8 ms·
Study: Teen Cannabis Users Have Poor Long-Term Memory in Adulthood
- binarytrees 12y agoI think there needs to be more studies. I'm sure Cannabis does effect development of the brain during adolescence, but does the brain recover over a period of time or is it perm dramage.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- yebyen 12y agoNot really. He could have just ripped a huge bong only minutes ago, for all you know.
- binarytrees 12y agono doubt this study is brought to you by the letter M
- yebyen 12y agoparent said "I think we have our answer" based on misspelled "perm dramage". FUBO
- phirschybar 12y agois this really news? :)
- stevedekorte 12y agoThe difference between a medicine and a poison is dosage. "Binging Alcohol Abuse Leads To Loss Of Working Memory In Teens": http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/231267.php http://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/231267.php
- sliverstorm 12y agoMedicine dosage is critically important, but do you mean to imply any poison can be good for you in small enough amounts? No safe blood lead level has been identified. -- http://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Lead_FactSheet.html http://www.cdc.gov/biomonitoring/Lead_FactSheet.html Which, tangentially, reminds me of "Unsafe at any Speed"
- rosser 12y ago"The difference between a medicine and a poison is dosage", not "the difference between a poison and a medicine." Medicines all have a "therapeutic index", however narrow it may be. Poisons may not — and often don't.
- na85 12y agoParent is saying that some legitimate medical treatments can still have serious negative consequences if the dosage is wrong, no doubt implying that cannabis should remain in the medical arsenal.
- coldtea 12y ago>Medicine dosage is critically important, but do you mean to imply any poison can be good for you in small enough amounts? He said "the difference between a medicine and poison". Not between "poison and a medicine".
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- shillster 12y agoIt will be great when this substance can be officially studied in a clinical setting but so long as its a schedule 1 substance at the federal level, well, its worse than methamphetamine (on paper).
- tsotha 12y agoIn theory there's a procedure you can go through and get permission for a proper clinical study. In practice it's nearly impossible to get the approvals you need.
- tptacek 12y agohttp://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=000884 http://medicalmarijuana.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourc... (Also, in what way is cannabis worse on paper than methamphetamine?)
- MichaelGG 12y agoIn the US, methamphetamine is Schedule II, and legal to prescribe (indicated for use in ADHD or obesity, trade brand Desoxyn). Pot is Schedule I, indicating no medical use and strictly prohibited.
- arasmussen 12y agoI find it really interesting that this jumps to the top of Hacker News. I wonder if it's because: - This study is self-serving for people who are anti-marijuana or - Hacker News users tend to be interested in or users of marijuana and find this study concerning I'd guess a bit of both but more the latter since the Hacker News community tends to be quite liberal.
- magic_beans 12y agoExactly why it should be illegal for ADOLESCENTS. Not for adults over the age of 18.
- na85 12y agoJust in case you're not aware, the brain doesn't magically become fully-developed the instant you turn 18.
- meepmorp 12y agoNo, but you do become legally responsible for your own health and wellbeing in significant degree. You're able to move out on your own, join the army, smoke, etc. You're also at an age where you can make informed decisions things that may affect you in the future, one of which is possibly causing yourself some level of impairment in exchange for using a drug.
- Crito 12y agoIf we allow 18 year olds to move out on their own and take up spelunking and basejumping as hobbies, I think we'll be okay if we trust them with a little weed.
- paulhauggis 12y agoI'm good with this, as long as you also don't expect the tax payers to pay for your medical bills when you have medical issues due to your long-term MJ usage.
- bdcravens 12y agoHeart disease, commonly caused by tobacco use and overeating, is the number one cause of death in the US, and probably has excessive health bills associated with it. If a person is injured in any way due to their consumption of alcohol (wreck, twisting an ankle, liver damage) they should likely have to foot the bill.
- chrisbennet 12y ago"I'm good with this, as long as you also don't expect the tax payers to pay for your medical bills when you have medical issues due to your long-term Sedentary Lifestyle." Fixed it for you. ;-)
- johndevor 12y agoAn excellent book on the topic of drug abuse is Gabor Mate's, In the Realm of Hungry Ghosts. He makes a convincing argument that the majority of drug users are struggling with severe early trauma. Given this study and Mate's book, it may just be that traumatized people are looking for ways to forget. They could be seeking the forgetfulness as exactly what they want. This is different from saying that memory loss is necessarily a bad, unintended consequence.
- jMyles 12y ago> Young adults who abused cannabis as teens performed about 18 percent worse on long-term memory tests than young adults who never abused cannabis. Wonderful. Another study with no basis for distinguishing causality from correlation. I bet you can randomly select a subgroup of 18-percent poorer performers and find that they have all sorts of things in common, from diet to exercise to presence or absence of parents - as well as bizarre factors like who was born on a Tuesday. There are probably dozens of markers that both correlate with these kinds of results and also plausibly suggest an explanation. > “It is possible that the abnormal brain structures reveal a pre-existing vulnerability to marijuana abuse,” Smith said. “But evidence that the longer the participants were abusing marijuana, the greater the differences in hippocampus shape suggests marijuana may be the cause.” What?! No it doesn't. It suggests quite the opposite: that people with greater abnormality tend to use marijuana longer. I suspect that, now that medical cannabis is widely available and somewhat widely used in the treatment of childhood maladies, we may begin to see, in the next decade or so, results based on much sounder science simply because of the availability of higher quality sample groups.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- anonbanker 12y agoat the time of this reply, this was the furthest-buried response, downvoted to very faint grey. Disgusting.
