3 ms·
"in a large company “fear of failure” inhibits speed and risk taking while in a startup “fear of failure” drives speed and urgency." I thought the conclusion f
by nostrademons 12y ago
"in a large company “fear of failure” inhibits speed and risk taking while in a startup “fear of failure” drives speed and urgency."
I thought the conclusion from that was so obvious that Steve Blank was surely going to talk about it later in the article, but he didn't...
In a startup, the "default" state - if you do nothing - is that you run out of money and starve. That's why fear of failure drives speed and urgency.
In a big company, the "default" state - if you do nothing - is that you collect a paycheck and live a relatively comfortable life. That's why fear of failure inhibits speed and risk-taking.
I recall a comment or an essay of PG's where he said that poverty seems to be a necessary condition for startup success, and without that incentive, startups frequently die. (There are counterexamples like Evan Williams or Travis Kalanick, but in both those cases they picked up their habits while fighting for their previous companies' lives.)
I read that and thought "It isn't so!", and then got a job at Google hoping to do the intrapreneur thing, but with the risk/reward balance slanted toward the big company. I found that there were managers willing to give me nearly carte blanche for finding & fixing new problems, but that didn't mean that I could actually launch or grow anything new or revolutionary. The problem wasn't actually with me or with management or with any corporate structure, it's that for a new idea to take root, you need many peoples' help, and each one of them needs their incentives biased against the status quo. That's why Silicon Valley works: there is a critical mass of people here who get nothing if the startup(s) they back don't take off.
- analog31 12y agoI think it can be even worse than that. What I've often seen is that "failure" isn't even real business failure, but merely your boss having your idea shot down by the boss above him. The risk is mainly emotional. People train themselves to play an elaborate political game to advance their ideas.
- s73v3r 12y agoThe other part being that, in a startup, you'll be rewarded if things go well. In a corporate environment, many times you won't be.
- dmichulke 12y agoYes, start-ups die if they are not meritocratic. Big companies are only prepared to give you X% of your annual salary as a bonus if you're good (with X < 15%). So the bigger the upside of your "innovation", the more you will find the company and its reward model unfair and leave. So big companies lose the best employees and so have to buy back innovation by buying start-ups.
- IanCal 12y agoWhen designing any system that involves people, it's vital to see what behaviours optimise your rewards. Usually there is some general process / overall plan you're supposed to follow: Follow the plan | Don't follow the plan Things go well | reward | unknown Things go badly | no punishment | punishment That is a setup which encourages people to follow the plan even if they think it's not the best one. Something else which makes this quite difficult is that you never know what would have happened if you'd jumped columns.
- carrotleads 12y agoI keep thinking about why I am not taking as much risks as I should and PG's poverty factor could be the issue. I am not poor and have a family with a bit of savings cushion. So does that mean I need to freaking blow my savings before I start giving approval to myself to start taking some big bets..
- thaumasiotes 12y ago[Malcom McLean's] net worth in 1955 was $25 million -- the equivalent of $180 million in 2004 dollars. Asked later whether he had considered ways to shelter some of his wealth from the risks of entering the maritime business, his answer was an unequivocal "No." McLean explained: "You've got to be totally committed." ( The Box, http://www.amazon.com/dp/0691136408/ http://www.amazon.com/dp/0691136408/ )
- wpietri 12y agoProbably not. I think panicky entrepreneurs aren't particularly good either. The worst case for most SV entrepreneurs is "have to go get a job" or "have to move in with family or friends for a while". When you're young and single, that's an ok outcome, especially since you have a level of control that matches your level of risk. It's a very different calculus with a spouse and kids. There if you blow up, you don't want your family to end up homeless. And you don't want your spouse worrying about ending up homeless, either. Since your spouse doesn't have control over the business outcomes, it can be much more stressful. I'd encourage you to jointly split your cushion into "can gamble with" and "won't gamble with". Then if you want to do a startup (or join something early enough that they can't pay you properly) the deal you make is that once you've burned through the ok-to-gamble money, you go back and get a real job. I promise you that watching your bank balance tick down is going to create significant motivation, especially if your #1 investor (that is, your spouse) is getting weekly status reports on the business progress.
- SyneRyder 12y agoI assume your last sentence is facetious, but in case it isn't: Do Not Do This. Bad idea. People suggest it will light a fire under you and be a motivator - but it can also paralyze you with anxiety so that you end up getting nothing done, like the deer frozen with fear in the headlights. It's a horrible place to be, and there's many business problems that can be rapidly solved with cash. (eg Don't waste hours and hours of labour if you can just buy an off-the-shelf software package to do the job faster & more cost-effectively.) Don't take risks, manage risk.
- lifeisstillgood 12y agoFirstly I think humans work on much shorter timescales such that even the imminent collapse of a startup is mid-range planning. But what makes your boss happy today is a much more important concern in your decision making. And secondly I think I get to see much worse startups and enterprises than Mr Blank. Most of my day today was re-writing some project mgmt automation to save me from nagging. It's similar code I have written in small startups and large organisations - everyone seems to think project mgmt is a Good Thing despite all evidence. Everyone will, if asked, say I should have spent the time today on those important innovations. But they all want their bug trackers filled out correctly each morning, but analyse the projects every few weeks or months. The feedback loop needs a tight time cycle for it to have a good effect on human beings. Even in startups, the time horizon for death of company has been months away. I rarely have come across projects in large or small companies that have a deadline more than a year out and usually six months. Most startups can plan on a runway that long. I think it is something else, a dedication to engineering quality perhaps, to open and transparent discussion, but somehow innovation happens in both startups and large companies. It's just in large companies it's harder to find amount at all the rest. All of which suggests one other consideration - the people lamenting the golden age of startups are suffering from a survivorship bias - the startup that grew was successful (else they could not pay Steve blank) but that means it was unusual. It is possible that most startups are also lacking in innovation, it's just the people who can lament this to Mr Blank do not see those startups in action and so think the incidence of innovative culture is more prevalent globally than it really is. Edit: tidy up a bit
- cpeterso 12y agoThe Manual (How to Have a Number One the Easy Way), the KLF's step by step guide to achieving a No. 1 single with no money or musical skills, advises: “Firstly, you must be skint and on the dole. Anybody with a proper job or tied up with full time education will not have the time to devote to see it through... Being on the dole gives you a clearer perspective on how much of society is run... having no money sharpens the wits. Forces you never to make the wrong decision. There is no safety net to catch you when you fall.“ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Manual http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Manual
- sukilot 12y agoI thought 'dole' is a a safety net
- dingaling 12y agoDole ( UK slang for Job Seekers' Allowance, JSA ) is very fickle and can be arbitrarily stopped for a number of reasons: https://www.gov.uk/jobseekers-allowance/further-information https://www.gov.uk/jobseekers-allowance/further-information For example, local to me there was some controversy when people refused a zero-salary 'job' working for a chain of discount stores. Their JSA was stopped as punishment, so they had no income. Not much of a safety net, it's actually now a policy tool to coerce people into menial and undesirable jobs, and to keep them there ( being fired makes resuming JSA difficult ).
- hansef 12y agoPoverty may be a necessary condition for "startup" success in the somewhat narrow definition of a startup common in our industry, but the idea that it's necessary for BUSINESS success is total nonsense, which is a useful thing to remember when you're feeling artificially burdened by being over 30 and middle class(!) The bulk of new wealth in human history has been created by people who already have some modicum of existing wealth, or access to it.