4 ms·
This is awesome, I really hope this guy lawyers up and takes this as high as needed until the FAA is told to go pound sand. Given that Youtube will use any exc
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
This is awesome, I really hope this guy lawyers up and takes this as high as needed until the FAA is told to go pound sand.
Given that Youtube will use any excuse in the world to slap commercials on your video without your approval[1], and even it you do put ads on your video the "money" demonstrates that pan handling is a much more lucrative use of your time.
My argument would be this a) oversteps the FAA charter because it is incidental revenue, and b) this level of regulation per injurious to the drone companies and their customers who might wish to share their perfectly legal hobby with their friends over a free video sharing service.
[1] - "Oh wait, that bird tweet sounds suspiciously like this note in this copyrighted song, take it down, or let us put ads on it."
- Zikes 12y agoAbout your footnote, Google and Twitch's automated copyright protection algorithms have made some pretty silly false positive matches in the past.
- whoopdedo 12y agoWell, a guy was sued[1] for "copying" John Cage's 4'33. [1] http://classicalconvert.com/2007/07/the-stupidest-music-lawsuit-ever-infringing-on-cages-433/ http://classicalconvert.com/2007/07/the-stupidest-music-laws...
- commandar 12y agoMy question would be is there a similar restriction on PPL holders monetizing videos recorded during their flights?
- ChuckMcM 12y agoI am not a lawyer but I would guess that it would be ok, the flight is being operated by a commercial airline and the FAA has already signed off on that. That said, one wonders if the airline would sue you for damages since you "stole" that view that they gave you as part of the fee you paid to fly, but did not re-license[1] you the right to share that view with others without their written consent. If this goes through I would not be surprised at all to hear and airline using that tactic to boost their revenue per passenger number. [1] There is a venue where this is already the norm, sports arenas. They explicitly forbid you from recording the event and re-showing it to anyone as part of the ticket "contract". Airlines just need to step up their game and add that to their terms and conditions.
- commandar 12y agoSorry if I was unclear. I meant holders of non-commercial private pilot's licenses. You see a lot of things like people posting videos recorded during their private flights online. e.g., https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPbOQZAymOU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NPbOQZAymOU I'd think this interpretation of commercial use would logically apply that as well (and be equally ridiculous).
- erobbins 12y agoSounds like it, and even worse. They'd probably pull your ticket for doing "commercial"flying with a PPL. I think we may need some case law, so hopefully some millionaire (or lawyer) who likes drone flying can push back against the FAA.
- commandar 12y agoYeah, it kind of sounds like someone that decided to stick a GoPro in their C172 would be at risk of falling afoul of this interpretation of commercial use if they stuck the video on YouTube.
- KeytarHero 12y agoDoes this mean if YouTube flags a drone video for copyright, now YouTube is the party that's breaking FAA rules because they're the ones using drone footage commercially?
- lutorm 12y agoThe FAA's definition of "for compensation or hire" as regards to flying is much stricter than that used in any other instances I'm aware of. This story sounds pretty much in line with how it works for aircraft carrying their pilots. 14 CFR 61.113 says "no person who holds a private pilot certificate may act as pilot in command of an aircraft that is carrying passengers or property for compensation or hire; nor may that person, for compensation or hire, act as pilot in command of an aircraft." Pretty much the only exception that applies widely is the next part, which says "A private pilot may, for compensation or hire, act as pilot in command of an aircraft in connection with any business or employment if: (1) The flight is only incidental to that business or employment; and (2) The aircraft does not carry passengers or property for compensation or hire." This basically means that if you are a pilot that works for a non-aviation related company, you may fly around as part of your job, for example for you and some coworkers to get to a meeting. If the company or individual makes money directly off the flight, then I'm pretty sure it will never be considered incidental. See my other posts for some things that the FAA does not allow private pilots to do. As asinine as these regs are, they are long-standing and I don't really see why having the pilot on the ground should make a fundamental difference to whether they're allowed to stand or not.