- readme 12y agoOne would assume that the reader of such a study would already know the flaw of correlation vs causation. It is taught when we learn how to interpret the results of experiments. This study however does not stand by itself. There will be more, if there aren't already, and all they are doing is backing up the conventional wisdom about the effects of marijuana. It definitely makes you forget. I grew up with two parents who smoked it, DAILY. They remembered nothing. Seriously.
- xalloc 12y agoWhen people don't like the result of a study, the very existence of "causality" all of sudden turns into a point of contention.
- lewaldman 12y agoYeah... being there, I'm like... Wait... about what we were talking??
- Will_Do 12y agoThis seems to be a simple correlational study with the added bonus that abnormal hippocampi is also correlated with pot usage. There isn't even an attempt to establish any sort of causality here yet the article uses the word 'affects'.
- trjordan 12y ago“It is possible that the abnormal brain structures reveal a pre-existing vulnerability to marijuana abuse,” Smith said. “But evidence that the longer the participants were abusing marijuana, the greater the differences in hippocampus shape suggests marijuana may be the cause.” Correlation, sure, but correlation with length of usage. Definitely a more interesting angle than simply usage <-> deformation.
- dmicah 12y agoIt's a bit difficult ethically to assign one group of teenagers to the marijuana group and one to the clean group...
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mattbgates 12y agoPrescription drug users also experience memory loss and poor long-term effects. Though I did smoke quite a bit when I was younger.... uh... forgot what I was gonna say ;)
- rjurney 12y agoSometimes I wonder what a booze/pot/acid/ecstasy free me would be like. Binged on all of them as a teenager. Would I be 10% smarter? 20%? More? Better moods?
- giarc 12y ago"n of 1" story. One summer between semesters at university, my room mate and I really took up smoking weed. After about a month or two, I really noticed a difference in myself mentally. Took longer to think things through, many more "That was stupid moments" etc. I decided to stop then and it all seemed to go back to normal.
- roneesh 12y agoYou know son, when I was younger, I kept to the straight and narrow, and it made me who I am today. looks back on life with regret
- AceJohnny2 12y agoUgh. I'm all for legalization, but the public discourse has skewed the risk perception of it. OK, it may not be as bas as alcohol, but that certainly doesn't make it harmless. For people who have access, I highly recommend this review article from June 2014 in the New England Journal of Medicine, arguably the most respected scientific medical publication in the world, which goes over the published scientific litterature about Marijuana: bottom line, it's not as innofensive as some make it to be, and adolescents are most at risk. Caveat Emptor. http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMra1402309 http://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMra1402309 (personally, I do believe it should be legalized for policy and social reasons, but that doesn't mean I think it's biologically harmless)
- mlmonkey 12y agoThe problem is: the USG prevents research in the area. It is extremely hard to get permission from the DEA to research the effects of MJ. I don't believe anyone is claiming that MJ is harmless; but that overall, MJ's harm is lesser than the harm caused by alcohol or tobacco. Teens are already known to be more susceptible to chemical substances because of their developing brains, so this study doesn't seem to be very surprising.
- tptacek 12y agoIs that actually true in the past decade, or is it, like, true, man? (We should end cannabis prohibition, and are obviously in the process of doing that, but I'm having no trouble turning up tons of recent cannabis research studies.)
- DanBC 12y ago> tobacco Why would cannabis be less harmful than tobacco? The smoke from each is roughly the same, with the obvious differences being nicotine in tobacco and cannbinoids in cannabis. Maybe cannabis smokers smoke less frequently than cigarette smokers; but maybe they inhale the smoke deeper and hold it longer. It's a bit frustrating that anyone who expresses any concern about cannabis is written off as a propagandist of an oppressive government. (I'm pro legalisation)
- inthewoods 12y agoI'm sorry what page am I on? What is this website?
- roneesh 12y agoThis from the medical journal "Duh".
- datashovel 12y agoI'm not saying this to try to discredit this or any other study, but I think it would be appropriate for publications, universities, hospitals, doctors whose names are on studies to disclose affiliations. Especially with contentious issues like marijuana. After a brief Google search I found other studies where this same doctor (John Csernansky, MD) has linked marijuana use to "Schizophrenia-like Brain Changes". http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/818082 http://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/818082
- swatow 12y agoHow is that an "affiliation". Isn't it natural that people tend to publish on the same topic?
- datashovel 12y agoLike I said in the original comment, I'm not trying to discredit anyone or even this particular study. I'm simply seeking a more deliberate model of transparency. That also goes for studies who may claim that marijuana is healthy or "less harmful" than other products. This guy has over the course of several years come up with very damaging evidence that marijuana is irreversibly harmful to humans. To start with, to know who these studies are funded by would be helpful so I can know whether it deserves my attention.
- datashovel 12y agoI'm not certain this paper I'm referencing is the same one referenced in this thread's article, but the doctor was a collaborator on this: 44 healthy controls, 10 subjects with a CUD history, 28 schizophrenia subjects with no history of substance use disorders, and 15 schizophrenia subjects with a CUD history http://schizophreniabulletin.oxfordjournals.org/content/40/2/287 http://schizophreniabulletin.oxfordjournals.org/content/40/2... I'm no scientist, but it seems a little presumptuous to me to say I've come to a general conclusion about anything when all I have to investigate are 25 people. To quote the above "10 subjects with a CUD (Cannabis Use Disorder) history,... and 15 schizophrenia subjects with a CUD history".