4 ms·
What kills me is how car radios are getting touchscreens now. What good is a touchscreen in a car radio? The whole beauty of the traditional design is you can
by emodendroket 12y ago
What kills me is how car radios are getting touchscreens now. What good is a touchscreen in a car radio? The whole beauty of the traditional design is you can operate it without taking your eyes off the road.
- r00fus 12y agoAre they getting touch screens mainly to support CarPlay and Android Auto? That's a big feature IMHO. My use of the car radio is essentially to toggle it from AUX to BT. Integration of my phone would be even nicer.
- jonathantm 12y agoJust wait a year or two. You'll see configurable hardware. Aka "software wrapped in plastic" (Brad Feld) http://venturebeat.com/2012/05/22/the-maker-movement-starts-to-attract-venture-capital/ http://venturebeat.com/2012/05/22/the-maker-movement-starts-... Go through the products available at a site like sparkfun or adafruit and tell me you couldn't make some awesome customization control panel system? Larger buttons for smartphone-specific functions, some with their own small (and low-cost) discrete display perhaps?
- sago 12y agoA modular control system, featuring 100% plug and play elements (knobs, sliders, mini-displays, buttons) mountable in a range of simple chassis (19"rack, keyboard size, mini desktop box, mixing-console-size control center) that can be configured by a trivial to use piece of software and thereafter control any device (PC, tablet). I've been wanting this for twenty-five years. There are things that do some of this, but not very well, and not very cost-effectively. There is software that simulates this on a touchscreen (grr). Anyone fancy a hardware startup?
- swift 12y agoI realize this probably isn't quite what you want, but have you looked at using MIDI? A lot of modern MIDI gear is quite cheap, connects to your computer over USB, and with the appropriate software can be used to control anything on your computer. There are MIDI devices with just about any kind of physical input you could want - pots, sliders, pedals, buttons, pressure-sensitive pads, optical and sound-based inputs, and much more.
- jdietrich 12y agoThere are a variety of development boards (Livid Brain, uCApps MIDIbox) designed to allow semi-technical users to build their own MIDI controllers. It's also reasonably straightforward to configure an Arduino Micro or a Teensy to work as a USB HID interface. If you can use a soldering iron and a drill, you can build a custom controller.
- sago 12y agoAbsolutely. I've been known to break out the breadboard to that end. But soldering irons and arduinos are a level of too much... erm... wires, for what I'm thinking. Not to mention that making it control what you want takes time and debugging and perhaps a sympathetic operating system or app. How about forgetting the electronics, and seeing controllers as just another UI problem. Software, implemented in plastic. What would you want to build if it were that easy? Custom controllers for games? Custom games? MIDI Instruments? Dashboards with physical elements? Home / media center controls? POS interfaces? Hardware usability testing prototypes? Kitchen gadgets? Maybe I'd be the only market, but I think it would be a big blurring of the line between hacker and maker culture.
- darkmighty 12y agoRecent developments allow software to make the configuration itself programmable which is going to be great I think. Pressure displays (2009): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Smai_Z_galE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Smai_Z_galE . I can't believe they didn't attempt to build "pixels" of some kind though. More recently, a lot of ultrasound tech (2014): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaoO5cY1aHk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kaoO5cY1aHk . Tangible displays from MIT (2013): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvtfD_rJ2hE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lvtfD_rJ2hE . I could see any of this being feasible for interacting in a non-mobile setting (car,desktop) with some adjustments.
- newman8r 12y agoI am one of the fools who bought an optimus popularis - it's optimus lame. Also those relegendable knobs and sliders are very popular in the music industry already 0 - so it would be fairly trivial to bring it to a consumer device.
- burger_moon 12y agoI had a 2012 jetta that had this. It was complete touchscreen with only a couple basic function buttons. I found it extremely annoying to use. To make matters worse, when the flimsy screen got a tiny crack in it, I lost all control of the radio because I could no longer touch to interact with it. I guess that would be a big deal breaker from me if I had means to be in the market for a tesla. I'm not big on having everything in a touchscreen. The lexus I recently purchased uses a mouse essentially to interact with the screen which I find pleasant to use and also offers a full range of buttons for the radio and climate control. I find this to be a much better experience for myself.
- Loughla 12y agoStill, the 'mouse' seems like a poor choice. As the op said - isn't the idea of big dumb buttons that we don't have to take our attention off the road to interact with them?
- emodendroket 12y agoI have a 2012 Mazda3 and it has a knob and buttons and it works great whether or not I'm looking at it. What a concept.