3 ms·
The Hawkeye Initiative: Woman uses art to explain sexism to her boss
- MollyR 12y agoI wonder if she understands the role of idealized forms in art, or idealized forms fit into everything. We see them not only in comic books, but also on the covers of romance novels. We also see them in roman statues for both genders. Edit: Personal anecdote: My asian friends are big fans of bishonen tropes or mangas, which seems to be the manga counterpoint to western comics beefcake/cheesecake tropes.
- Retra 12y agoWhy wouldn't she? Idealization in art is not a problem. Her boss didn't put the poster up because it was an idealization. If he had, there wouldn't have been any concern in switching it with another idealization; he would have simply appreciated the new poster. But he did appreciate it: not for it's "sexy woman" idealization, but for the statement it made, and for being a reminder about what is important in a workplace. There is more to art than pretty pictures. Focusing on sexy pictures in the name of "artistic appreciation of idealizations" is narrow-mindedness, no matter how you spin it.
- MollyR 12y agoI agree, it's not professional. Those don't belong in the workplace, and I admire the way the guest poster went about convincing her coworkers. Sorry I wasn't clear, when I was referring to she, I meant the creator of the website, not the guest poster. >Focusing on sexy pictures in the name of "artistic appreciation of idealizations" is narrow-mindedness, no matter how you spin it. I think it would also be narrow-minded to not think that "sexy pictures" could be a component of art or art in themselves. My main thoughts are that humans didn't evolve or create things in vacuum, why do we even value art ? and where in our biological wiring do they values come from ?
- Retra 12y agoIt is just very easy to appreciate a sexually-charged picture in a superficial way. It is so easy, in fact, that I would be hard-pressed to claim there were any actual value in doing it. It's like talking to someone who wants to eat chocolate cake every day. Sure, chocolate cake is good, and we could talk for days about the nuances of cake making. But if you eat it every day saying "I just like it," you're not being nuanced. You're being crude and childish. Now, if you 'went meta' and artfully maintained an appreciation for hedonism in a way that communicates it well, then that's different. But sticking a poster in your office is not that, either, because it doesn't really communicate that intent. Putting a complementary poster next to it as an act of social awareness or even irony might.
- johnnyappleseed 12y agoI've seen this debate, that the other posters are having before. 1) Art is subjective. Some people consider soup cans art. Some other people consider pin up girls or even suicide girls art.Sexually charged pieces of art are fairly common. Some people only consider pieces of art to be artwork, if the creator intended it to be art. Essentially "art" means a bunch of things to different people. One person doesn't get to dictate an individuals values. Also putting pretension aside, there is nothing wrong with just liking something. I think adults should be free to make that distinction for themselves, and I don't expect them to defend it to me. Grown-a adults are free to believe what they want. 2) The borderline between art and products can be thin. Artists need to eat too. Sex sells period. Some things can be a product and a piece of art. This can lead to a lot of controversy as people are arguing different things. 3) Business doesn't care about art. They care about making money and not losing money. If someone finds something is offensive for what ever reason sexism,religion,explicit language,then take it down. You'll often see only very neutral business "art" for this reason. Business's don't want to be sued. There is a good parks and recreation episode about this. I expect to be downvoted for this. But the hawkeye initiative is stupid. I think Marvel should be allowed to do whatever it wants. I also think the customers should be allowed to buy whatever they want. So women are in more suggestive poses . . , so what ? Why do we need social awareness for works of fiction ? And if we do why aren't there social awareness campaign against things like 50 shades of grey, twilight, or unrealistic romance novels. The whole things screams of "Don't like what I don't like" If women like guys who are like a half naked Christopher Hemsworths, let them. If guys like women who are like half naked Scarlet Johanneson, let them. Let people like whatever they want. I don't like the hawkeye initiative passive aggressive policing of a product thru "social awareness". It's shaming people for liking what boobs ? It sounds an awful lot like religious behavior, and screw that. I didn't let the church shame me for thinking women and men are equal, and I won't let feminists shame me for being hetero and like boobs. Finally I am sick of seeing this stuff on Hacker News, I come here for the tech discussions, not art or social awareness.
- johnnyappleseed 12y agoIf you want art or social awareness, Go To Reddit