5 ms·
I don't really think the drones are the problem. The problems are: - Lack of intelligence. The drone may be hovering overhead, but you still need local intel.
by outworlder 12y ago
I don't really think the drones are the problem.
The problems are:
- Lack of intelligence. The drone may be hovering overhead, but you still need local intel. Which is unrealiable
- The weapons are not designed for the task. A hellfire missile is not the right weapon to target a single individual. There will be collateral damage unless the target is standing in a deserted area by himself. Also, while the hellfire may be supersonic, the travel time is still significant and other people may move next to the target
- Armed drones are not really what's needed. Anarchic organizations are not well suited for a decapitation strike. The next strong person will take the leader's place. At most, you buy some time while there's a power struggle. Also, killing religious leaders turns them into martyrs.
- And last, but not least: who judged those people? Serial killers are taken to the court, which then decides their fate. Deadly force is not automatically authorized even for such dangerous individuals. Too dangerous to apprehend those extremists? Well, I imagine such a wealthy nation can figure out ways around it.
Then again, a drone is an expensive machine which keeps contractors happy. And 'lets kill that asshole' is an easier sell than investing in intelligence and long term planning.
- Lawtonfogle 12y agoAll of this ensures the organization will stay around. Collateral, incorrect targets, and martyrs enrage the populace and get recruits. Killing the head keeps the group from getting too big. Keeping them out of the courts allows for any real grievances they have to remain unheard by the voters (out of sight out of mind means they won't be fixed). This gives the MICC a great target to keep them running. I've heard that one should never blame one evil what could instead be attributed to stupidity, but I do not agree with such logic. Under that rule, there would only be stupidity.
- DanBC 12y agoPrevious killings used mass bombing (which obviously kill too many civilians) or cluster bombing (again, killing and maiming too many civilians, especially hen the bomblets were the same colour as food-aid air-dropped packages http://www.landmineclearance.org/page2.html http://www.landmineclearance.org/page2.html http://www.rawa.org/cluster2.htm http://www.rawa.org/cluster2.htm) In that context drones feel like an easy sell to the public. "Targeted!" People opposed to drone use need to show how untargeted they actually are and how international law is probably being broken.
- chinathrow 12y ago"People opposed to drone use need to show how untargeted they actually are and how international law is probably being broken." Are you kidding us? People opposed to drones do not need to show anything - except to state that flying drones over sovereign countries without being officialy at war with that country is not the way to do it. Targetet killings are not the way to do it either.
- josefresco 12y ago"Anarchic organizations are not well suited for a decapitation strike." You've been mislead if you believe ISIS and it's supporting factions are "anarchic" and don't have specialized training enough to cause disruption if personnel is lost. Along with the "guys in pickups" you see in the media, there are highly trained, well funded, experienced foreign and domestic soldiers taking part (on all sides).
- speeder 12y agoExcept the decapitation strike we are talking here are not about ISIS (That is another matter entirely now, they are effectively a state in many respects). We are talking about the places where drones are used in a controversial manner: Afghanistan, Yemen and some other countries few people heard about, in all those places, the enemies US are fighting are warlords, tribal leaders, and loose terrorist groups... They are not anarchic in the classic sense, they have hierarchy and structure, but they are like the Hydra, no matter how many heads you cut off, other will always pop up in its place.
- josefresco 12y ago"but they are like the Hydra" Over simplification of the issue. We're not talking about a single organization with a single motive. We're also not talking about replacing cogs in a wheel. These are people, with skills and experience that they bring to their organization. Eliminating leadership, or even mid level leaders can cripple an organization both psychologically and in a practical sense as they loose expertise/experience/connections etc. "the enemies US are fighting are warlords, tribal leaders, and loose terrorist groups" This is actually a very accurate description of the ground level soldiers the US is fighting. These warlards, tribal leaders and terrorist groups are funded however by much larger nation-states and those individuals and groups with the funds to pursue their agenda.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 12y ago> And 'lets kill that asshole' is an easier sell than investing in intelligence and long term planning. If that were true, how did we end up with a court to decide the fate of serial killers?
