5 ms·
But is it really? 10% of your income if you make $500 a month is a LOT, because it can make a difference between being able to afford rent/food or not. But 10%
by gambiting 12y ago
But is it really? 10% of your income if you make $500 a month is a LOT, because it can make a difference between being able to afford rent/food or not. But 10% of your income if you make 10 million is obviously huge, but is it going to have any impact on your lifestyle? No.
I love how UK does it - the fines are relatively small, but your insurance rates can go up so much you can pay a small fortune over next 3 years after getting a ticket. You get a 50 pound speeding fine,but your insurance goes up by a few hundred for years. It really really hurts.
Still, this doesn't hurt "rich" people as much - but that's what penalty points are for. If you get enough of them, you will lose your licence, rich or poor.
- kilotaras 12y agoBut the system where both pay $200 is even less fair.
- robmcm 12y agoBetter still for some fines you are forced, or can opt (as opposed to larger fine) to go on a speed awareness course. After all the point is to make people drive safely, not make money for the state.
- sago 12y agoExcept that you have to pay for the course. And the cost is the same as the ticket. The only difference is you don't get the endorsements on your license.
- RobAley 12y agoAnd this saves you a lot more money than the fine on your Insurance premiums not increasing.
- sago 12y agoI guess so. I've only had 3 points and it didn't make a difference to my premiums. I guess if you get more it might though. I'd probably take the first 3 if I got caught speeding again. Four hours taking the course would be a world more hassle.
- RobAley 12y agoOr you could, at a push, simply not speed? That way you won't get caught and won't need to deal with points, courses, fines and the like. Just a thought.
- sago 12y agoIndeed. It isn't always so simple. I'd prefer to always drive 100% perfectly with 100% awareness of speed, speed limits, road conditions, and so on. Unfortunately I err from time to time. Hence the 'if' in my statement.
- zurn 12y agoYes, 10% of income would be unfair to low earners. That's why, like the article explained, the system is based on disposable income. Precise formula is described at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day-fine#Finland https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Day-fine#Finland For big earners it still hurts, as you can read from the article (search for rhinos).
- onion2k 12y agoYou get a 50 pound speeding fine,but your insurance goes up by a few hundred for years. It really really hurts. Not if you make 10 million.
- RobAley 12y agoIt's not quite proportionate, but a millionaires premium is likely to go up more than a few hundred as they're likely paying a much higher premium already for their 200K car.
- frobozz 12y agoA system could be worked out that reduces that inequity - A tiered system like income tax would be easy to apply. A system that charges based on a fixed, high percentage of your income above a certain threshold (e.g. the living wage) would ensure that offenders lose most of their disposable income for a period, regardless of their wealth, and that they don't risk eviction and starvation, regardless of poverty. Of course, if, due to your lack of spare cash, you're stuck in your mansion, swimming in your own pool, and unable to replenish your comprehensive cellar of fine wines as you drink through them (until your fine expires), it's still not as much of an impact as being stuck in your flat, unable to buy admission to the municipal pool or buy a single can of Special Brew; but it's fairer than a flat percentage, which in turn is fairer than a flat penalty.