4 ms·
From the perspective of global warming, all that matters is the net contribution of carbon dioxide from fossil fuels to the atmosphere. The reason oil companie
by snowwrestler 12y ago
From the perspective of global warming, all that matters is the net contribution of carbon dioxide from fossil fuels to the atmosphere.
The reason oil companies object to the Renewable Fuel Standard is that it results in lower net usage of oil. If it resulted in higher net oil usage, they wouldn't oppose it. So that answers your question.
- eru 12y agoIt's not quite as simple. Oil companies are interested in making money, not in your burning oil. If they could make more money with your burning less oil (eg by raising oil prices high enough without damaging demand too much), they'd go for it. In this case, the conclusion might still hold. But the proper argument has one more step.
- snowwrestler 12y agoYou're right but that's not the effect that the RFS has. Ethanol directly supplants oil, without affecting total supply or demand for liquid fuel, so it does not allow oil companies to raise their price per volume. Again: that's why they oppose it.
- eru 12y agoActually, it's even worse: if people are forced to consume ethanol with their oil, and ethanol makes the combination a worse product, then demand for oil will drop further than the displacement alone.
- IgorPartola 12y agoNo, that isn't all that matters. I outlined the other factors that matter in my original comment. Wouldn't you agree that fracking also contributes to global warming? Or that fermenting corn does? What matters is the net total. If all that mattered was CO2 from oil, it would be an easy problem: get rid of oil, use ethanol. Thing is CO2 is the same, whether it comes from oil, ethanol, coal burning power plants, or cow manure. What matters is the net emissions.
- snowwrestler 12y agoIf we got rid of oil and used ethanol for everything, we would indeed solve global warming because we would be fixing as much carbon as we release every year. Edit: Not totally solve of course because that doesn't do anything about coal and natural gas emissions.
- joshuapants 12y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but if for example we only used pure ethanol as fuel, carbon would still be emitted, but it would also be offset by the carbon absorbed by growing the next round of fuel crops. It seems like such a situation would be either carbon-neutral or close to it. Especially if we develop (through GMOs or ordinary selective breeding) crops specifically for fuel purposes to make the whole process more efficient.
- IgorPartola 12y agoThat's not correct. In a pure-ethanol economy, the total emissions will be CO2 from: - Deforestation for the creation of corn fields. This includes the process of cutting down trees (gas powered machines, transport, etc.) and loss of trees that will no longer produce O2/absorb CO2 - Planting - Fertilizers. This one is huge as creation of fertilizers is nasty business and fairly energy intensive. - Harvesting - Transport - Fermentation - Disposal of byproducts - Transport again to the pump - Combustion - Other effects, such as having to manufacture more engines as they would wear out quicker and recycling of more worn out engines. This would partially offset by the fact that the corn is absorbing CO2. As I mentioned above (twice), fossil fuels have similarly complex sources of emissions (drilling/fracking, transport, refining, transport again, combustion). The question to answer is this: if you sum up the totals for both methods, which is more efficient. I guarantee you, both still will produce net positive CO2 emissions. The only question is which will produce less net CO2 from all the sources. Lastly, I should mention that theoretically, there is also a benefit of reducing other nasty emissions from fossil fuels such as sulfur. We could probably produce cleaner ethanol than gasoline. But none of that will matter if we spew so much CO2 into the air that we suffocate before we can measure these secondary pollutants properly.
- ArkyBeagle 12y agoThere is no "oil company" that is purely interested in maintaining oil demand. It's all services except for the actual leaseholders. There may be consortia that are interested, but they are of limited ability to influence policy. Post-2008, demand for oil has dropped without recovering, yet the cash flows of oil firms have remained strong ( it remains to be seen what comes of the big price drop ).