4 ms·
Learning Apps Outstrip School Oversight, and Loss of Student Privacy Is at Risk
- tracker1 12y agoI'm pretty sure there are laws regarding tracking people in the U.S. under the age of 13 without parental consent... Data really should be anonymized behind a token from a school provided OAuth2 login server... actually tracking student information in the applications shouldn't happen in an identifiable way to said application. Unfortunately many IT jobs in government pay less than half of what a corporate position will.
- rodgerd 12y ago> I'm pretty sure there are laws regarding tracking people in the U.S. under the age of 13 without parental consent... That might be great in the US (although US privacy laws are generally pretty shithouse compared to Europe, for example), but there's also a huge push of these products into overseas markets with little to no sign that there's any adherence to local laws.)
- thephyber 12y agoI assume you are talking about COPPA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Protection_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Children%27s_Online_Privacy_Pr...
- kendallpark 12y agoThis is worrisome especially considering the fact the private information at stake is that of minors. I personally believe schools are too quick to jump on the "new tech" bandwagon without actually evaluating whether their new shiny apps are actually more effective in teaching than the traditional methods. It's like the CSMP madness x 10. You have schools promoting "one laptop per child" when numerous studies have some that laptops in the classroom decrease material retention. A lot of these additions are just so the schools can look better on paper. I remember when my high school installed smartboards under some upgrade-tech initiative. Very few teachers actually need the extra capabilities that smartboards had. It was all so they could impress parents with their "state of the art" classrooms.
- ForHackernews 12y agoYCombinator's own Clever is in this space. I'd be interested to hear what safeguards they have in place.
- frogfuzion 12y agoEdTech right now appears to be the wild west with a lot of startups/VC now chasing around dollars of typically uninformed and naive school district officials who will throw the budget towards any shiny new toy or teachers who will sign up for any cool freemium service. All of this experimentation is often occurring with ANY sort of cost-benefit analysis or performance benchmarking. On top of that it experimentation on -- human children!
- psychometry 12y agoYeah let's just keep doing things the way we've always done them!
- frogfuzion 12y agoI'm not arguing against change. Im arguing against change without accountability and performance metrics. This is what happens now in most cases. Tax payers are then left to guess if their indirect investments in technology are worth it. I'm arguing against tech change blindly initiated by educrats who are easily suckered by sales pitches at conferences. This is also what is happening now with such a low barrier of entry to edtech market.
- fnordfnordfnord 12y agoIt was only about ten years ago that it was still considered an acceptable practice to require college students to write their SSN on every assignment and every other bit of paperwork they exchanged with the college. Things are getting better, just maybe not fast enough.