3 ms·
This is one of these issues where there are no "right" answers, no black & white, just shades of grey. For example, on one hand if you only allow normal names
by Someone1234 12y ago
This is one of these issues where there are no "right" answers, no black & white, just shades of grey.
For example, on one hand if you only allow normal names then you wind up hampering or completely stopping name progression/evolution/adoption. Historically names have fallen in and out of popularity every few years going as far back as records date.
Another troubling consequence of having a certain group of people signing off on names, is that those people have inherent (even unintended) biases. So for example if someone moves to Sweden and wants to use a family name from abroad that could be rejected for being too unusual even if it may be completely unusual where they're from.
On the other hand is it really in the child's best interests to be named e.g. "Hitler," "AAAAAAA," "Bobby tables," "Stupid," etc? I think if you asked people in the street they would say no most of the time.
It really is a complex issue with no right answer. I will say except in extreme cases I'd side more with the freedom for parents to choose rather than some draconian list. I think new and original names are healthy, even if not well received initially.