16 ms·
What most people have missed is that USB allows charging and data over the same port. So you can easily get a power adapter that has a charging tip which has on
by ChuckMcM 12y ago
What most people have missed is that USB allows charging and data over the same port. So you can easily get a power adapter that has a charging tip which has on the same cord another USB-C port (socket) which you can plug into your display chain, or port replicator or what not.
In Apple's case I fully expect they will make it so that when you plug your Apple display into your laptop it also charges it since the charger is permanently connected to (or built into) the Apple monitor/display.
- cV6WB 12y ago> In Apple's case I fully expect they will make it so that when you plug your Apple display into your laptop it also charges it since the charger is permanently connected to (or built into) the Apple monitor/display. Except that this display does not exist.
- outericky 12y agoAdapters will exist for now. I think a solution to a single port (though, having more than 1 is probably better) is great. Why do we need 8 different port types? We should have one and it should do everything. But we should have 2 of them.
- Zak 12y agoI haven't seen anybody complaining about the move to a single port type. Most of us in the tech world recognize that as a Good Thing. What many of us don't like is that you have to unplug the power adapter just to plug in a flash drive unless you have a dongle.
- seanp2k2 12y agoHopefully the charger has 4x USB built in (2x normal + 2x type C)
- mark-r 12y agoI'd like to see all type C, with converter cables when necessary. Hopefully they designed it so that's possible.
- Zak 12y agoIt does not. Here's the adapter; the separate USB-C cable (one is required to use this adapter) Apple sells for $30 does not include a hub or extra ports either. I'm sure there will be some third-party option that does this. http://store.apple.com/us/product/MJ262LL/A/apple-29w-usb-c-power-adapter http://store.apple.com/us/product/MJ262LL/A/apple-29w-usb-c-...
- rbanffy 12y ago> Except that this display does not exist. Yet. Neither does the laptop, by the way. By the time it launches, I expect it'll be surrounded by a fairly decent line of accessories.
- kevincrane 12y agoGoodie, more things to buy.
- seanp2k2 12y agoJust like Thunderbolt? I'm not holding my breath, but I do think USB has a better chance of a successful accessory ecosystem.
- gambiting 12y agoBecause if anyone has ever thought that Thunderbolt would be used for all accessories they were very, very, very wrong. You wouldn't plug in a printer, or a flash drive, directly to a Pciexpress bus, would you? There's simply no need. And yet, this is pretty much exactly what Thunderbolt is. It's fantastic for things which need this kind of connector - external graphics cards, 10Gb optical network cards, RAID controllers - but not pendrives.
- JustSomeNobody 12y agoRight. Because my desire is to spend a fortune, only to have to spend another fortune to make it all just work.
- cdelsolar 12y agobecause $1299 is a fortune
- sspiff 12y agoWhile many of us routinely spend this amount of money on laptops or other hardware, the average Joe doesn't want to spend more than 600-700 euro on a laptop (which translates to up to $650 in practice). So yes, for most people, this sounds like a fortune for a laptop. I think it's actually addressed half of shortcomings of the old Pixel: 4GB of memory has been upped to a reasonable 8GB or a generous 16GB. The CPU bump is also a welcome change. Only the limited disk space is an issue. I just wished they doubled the storage (at least) and sold them with plain old Linux as developer machines. Would be a great way to get into the hearts and minds of many programmers.
- w0rmwood 12y agoIt's pretty safe to say this isn't a laptop intended for the Average Joe to purchase. They're not even aiming at that demographic, IMHO. I do agree that making it more Linux-friendly or selling a pre-installed Linux version would be great.
- ghrifter 12y ago$650 dollars is about 700 euro? Well now's the time to travel to Europe! (I suppose there is some sort of tax or import cost...?)
- sspiff 12y agoTo ghrifter (I couldn't reply to your thread): yes it's a tax thing, and also the cost associated with the EU mandated 2 year minimal warranty programs. Electronics are generally more expensive in euros than in dollars, even though the exchange rate of a dollar is still below 1.0 euro.
- higherpurpose 12y agoFor all of Apple's focus on "simplicity" and "elegance" in design and whatnot, the company sure makes you carry a shitload of ugly dongles and extra cables and adapters along with your iDevices. Wouldn't they be more elegant if they would, you know...Just Work?!
- arrrg 12y agoEh … if you need a dongle maybe it’s just not, you know, for you? What a novel concept! I practically never plug anything into my laptop except the charging cable. I suspect there are many people like me out there. This one is for use, not for you. Apple isn’t into being all things to all people, you know. Or at least their single products never are. Sometimes something is just not for you and that’s ok.
- dysfunction 12y agoThen why put a data port on it at all? Either they expect you to do everything through the cloud or they don't. If they expected enough people to plug stuff into it that it was worth putting a USB port on it, that means expect that the same people would sometimes do that while it was charging (given that these things last through a day of heavy use at best). Which means they do expect people to have to use a dongle.
- arrrg 12y agoHuh? That’s just an incoherent statement. You are inventing false dichotomies. That’s just so absurd.
- pbreit 12y agoFor something that is performed several times per day (plugging in/out) I appreciate the clear superiority of Lightning cables.
