5 ms·
> we'll all be so happy with the obvious (in hindsight) decision to switch to USB-C. I don't think the issue is the inclusion of USB-C -- in fact, USB-C offers
by Alupis 12y ago
> we'll all be so happy with the obvious (in hindsight) decision to switch to USB-C.
I don't think the issue is the inclusion of USB-C -- in fact, USB-C offers a lot.
I think the issue is only having one connector on the entire laptop. What happens if that port fails or beaks? Your laptop stops working...
- moe 12y agoWhat happens if that port fails or beaks? Your laptop stops working... I'm not a fan of their single-port decision either, but in fairness: Every laptop stops working when the charging port breaks. No matter how many other ports it may have.
- Alupis 12y ago> Every laptop stops working when the charging port breaks That is true, however if you are using the same port for a multitude of things (plugging/unplugging USB sticks, monitors, etc...) it's going to get a lot more use, and therefore increases the likelihood of something breaking. I've broken USB ports before on laptops, usually by crushing the floating center plastic thing (USB cable gets ripped out weirdly or something), but I have other USB ports so life goes on. USB-C has the same center floating plastic bit -- just waiting for it to get broken off. DC ports tend to be pretty robust, but do break from time-to-time. Apple's solution to this was the Magsafe connector, which avoided the issue for the most part. Seems like a step backwards for laptops to now rely on a single, potentially fragile port for everything.
- riquito 12y ago> That is true, however if you are using the same port for a multitude of things (plugging/unplugging USB sticks, monitors, etc...) it's going to get a lot more use, and therefore increases the likelihood of something breaking. By design it allows at least 10000 cycles of insertion/removal. Using it 8 times a day every single day you'd need about 3.5 years to end them. It's probably ok for most workloads.
- jeeva 12y agoSpeaking from a helpdesk perspective, user-caused breakages are rarely by design.
- bashinator 12y agoAnd Apple is replacing the nigh-indestructible magsafe with a traditional plug...
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoOf course this is purely anecdotal, but amongst my friends and coworkers I've seen magsafe connectors fail at about the same rate as normal power adapters. Usually at the end where the wire goes into the wall plug brick part.
- kalleboo 12y agoYes the cheap to replace wire end breaks easily. But the expensive-to-repair computer side port is solid. You're going to see a lot more expensive computer repairs with the USB-C charging port.
- semi-extrinsic 12y agoTrue. Although I think it would be much better for durability if Apple used the same wire/power brick layout as everyone else: have the power brick in the middle of the wire, accepting 120/240 V from a standard "figure-eight" cord. Then that cord would be the one that breaks, and they cost $1 to replace. Of course this conflicts with Apple's business model...
- iSnow 12y agoAt least over here in Europe, you can attach a bog-standard 240V cord to the Apple power brick so it sits in the middle of the cord. However, this does not help if the computer-side plug does not disengage if your lovely child barrels down your living room. Magsafe has prevented a costly fall or other here.
- kalleboo 12y agoAll the Apple laptop and iPad adapters I've gotten accept a standard figure-8 cord if you just slide off the national plug. For my it's the slim cord between the charger and the machine that wears out.
- phaemon 12y agoNot if you had 2 USB-C ports, and you could charge from either side. That would be pretty cool actually.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- lobster_johnson 12y agoWhat I hear people complaining about is that the product isn't complete out of the box: You immediately have to go out and buy a hub, or at least a charger that also acts like a hub, and/or an HDMI adapter. Some of these gadgets are, for now, a little expensive -- $40 for something that used to be built in is, for some people, an insult. (I don't mind myself; I take the long view about things like this.)
- chetanahuja 12y ago("it's just an 80 dollar adapter from the apple store" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFhjDX-DUew https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFhjDX-DUew )
- modfodder 12y agoThe product is complete out of the box, just not complete for every use case. Even as a commercial editor my need for multiple ports decreases every year. Currently I work on broadcast spots with one client using one drive and dropbox. If I was on the print or web side I could get rid of that drive. I haven't used a thumbdrive in probably a year. Everything is dropbox or google drive if it's not large video files that require a raid. Two years ago I cut spots for Reebok on location using a 13" air, I have no doubt I could do the same with the new Macbook. Now I wouldn't buy the new Macbook for my main editing rig, but I might buy it to use when traveling and consulting. I don't understand people complaining about a product that was obviously not designed for their use.
- lobster_johnson 12y agoIt's complete, but most people will want and need to buy some kind of adapter for their external drives or whatever. Some of the anger seems to stem from confusion about what the new MacBook is. It's clearly a smaller version of the Air, not a replacement for the Pro.
- grecy 12y agoIf you have devices that immediately require you to buy a hug for the new MacBook, it's obvious you're not the target market, and you need to buy one of the more "Pro" ones. I.e. the one with "Pro" in the name.
- hobarrera 12y agoAlso, only one device connected at a time, and not devices if you're charging. Forget about using a mouse a these laptops.
- stephen_g 12y agoIt's intended to be used with a Bluetooth mouse (if the user wants to use something other than the trackpad). Even now, this is sort of like saying 'Forget about watching a movie on these laptops' about it since it doesn't have a DVD drive! (I was going to say 'in a little while', but really, wireless mice are so common now)
- hobarrera 12y agoHigh end mice still don't come in plain-bluetooth version. I've a couple of Logitech Performance MX and there's still no succesor (either from Logitech or an alternative from another company) that's just plain bluetooth with no dongle. > [...] wireless mice are so common now) I never made any mention of a non-wireless mouse. All highend mice come with USB dongles, regrettably.