5 ms·
Are the dissenting opinions available? The FCC delayed this release, declaring that they were obligated to respond to dissenters and that they were going to ho
by rektide 12y ago
Are the dissenting opinions available?
The FCC delayed this release, declaring that they were obligated to respond to dissenters and that they were going to hold off releasing until dissenters had written up their opinions and they could prepare a rebuttal. (This strikes me as a surprisingly sensible, all-cards-on-the-table governance model, rather than an ongoing media-frenzy feeding blow-by-blow release.)
It pains me greatly knowing that Google worked hard to get a piece of this document dropped. Alas due to a lack of transparency and openness among the FCC and Google's discussion, we'll never have more than faint rumormongering to do here, but in tandem to "Broadband Internet Access Services" it seemed like there was to be another leg of openness, "Broadband Subscriber Access Services." Google not only got to know what was being proposed but got to get it dropped before the public had any idea what was under consideration here.
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/02/26/net_neutrality_rules/?mt=1426176998774 http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/02/26/net_neutrality_rules...
To me it comes off as a denigration of the public by the FCC and Google, and the scant evidence about is hard to interpret as anything but subterfuge and sabotage done at the very last minute. A more transparent process would have been appreciated- rather than this "Government as a Service" model of building regulations and applying them, I'd like to have seen the FCC use some transparency and openness in their creation of these regulations to bootstrap regulations better meeting the public mandate.
I expect most registered, official dissent is going to focus on the FCC doing too much, and that no one is going to dissent saying these protections fail to address core points. But gee do I want to know what was in the 15 "Broadband Subscriber Access Services" pages the FCC dropped at the last minute, and why Google lobbied to drop them.
- adelevie 12y ago> Are the dissenting opinions available? Yes. Keep scrolling :)
- georgemcbay 12y agoApplies not just to this thread, and virtually every HN thread ever, but all comment section threads anywhere on the Internet.
- stephengillie 12y agoExcept for those which are judiciously moderated. :)
- stephengillie 12y agoDownvote for truth! Edit: It's working!
- intrasight 12y agoPerfect :)
- smutticus 12y agoThe opinions of the dissenting FCC commissioners are exactly what you expect. They claim the FCC is engaging in over reach. I'm curious to hear more about the '15 "Broadband Subscriber Access Services" pages' you mention. Where is this mentioned? You might want to check out a recent talk @ NANOG from John Yoo. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVJV1gWYPX8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVJV1gWYPX8 IMO the questions are more interesting than the actual preso. What we got with this FCC ruling is an arrangement between the ISPs and the edge. Or you might call them the pipes and the content. It's striking to me how little discussions of the last-mile were framing the debate, or how little consumer choice was taken into consideration. According to Wheeler, my interests as a consumer end at me not having my traffic biased. When in fact, most consumers are more interested in having choice in last-mile providers, or just paying less for their Internet connectivity. In short, I'm bummed we didn't get unbundling in the last-mile. The pipes got a monopoly. Content got the right to offer services without having to pay the pipes for the privilege. Google got the right to access utility poles. Google is the interesting hybrid with a history in content, but quickly moving into pipes. None of these interests really care if you or I have choice in our last-mile ISP, or how much we pay. So Comcast, TWC and Verizon get handed a monopoly by the FCC. Americans shouldn't have to clamor and beg Google to deliver fiber to their homes. Also, what happens once Google is everywhere and they turn tyrannical? Do we need to have yet another last-mile provider invest billions to deliver service to our homes? How many Internet wires do I need running into my house to get competition? Imagine how stupid it would seem if I had multiple water pipes running into my house, or electricity wires. The FCC missed an opportunity to reframe the debate away from net neutrality and towards monopoly in the last mile. If I had choice in last-mile providers net neutralty wouldn't be an issue. If my provider treated me like crap I could simply choose another one.
- supergeek133 12y agoThe general response I've seen to that is they're encouraging more last-mile providers to be developed from Title II opening up the equipment poles/lines. Basically, making it easier for the Google Fiber types to do their thing. But then they have to live under the same rules as the big guys, and that was one of the rebuttal points. Valid or not.
- mikeyouse 12y agoHere's the 67-page dissent from Pai: http://www.fcc.gov/article/fcc-15-24a5 http://www.fcc.gov/article/fcc-15-24a5
- digitalchaos 12y agoI'm pretty sure this is the answer to what Google wanted dropped (Edge Service): http://www.telecomsense.com/2015/03/the-fcc-avoided-a-bigger-disas.php http://www.telecomsense.com/2015/03/the-fcc-avoided-a-bigger...
- tzs 12y ago> It pains me greatly knowing that Google worked hard to get a piece of this document dropped. Alas due to a lack of transparency and openness among the FCC and Google's discussion, we'll never have more than faint rumormongering to do here, but in tandem to "Broadband Internet Access Services" it seemed like there was to be another leg of openness, "Broadband Subscriber Access Services." Google not only got to know what was being proposed but got to get it dropped before the public had any idea what was under consideration here Google didn't have access to anything you didn't have access to. The got their information from the publicly available Fact Sheet Wheeler released on 2015-02-04. More detail is in Google's Notice of Ex Parte Communication they released on 2015-02-20 describing the conversations they had via phone with various FCC people [1]. [1] https://prodnet.www.neca.org/publicationsdocs/wwpdf/22015google.pdf https://prodnet.www.neca.org/publicationsdocs/wwpdf/22015goo...
- dragonwriter 12y ago> Are the dissenting opinions available? Yes, as well as the text of the order, all 5 commissioners statements are available at the link provided. > It pains me greatly knowing that Google worked hard to get a piece of this document dropped. Alas due to a lack of transparency and openness among the FCC and Google's discussion, we'll never have more than faint rumormongering to do here, but in tandem to "Broadband Internet Access Services" it seemed like there was to be another leg of openness, "Broadband Subscriber Access Services." Google's (and others') objections to what was openly stated in earlier FCC communications about the rules under development -- that they would classify both retail service provided to consumers and the "service" provided by broadband operators to edge providers (content/service providers that are not their direct customers, like Google, etc.) as separate Title II services were made public. Wheeler openly stated that this was done to provide the strongest possible basis for preventing ISPs from actions like discrimination among edge providers. The basis for the objections -- from Google, but also from others, IIRC, including other big "edge providers" -- was that classifying a "service" provided by ISPs to edge providers as a "service" might provided a basis for ISPs to charge edge providers for that service, and that classifying retail service as a Title II service provided a strong-enough basis for neutrality regulations without additionally finding the existence of a Title II service provided to "edge providers". All of this played out in public, was widely reported, and was commented on here on HN.