4 ms·
The phrase "lawful content" occurs 32 times. "No-Blocking. First, we adopt a bright-line rule prohibiting broadband providers from blocking lawful content, app
by sschueller 12y ago
The phrase "lawful content" occurs 32 times.
"No-Blocking. First, we adopt a bright-line rule prohibiting broadband providers from
blocking lawful content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices."
So I guess that means they can block thepiratebay.com, wikileaks or any content congress deems unlawful.
Couldn't these new rules be applied to the Chinese internet and nothing would change? The great firewall only filters what is not lawful.
- xyzzyz 12y ago> So I guess that means they can block thepiratebay.com or any content congress deems unlawful. Yes, but it's hardly surprising. The point of the FCC net neutrality rules is not to protect Americans from the censorship by US government -- FCC simply has no power to do that. These rules are there to protect Americans from the censorship by ISP companies.
- tubbs 12y agoHow "lawful content" is determined and how liberal they are at blocking is the real question. Obviously sites like thepiratebay.se will be censored, but how about, say, torrentfreaks? I continue to believe that none of this will be an issue if we continue to push encryption.
- diminoten 12y ago> Obviously sites like thepiratebay.se will be censored What? No they won't. Comcast/Verizon/No one is going to block sites for their customers on the Internet. They don't today, and they won't tomorrow. Except child porn. That shit gets blocked and will continue to get blocked, regularly. But that's about it.
- dublinben 12y ago>That shit gets blocked and will continue to get blocked Does it? I'm unaware of any legally binding or ISP level blocking of this sort in the US.
- diminoten 12y agoHonestly neither am I but I know the one exception to freedom (and for good reason) in the US is child porn.
- rmxt 12y agoI wouldn't be so quick to assume that ISPs in the US won't go above and beyond the "call of duty" now, or in the near future. ISPs in the UK [1] and Denmark [2] have already shown willingness to do more than what is legally required of them in order to appease the government or copyright interest groups. What makes Verizon or Comcast different from those ISPs? [1] http://torrentfreak.com/sky-broadband-starts-blocking-pirate-bay-proxies-130603/ http://torrentfreak.com/sky-broadband-starts-blocking-pirate... [2] https://torrentfreak.com/isps-agree-voluntary-pirate-site-blocks-141011/ https://torrentfreak.com/isps-agree-voluntary-pirate-site-bl...
- vertex-four 12y agoIf you have broadband from Sky, you are knowingly using a content company for your Internet provider, rather than a company that actually makes its money on providing Internet access. You don't have to do that here, unlike the US. It's very much your own fault for using such a service.
- rmxt 12y agoI agree that that seems like a bad choice, or at a minimum, one is choosing to do business with a company that has to internally negotiate an apparent conflict of interest. (Or, vertical integration if one has a generous take on the situation.) I am not so familiar with the layout of ISPs in the UK, but if other choices than Sky are present in a given locale, then, yes, the choice (I would make) is clear. However, how does the Sky situation differ from the Comcast (content delivery) / NBCUniversal (content production) relationship? Verizon, AT&T, and TWC, as far as I can tell, are only content delivery services. I don't have specific statistics on hand, but I assume that for some people in the United States, Comcast is (unfortunately) the only viable broadband service provider.
- djrogers 12y agoWhat are you smoking, and will you share? Most people in the US can chose from one or two of the handful of large ISPs - Comcast, TWC, AT&T, and Verizon. The Lucky ones can choose between two or three of them, many only have one real option. All four of those ISPs are content providers - hell, you the Triple-Play is a thing precisely because they all sell subscription TV services as well as internet and voice...
- tubbs 12y agoYour reply is encouraging. By the tone of the replies I've gotten it sounds like the censorship will not be applied liberally at all, but I'm glad this is not the case.
- duaneb 12y ago> Obviously sites like thepiratebay.se will be censored, This is not obvious. Visiting the site is not against the law. I don't believe it hosts any unlawful content.
- sixothree 12y agoI'm sure there are a few links on the HN front page that break one law or another.
- Goronmon 12y agoWas there any expectation that this wouldn't be the case?
- mattybrennan 12y agoThat's a bit of a stretch. China doesn't have a 1st Amendment
- pmalynin 12y agoWell, DPRK says "[People] also have freedom of speech, the press, assembly, demonstration and association, freedom of religious beliefs and they are entitled to submit complaints and petitions." [1] [1] http://korea-dpr.com/citizen.html http://korea-dpr.com/citizen.html
- diminoten 12y agoWhat a government says and what the law that created the government says are two different things. Okay, maybe not for DPRK, but still.
- smutticus 12y agoThis gets brought up on HN whenever these rules get mentioned. The point is that the FCC cannot stop ISPs from blocking unlawful content. If an ISP is under some other obligation to block unlawful content these FCC rules cannot overrule that. That's really all that's going on. By using the term 'lawful content' the FCC is limiting the scope of their rules, nothing more.
- wnevets 12y agoYour post makes sense and I don't wanna make it sound like I'm disagreeing with you but can't this be used as a launching point by congress to start deeming new internet content as unlawful?
- snowwrestler 12y agoCongress does not need a launching point from the FCC; Congress can pass whatever law they want, whenever they want. It might later be found to be unconstitutional, but until then it will be the law. Congress can overrule the FCC; the FCC cannot overrule Congress. That's why the "lawful" language in FCC rules does not matter much.
- sigzero 12y agoExactly right.
- smutticus 12y agosnowwrestler gets it right, but imagine if the FCC didn't have this language? What would happen if Congress or the courts ruled traffic as unlawful and mandated ISPs to block it? The ISPs would be stuck in a jam. Either they run afoul of the FCC by blocking it, or they could run afoul of some court by not blocking it. We need clear rules. With the exception of things like TV and radio, there's little precendent for the FCC telling operators what they can rebroadcast. This 'unlawful' language is the FCC's way of not addressing the issue at all. They're not defining what 'unlawful' means intentionally because it's not part of their Congressional mandate.
- duaneb 12y agoA) congress typically doesn't dictate what is lawful, that's for a judge. Congress just writes the laws. B) wouldn't this imply that ISPs now need to demonstrate that it's unlawful to block it?
- 001sky 12y agoThe executive branch has the ability to define lawful when congress provides them leeway to do so. thats exactly what these rules are about. so that's an important qualifier I would think. All three branches of government dictate what is lawful (at different levels of abstraction).
- chasing 12y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but I thought that unlawful activity existed outside of the law, anyway. Meaning, if (for example) I sell you heroin, you can't sue me in small claims court saying that I cut it with baby laxatives and therefore you demand your money back. If that's how things work, then if Comcast were to block a child porn site, the child porn site couldn't take Comcast to court over it and expect to win. Regardless of any net neutrality laws. http://definitions.uslegal.com/c/clean-hands-doctrine/ http://definitions.uslegal.com/c/clean-hands-doctrine/
- trose 12y agoYes but say you're a torrenting site that allows users to upload their original content to distribute and ISPs block your traffic because they think all torrents are illegal. Then you'd care a lot about that clause.
- chasing 12y agoPresumably if Comcast was blocking your perfectly legal torrents, then net neutrality would come into play.
- Igglyboo 12y agoThe FCC can't force them to serve unlawful content, that would be forcing them to break the law.