- TazeTSchnitzel 12y agoThey don't make you. Apple's approach is you do everything wirelessly. For the laggards, well, you might need an adapter or two, but it's still more portable than a thicker and heavier laptop.
- EpicEng 12y agoSo I have to purchase and carry around peripherals just to use my machine in anything but the most basic scenario? Not a fan. To be clear, I am a Mac laptop user and have been for years. I love them from a build perspective, but I don't agree with the one-port-to-rule-them-all decision.
- drivingmenuts 12y agoI didn't either, but then I looked again and realized it was the Macbook, not the Air or the Pro. The Macbook isn't exactly the choice of power-users. (Actually, seeing how underpowered it is, it's probably the choice of very patient users.)
- sjs382 12y agoBut if I have external storage plugged in (I'm copying a large file), and I need to charge the laptop, then I need to disconnect the drive in order to charge the laptop? There are countless examples where daisy-chaining these devices becomes very inconvenient.
- benihana 12y agoAt this point, I find this whole thing funny. Again. How many times has Apple done this in modern times? Remember the outrage when Apple removed floppy disk drives? Optical drives? Ethernet ports? Remember how mad everyone got when Apple replaced their old, thick connector on the iPhone 5? Nobody complains about how thin their phone is now that the old 30pin connector is no longer the limiting factor on size. Nobody is bemoaning the fact that they can't watch a DVD on their laptop - we've moved on from optical media. Nobody will even bother examining the bellyaching about this in a couple of years because we'll all be so happy with the obvious (in hindsight) decision to switch to USB-C.
- bonaldi 12y ago> Nobody complains about how thin their phone is now that the old 30pin connector is no longer the limiting factor on size Yeah, they do. Ask someone whose iPhone has just died (again) if they'd take it being a bit thicker with a bit more battery, and I don't know anyone who wouldn't make the trade. And I personally still miss living in a world where no matter where you went you were never more than 5 feet from a 30-pin cable.
- jusben1369 12y agoI understand your general point and think it holds true. However, I would say in my mind that the way Apple can decide to change their connector and suddenly make redundant a full range of downstream devices (house and car chargers, general chargers, audio equipment) is a real negative and one of the 3 or 4 things that keeps me from moving back over from Android.
- copsarebastards 12y ago> What most people have missed is that USB allows charging and data over the same port. So you can easily get a power adapter that has a charging tip which has on the same cord another USB-C port (socket) which you can plug into your display chain, or port replicator or what not. What you seem to have missed is that this is nobody cares. Nobody is going, "I really wish I could charge my laptop through the same port I connect my external hard drive to." This just isn't a problem people have. However, plenty of people say about the MacBook Air, "I really wish I could transfer data from my external storage hard drive to my thumb drive while my MacBook Air is plugged into my monitor." The new MacBook Air that they've oddly rebranded to confuse with the entire MacBook brand will have a much worse problem in this respect.
- frio 12y agoIt's a problem I have. Apple don't have docking stations; it's frustrating unhooking multiple devices so I can wander to a meeting room, only to hook them up again later. A single cable would be amazing (even more so if it was MagSafe, but oh well).
- kevin_thibedeau 12y agoA USB 3 hub can fulfill any function a traditional docking station would other than extremely low latency I/O which most users don't care about.
- frio 12y agoThat doesn't account for my screens, charger, etc. It's an admittedly minor concern, but I imagine it'll be very nice when I can just plug in a single cable :). The thing I've come to appreciate better is that everybody needs different tools. When I was working as a Systems Engineer and needed to connect via serial port to ratty old servers, this new Macbook would have had me screaming. As a developer at my current workplace, I don't need infinite connectability, just portability :).
- tehaugmenter 12y ago
- FireBeyond 12y ago"In Apple's case I fully expect they will make it so that when you plug your Apple display into your laptop it also charges it since the charger is permanently connected to (or built into) the Apple monitor/display." Some of us are still waiting for our Displays with MagSafe2 and USB3... when was the last MagSafe1 laptop made? Yet Apple is still manufacturing the TB display as-is.
- sjwright 12y ago> waiting for our Displays with MagSafe2 and USB3 And Thunderbolt 2. And a screen with the same great anti-glare coating as the current two-year-old non-retina iMac. And industrial design that matches any of Apple's current products, rather than something visually unchanged in six years.
- nogridbag 12y agoWhat about when you're not using the power adapter? Even two USB ports on my MacBook "Pro" is too limited for my daily use case. I use a USB yubikey for multifactor auth with LastPass and it takes up one USB slot permanently. I prefer wired mice, so my mouse takes up the second USB port. If I want to charge my phone, Fitbit or in the past Google Glass with the USB port, I have to unplug my mouse. I would not buy the new MacBook as it's unusable for me unless I carry around a hub everywhere.
- xixixao 12y agoSay it had three ports, you would really buy an underpowered thinner Pro for the same amount of money? I didn't think so...
- masklinn 12y agoHaving two of them on opposite side as the new Pixel does is certainly convenient, even more so because the port is flexible: you can just plug your stuff in whichever port is more convenient in terms of distance/position. Have a power plug to the left? Plug it to the left port. To the right? Plug to the right port. That is by far the main reason why I'm bothered by Apple's MB and its single Type C, while having a single one may be sufficient having one on each side is significantly more convenient.