4 ms·
Too bad this semantic desktop concept did not work out. I have two Linux laptops, and as I started reading the article, I was thinking of installing KDE, only
by mark_l_watson 12y ago
Too bad this semantic desktop concept did not work out.
I have two Linux laptops, and as I started reading the article, I was thinking of installing KDE, only to be disappointed to read that the project is basically dead.
I have written two Semantic Web books and have had some semantic markup on my web sites for about ten years, but my view of the SW is changing. Google Knowledge Graph, which I worked with in 2013, is basically a huge triple store, but different than SW because it is one giant curated repository, and not a distributed interlinked graph comprised of many sources.
- frik 12y agoAs you mentioned Google Knowledge Graph, it's based on the open Freebase ontology. Google bought the company behind Freebase and the ontology will be no more in March 31, 2015: http://www.freebase.com http://www.freebase.com , http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freebase http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freebase A rather sad demise. There is an half-hearted(?) attempt to donate some data to WikiData of Wikipedia. But given the track record of WikiData history and how different the ontology is, it looks like Freebase will go offline forever and used as internal datasource for Google Knowledge Graph. It would be great if Google would donate the data and the tools to generate Freebase to Archive.org or another open source community, so that they can regenerate the ontology on a monthly interval from its Wikipedia, and various other data sources. Given that Freebase is also what powers Siri, Cortana and Watson, maybe another corporation can help.
- mark_l_watson 12y agoI agree. I have used Freebase since Metaweb became a company. Really sorry to see Freebase disappear. Archives are runnable on a publicly available AWS EC2 image, but there will be no more community contributions to Freebase.
- pnathan 12y agoIs there a way to migrate Freebase into a community-funded project? Having that kind of knowledge set disappear is very concerning.
- lawlesst 12y agoIs there evidence that the migration to Wikidata is half-hearted? This was just announced in December. Not sure this is evidence of a "sad demise". Wikidata is non-commercial project managed by a foundation. Freebase/Metaweb was always a commercial project. Seems like this is a move towards openness if anything. Full Freebase data dumps have long been available. https://developers.google.com/freebase/data https://developers.google.com/freebase/data
- frik 12y agoFreebase updated the data dumps monthly. The main data source is Wikipedia, with many other data sources that update their content frequently. Without releasing the tools and without a community who adds/fixes the data, it will be a lot less useful/useless. It's like reading a years old printed lexicon. There is a lot evidence that the up-coming event will be a big loss - do a web search. A lot of software has been written and a lot of effort at e.g. http://schema.org http://schema.org has been made, all based on Freebase ontology with links to Freebase website. Freebase is basically the machine readable form of Wikipedia plus a lot of other data sources. It's basically like closing down Wikipedia. And then a data dump of Wikipedia of March 2015 will be useless in 2020! Do Facebook, Microsoft, Nuance, IBM, WolframResearch all have already an in-house Freebase clone. Or how do they update their databases in near future - the data used for Siri, Cortana, Siri, Watson, WolframAlpha. If not, would one of these companies be so kind and boot-strap/support an open Freebase rescue project?
- lawlesst 12y agoFreebase doesn't have an ontology in the Semantic Web sense. It's always been a specialized tool with non standard protocols like MQL. Schema.org is somewhat related but not tied whatsoever to Freebase. Wikidata is fully editable and has an ecosystem for updating data so concerns about stale data aren't valid. Since Wikipedia will be pulling from it (is already in some cases) you could argue that their will be more sunlight on the data. There's been a lot of code written against Freebase APIs (me included) but it isn't sad it's going away. It's the risk you take when relying on 3rd party services. I think your confusing short term developer convenience with a real loss of open data.
- snassar 12y agoI am not sure what your second paragraph is referring to. KDE might be many things, but dead is not a valid descriptor. It's been going strong with a new iteration based on Qt 5, the project just released Frameworks 5.8 which support compilation against Qt 5.5. In addition to Frameworks 5, the KDE project is porting their applications to Qt 5 while adding security fixes, usability improvements and new features. The KDE project has a full-featured mail client, including smart OpenPGP integration, an IDE, a modern XMPP client with OTR integration and a pretty wonderful general document viewer. There are people who don't like KDE for whatever reason, but it is far from dead. On a related note: I've interacted with several KDE developers when submitting bug reports over the years and I have found them to be really nice, responsive and respectful overall. [Edited: added valid to first paragraph]
- kasabali 12y agoHe's saying semantic desktop in KDE is dead, not KDE itself.