4 ms·
They may not look pretty, but they work a lot better than the over-designed crud with pretty UIs. As a SysAdmin, I hope none of these enterprise vendors ever hi
by ocdtrekkie 12y ago
They may not look pretty, but they work a lot better than the over-designed crud with pretty UIs. As a SysAdmin, I hope none of these enterprise vendors ever hires a single designer.
- MrDosu 12y agoThis. This is software that is used to make money, not do something overly simple with pretty colors.
- cheatsheet 12y agoI think if you spend enough time appreciating the core functionality over the superficial form, your aesthetics change, and the superficial form that denotes quality functionality is what is considered 'better designed'. It's a bridge between design and engineering. They are often two halves of the same coin.
- skynetv2 12y agowell said. Also the author ignores the fact that changing design in enterprise sw is difficult because it impacts the user familiarity of the product they have become used to.
- ocdtrekkie 12y agoIn reality, I consider that a problem in the consumer space too, but designers don't really care. Which is now why I just prefer to use enterprise-grade products in the home.
- lultimouomo 12y agoI laughed when I read the complaint about the "embarrassing lack of spaces"... Add the generous amount of space any fancy à la page UI needs and try to keep the all the functionality these apps have, you'll need way more than a 4k screen for it to fit the screen. No, less is not always better.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> Add the generous amount of space any fancy à la page UI needs and try to keep the all the functionality these apps have, you'll need way more than a 4k screen for it to fit the screen. Exactly. Reading Tufte's books I learned that if you are aiming for actually useful instead of just pretty, you'll end up with denser information display.
- tablet 12y agoSo you think this is OK? http://cl.ly/image/0a0r1P1m0b2U http://cl.ly/image/0a0r1P1m0b2U
- smcl 12y agoI don't think that is quite what the parent was referring to. I think it was more "space" as in "have a clean simple uncluttered UI with ample padding around the edges" (see point 3 here: https://medium.com/@erikdkennedy/7-rules-for-creating-gorgeous-ui-part-1-559d4e805cda?hn=1 https://medium.com/@erikdkennedy/7-rules-for-creating-gorgeo...) not literally a lack of spaces between elements.
- lultimouomo 12y agoI obviously meant general page whitespace; but you are right, the particular sentence I quoted was referring to the screenshot you posted, in which there is gratuitous (and horrific) lack of space. I still think that my comment is appropriate for the general stance of the article, but the downvotes were undeserved (I upvoted you, for that matter)
- 12y ago
- jchendy 12y ago> I hope none of these enterprise vendors ever hires a single designer. There are many aspects of design other than visual design (aka prettiness, as you call it). Usability, workflows, integration with other tools, onboarding process, documentation, etc, etc all fall within experience design. I'm not familiar with the tools mentioned in this article, but if a UX designer has never worked on them, I guarantee there's lots that can be improved without making them any more pretty.