5 ms·
That isn't wrong, but a bit oversimplified. The difference between streaming and Torrents is that it's easy to get hold of the IP addresses of Torrent users but
by weinzierl 12y ago
That isn't wrong, but a bit oversimplified.
The difference between streaming and Torrents is that it's easy to get hold of the IP addresses of Torrent users but
difficult for streamers[1].
The situation is special in Germany because:
1. It is possible go get the name and postal addresses if
you have the IP address. The lawyer just asserts
infringement and the prosecutor will hand it over.
2. Legal fees for cease and desist letters are based on the
amount in controversy and to be paid by the addressee.
No lawsuit will be filed, just a cease and desist letter sent with a fictitious amount. People will pay out of fear,
it's border line extortion.
As far as I can tell, Torrents are dead in Germany.
[1] Assuming the copyright holders don't cooperate with the streaming services.
- happyscrappy 12y ago> It is possible go get the name and postal addresses if you have the IP address Do you have any more info on this, it sounds strange.
- efdee 12y agoThe combination of your IP and a timestamp of when it was used usually links directly to your ISP account. Your ISP probably has your address.
- weinzierl 12y agoThat's correct for the technical side. As far as I understand the legal side works like this: The lawyer files charges against a person or persons unknown. A judge decides about the request for information according to § 101 UrhG[1] (Anspruch auf Auskunft). With this document the lawyer can obtain the name, address and other data from the provider. The lawyer sends the cease and desist letter, people pay (usually) and the legal case is dismissed. [1] http://dejure.org/gesetze/UrhG/101.html http://dejure.org/gesetze/UrhG/101.html
- Kenji 12y agoYou are mistaken. In many countries an explicit, legal line is drawn between uploading and downloading copyrighted material, and some allow downloading because otherwise clicking on a link might already incriminate you. What k___ is saying is that it's the illegal upload part that moves people away from torrent.
- weinzierl 12y agoIn many countries an explicit, legal line is drawn between uploading and downloading copyrighted material, Not true in Germany, as far as I know. Nach aktuellem Urheberrecht stellen sowohl Download als auch Upload eine Urheberrechtsverletzung dar und sind als solche prinzipiell auch strafbar. [1] My translation: Under the current copyright law both download as well as upload are copyright infringement and as such, in principle, punishable. and some allow downloading because otherwise clicking on a link might already incriminate you. In Germany it does. The most prominent case, so far, was when in 2013 the law firm Urmann + Collegen sent a large number of cease and desist letters to people that used a popular adult video portal. They obtained the IP addresses from ads they allegedly published themselves. This was major news in Germany. The reason it doesn't happen more often is that going against Torrent users is much easier and less risky for the law firm. Urmann + Collegen went bankrupt in 2014 from the fall out of this case, but this is the exception. I don't have a number for 2013, but in 2011 the mentioned law firm alone sent 70000 cease and desist letters amounting 90 million Euro. What k___ is saying is that it's the illegal upload part that moves people away from torrent. I understood, but that's not relevant for Germany. Even if it was true it wouldn't matter, because the two points I mentioned give the cease and desist lawyers (Abmahnanwälte) a much easier way to go against downloaders. [1] http://www.rechtsanwaltskanzlei-urheberrecht.de/news/Abmahnung_Download_Uplo http://www.rechtsanwaltskanzlei-urheberrecht.de/news/Abmahnu...