4 ms·
In all seriousness, if California's water problems really did get to Arrakis levels of expensive where some set of people could not even afford to drink, then "
by jerf 12y ago
In all seriousness, if California's water problems really did get to Arrakis levels of expensive where some set of people could not even afford to drink, then "they move to somewhere where water is cheaper" would actually be a good outcome. It would relieve an incredibly overloaded infrastructure. (If there was going to be nowhere to move those people, that would be a different problem, but that's not the current problem. There are many places with enough water to drink.)
I mean, this is just the "planetary carrying capacity" issue applied to a smaller area. The argument still holds, so if you accept the idea that the planet has a certain carrying capacity for a certain level of lifestyle, the idea that maybe California can not support necessarily arbitrarily large numbers of people in a given lifestyle is just the same idea. Which idea is going to win out if they conflict?
- tanderson92 12y agoBut by forcing out people who cannot afford the water you are driving out essentially only lower-class people which is unrealistic. More problematically, these are specifically people for whom moving is more difficult since they lack the financial resources which makes moving possible.
- jerf 12y ago"But by forcing out people who cannot afford the water you are driving out essentially only lower-class people which is unrealistic." Remember, we're already talking about an "unrealistic" situation. In real life, the price of water is orders of magnitude away from pricing people out of being able to drink. You should expect a world where that is not true to be substantially different from this one, and uncritically examined shortcuts used to think about morality, such as simplified "class warfare" narratives with dubious applicability even to the world as it stands today, may need to be reconsidered. (In either direction, after all; what is today a minor problem could in this world be a "start the revolution!" crisis. Hard to tell; we're a long ways away from this and there's many paths from here to there.) What's the alternative? Force these people to stay in this place where the water is too expensive to drink? How is that any better than moving to somewhere where it isn't? (How did we get to that point in the first place? After all the meta-point here is that the whole conversation is completely disconnected from reality and was showboating to start with.)