- mc32 12y agoDrones are to war what anesthesia is to surgery. It's not that people are against annihilating the enemy, we just don't want to know the dirty details. We know that there are times we'll need to eliminate an enemy -just don't get me dirty with it. This tool allows us to put fewer of our own in peril while putting out enemy at a disadvantage. Given that we are involved in conflict, neo liberal ideology has to step aside and let Realpolitik take over. So just as we don't want to be conscious when the good doctor puts us under the knife and are spared from all the guts and nasties, so do drones do the dirty bidding for us. We could all clean up dirty toilets ourselves, but we'd mostly rather have someone else do that for us. It's a job which must get done, just spare me the details.
- tomaskafka 12y agoNeither of your arguments is the problem. The real problem is a system, where it only takes three mutually self-assured groupthinkers, under stress, who have never seen a dead man, woman or child, to push a button and kill. It might seem like unhappy accidents, but under these circumstances they are inevitable, and whoever set this system up should be judged and found guilty. (The next level is that these systems grow this ugly exactly because there is no specific person responsible for that. The guilt is spread out thinly such that no one's moral sense is triggered. Exactly how the machinery of concentration camps worked, everyone is doing their job and at the end of the machine, people die). I believe that only solution to this is to have a personal moral code, and if your higher ups are ordering you to do something that you know isn't right, fk the orders. But the army know this, and attracts losers that can be brainwashed so that belonging to army becomes their only way of life. Saying no to order then means being expelled from whole your life. So they rather press the button and kill twenty mothers in Afgnanistan.
- cmdkeen 12y agoBut who was supposed to say no? The SF officer on the ground who did not have line of sight but was being told they had positive ID on military age males, weapons and no children? Or the helicopter pilots who were given a target, and who don't have the technology to provide any better or worse information? The problem is that US Forces are almost permanently on a overkill strategy where the answer to this problem was using Hellfire missiles, in the same way as dropping artillery into Iraqi towns in the 2003 invasion. Taliban dismounts from a SUV die quickly against helicopters, taking time to check the vehicles were hostile via an overflight or "warning shot" should be a valid tactic. But that is not for a specific flight commander to make.
- Bahamut 12y agoCan't speak for other MOSs, but at least for infantry, infantry are exposed to videos where people die during training - one video I remember seeing was from the point of view from an insurgent, and it showed his comrades & him launching an assault on some Marines, only to promptly run away from a hail of gunfire. The person whose perspective is seen dies quickly. I suspect that most training in the US military show such content, in order to avoid sudden shock from experiencing the situation for the first time. The US military trains as close to real scenarios as it can, so that the same decision making happens during actual combat situations. Contrary to what you might believe, the training often stresses to use sound judgment - there are many accidental casualties in war, sometimes due to miscommunication. One story that a Marine told me was that in Afghanistan, while he was on watch at a vehicle checkpoint, a truck was speeding towards his post - his battle buddy and him were signaling to the driver to slow down/stop. The driver did not stop - they were forced to try to incapacitate the vehicle, which ended up killing the driver. There were no explosives, but you cannot know which vehicle has any - this is part of the fog of war. Contrast that with two recent Navy Cross awards for two Marines who died in the same situation in Iraq, except the vehicle was a suicide machine meant to do significant damage to the base. War is not black and white - in war, the only thing people care about is helping get their buddies home safely. When it comes down to it, almost every person made the choice to be ready to sacrifice if necessary to achieve this. It is at least an honest choice when contrasted with those who have no experience with such a world commenting without the proper perspective.
- shangxiao 12y agoLet's not ignore the disgusting gun-ho attitude of these "pilots" who are looking for any excuse to pull that trigger and ignoring any possibility that these were civilians. "I was hoping we could make a rifle out. Never mind." "Yeah, review that shit . . . Why didn’t he say possible child, why are they so quick to call fucking kids but not to call shit a rifle."
- shangxiao 12y agoI guess the people who downvoted this like to ignore the facts hey.