4 ms·
How does this jibe with the first amendment?
by mrfusion 12y ago
How does this jibe with the first amendment?
- icebraining 12y agoThey aren't actually banning the videos, despite eye catching headlines. They're saying that the videos, if monetized, make the drone flying a commercial activity, which is banned.
- dang 12y agoIf anyone wants to take a crack at making an accurate and neutral title for this story, we can change it.
- shittyanalogy 12y agoFAA says monetized youtube videos shot from drones are against the law.
- dang 12y agoThanks! Changed.
- jacquesm 12y agoRetroactively!
- CognitiveLens 12y agoThe FAA doesn't say the videos are against the law, or even that the flight is against the law - they're saying the flight must comply with commercial flight regulations if the video it takes is monetized. "Drones taking monetized videos are commercial flights, according to FAA"
- Someone1234 12y agoNot "banned" but excessively regulated. Subtle but important difference.
- shit_parade 12y agobanned for everyone who aren't our friends, who give us money, and who write the laws we use.
- TylerE 12y agoThat's a rather unfair characterization. The FAA keeps very tight reins on commercial operations, with damn good reason. Why do you think commercial flight is so safe?
- shit_parade 12y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#United_States_examples https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture#United_Stat... See FAA Is anyone familiar with the concept of a revolving door? The FAA isn't magically immune to this process and is in fact a good case study of the phenomenon. But continue to downvote comments not because they aren't true but because they challenge your mistakenly held beliefs.
- TylerE 12y agoI'm not saying it's not expensive, or that it's efficient. I'm saying that's it worth it.
- jpmattia 12y ago> They're saying that the videos, if monetized, make the drone flying a commercial activity, which is banned. Strange, I didn't know there was any non-commercial component to the first amendment. How did newpapers and newcasts, which are also commercial activities, escape such issues?
- Naga 12y agoIt isn't banning posting videos of flying drones, it means that if you make money off posting a video of flying a drone, it means you are operating a drone commercially, which is not allowed. It has nothing to do with speech, it is about unlawfully flying.
- smokeyj 12y ago> It has nothing to do with speech, it is about unlawfully flying The act of flying a plane becomes retroactively illegal because money was made from a video? Can we be adults and admit this has nothing to do with lawfulness and everything to do with money?
- lutorm 12y agoOf course it has to do with money, we are talking about whether or not it is a commercial activity, which is exactly what determines whether or not the flight is in violation of the FARs. I'm not sure what your point is.
- wlesieutre 12y agoThere's nothing illegal about posting and monetizing the video, the illegal part is flying the drone to shoot the video for commercial use. Unless your newspaper is delivering its newspapers by drones, they would not run into this issue.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- mdholloway 12y agoWell... it doesn't. This strikes me as a pretty unconvincing definition of "commercial activity" and obviously implicates free speech rights. (That said, if the operators facing trouble are most often getting ratted out to the FAA by business competitors, that does suggest that there's commercial activity somewhere in the background.) My read is that the agency is just trying to hold would-be drone operators at bay until it actually has clear legal authority to regulate (which is in progress).