forced the architects to make it high just some meters below the height of the Mole. And still today there are protesters who say it ruined all the city. Trying to modernize even some peripheral areas of Rome will be really hard.
- pesenti 12y agoYou could say the same for Paris, Venice, Prague, etc. I feel the opposite of you: these cities fill me with a sense of beauty that no modern architecture is able to match. And their urbanism, centered around piazzas and dense walking centers with low rise buildings, is so much more human and enjoyable than any American city. It makes me wonder what we have learned in the past 300 years....
- bluthru 12y agoWe learned that the automobile industry will warp our built environment and perception to sell people cars.
- gaadd33 12y ago> These suburbs are dominated by huge, gray, unattractive public housing projects. I'm guessing the above commentator was referring to the parts of European cities outside of the historic city centers. It seems very similar in the few German cities I've wandered around extensively, you have a great walkable low rise center with lots of mixed use and then just bland same looking housing blocks outside of that. The European city centers tend to be far better than their American counterparts but I would argue the suburbs mentioned are worse architecturally.
- davidw 12y agoVenice actually does feel a bit more monotonous to me, even though you can clearly see different period styles. Most of Venice's history happened in a relatively shorter time frame than many Italian cities. Here in Padova there are everything from Roman ruins (and they've dug up even older stuff) to modern buildings. Venice has none of the Roman architecture because it got its start much later.
- carlob 12y agoActually this is much more true of Paris than Rome. Paris was basically all rebuilt in the same period of time with ideals of uniformity. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Paris http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Par...
- prawn 12y agoParis isn't too bad. The Louvre Pyramid, Centre Pompidou, much of Palais de Tokyo (e.g., National Museum of Modern Art in Paris), Parc de la Villette, Musée du quai Branly. I think it's inevitable that any international city with loads of history will struggle to find opportunities for urban renewal that reaches the typical tourist.
- Red_Tarsius 12y agoI hear you man, I'm Italian and sometimes the architecture feels suffocating. Beautiful, but... suffocating. It's like being inside a giant cemetery.
- ptaipale 12y agoAt least it is an often beautiful cemetery.
- davidw 12y ago> the same architecture It's not, though! It's over 2000 years of architecture, and there are a lot of different things that have happened in that time. Granted, like anywhere, certain kinds of architecture are more represented than others, but still, there's a lot going on there. I don't particularly like Rome as a city - it's too big, noisy, chaotic and loud for my tastes - but as a tourist destination... you could spend a year there and not see half of what it has to offer. (And not just because of strikes, inconvenient hours, or 'temporarily closed for rennovations'!)