10 ms·
> H1B is not a problem for America or "engineer's wages". Abuse of the system is. I'm sympathetic. I really am. I have a lot of friends working on visas, both
by humanrebar 12y ago
> H1B is not a problem for America or "engineer's wages". Abuse of the system is.
I'm sympathetic. I really am. I have a lot of friends working on visas, both now and in the past. But I just don't see the economics of this. How can adding hundreds of thousands of people in any field not depress wages, at least in the short-to-medium term.
Why do I care? I want young Americans to go into IT and engineering in general. They are becoming more interested because wages and job security have been improving (at least relative to other careers, I'm not sure about in absolute terms). If we open the valve and flood the market, wages will be affected. Maybe they won't shrink, but maybe they'll be stagnant. And maybe the job security isn't quite as good.
When I was in school, many people didn't go into IT because investment bubbles and trends in offshoring made IT work seem like a bad bet. There was skepticism that IT would provide a good long-term career. I don't see how importing hundreds of thousands of technology workers won't do the same thing.
So, again, I really want people all over the world to have opportunities, but I feel my concerns should be for the future of the young people around me. They don't have another America to move to when their prospects get stale or bleak. They're already here.
- mwsherman 12y agoThese are not engineers being “added”. They are being allowed to cross borders. What it does is equalize wages. They (outside the border) make more, and we (inside the border) make less.
- davidw 12y ago> But I just don't see the economics of this It goes beyond basic economics, so it's worth reading and learning about. > adding hundreds of thousands of people "Unfortunately", those people already exist and have skills, just in other places, where they happened to have been born. If you create bad enough policies, companies can and will go where the workers are. Also, this is not a zero sum game. There are more people and workers than 100 years ago, and yet... wages haven't cratered. > I feel my concerns should be for the future of the young people around me What is the radius of 'around you'? Your city? State? Country? Why are those people more important than those that happen to be born elsewhere? When did your ancestors come to the US? Why should people now not have the same rights they did? I'll post my link again: http://journal.dedasys.com/2014/12/29/people-places-and-jobs/ http://journal.dedasys.com/2014/12/29/people-places-and-jobs...
- nikroux 12y ago> Why are those people more important than those that happen to be born elsewhere? I can answer that one for you. Why should he as an American care about and for the future of youth in other countries? It is natural for us as humans to first take care of our own family/neighbours/country men. As mean as it sounds you cannot build a better future for your children if instead of taking care of things that will help them you take care of things that will help others' children. Its not a hard concept to grasp really. And for Americans the future of American youth is ABSOLUTELY unquestionably more important the future of the youth elsewhere in the world. You know I had this exact conversation with an Easter European friend of mine who wants to have an easier time to move to the US, but at the same time he got upset when I proposed that his country should take in African immigrants in droves. > Why should people now not have the same rights they did? Different times. Its very childish to expect the world be the way you want it to be and to throw a tantrum about it. Americans pay taxes in America and they build the country. Their ancestors did the same. Their alligence was and is to the US - it is their home. Do tell me what the artificially driving down of wages has in store for them? How does benefit the US?
- davidw 12y ago> And for Americans the future of American youth is ABSOLUTELY unquestionably more important the future of the youth elsewhere in the world Unquestionably? That's pretty strong. I live in Italy, and frankly, I'm more inclined to care about my friends' kids here than about some kid in, say, Alabama, although of course I wish all of them the best. 50 years ago, there were people who unquestionably thought the future of kids they shared a "race" with trumped that of other children. > Different times. So your relatives got what they wanted, and fuck everyone after them? Can you point to a year and month when 'things changed' and after which immigrants should keep out? > Americans pay taxes in America Uh, the other people in the US pay taxes too, and don't even get to vote.