6 ms·
The practices of the Oregon lottery seem wrong to me. Government should be in the business of helping people and providing uncorrupted resources and facts, not
by jab2014 12y ago
The practices of the Oregon lottery seem wrong to me. Government should be in the business of helping people and providing uncorrupted resources and facts, not marketing dreams and hope to people while taking their money hand over fist. John Oliver just did a good segment about this too https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9PK-netuhHA
- vonklaus 12y agoI dont think the government has ever been in the business of providing uncorrupted resources.
- felixgallo 12y agonext time you drink water or drive on a road, remember this comment.
- automatthew 12y agoWells and driveways.
- mintplant 12y ago"Uncorrupted", not "exclusive".
- shit_parade 12y agoWater usage in the US is incredibly irresponsible, not really priced by usage(farmers get enormous subsidies), and largely done by favoritism and grandfathered laws. The UN has aggressively called out US biofuel production as irresponsible and even disastrous. Fracking continues to poison the water tables and ogallala aquifer is sucked dry. Why don't you actually try reading, or educating yourself instead of knee-jerk defending the government with whatever at hand response you've learned as a child and repeated verbatim. Fucking idiot.
- baddox 12y agoHow many people die on government roads every year, and what do you think the reaction would be if a private road system was similarly managed?
- yongjik 12y ago"Geez, I already paid for route 284 and Interstate 99. Do I have to pay a separate weekend surcharge for the 1000-feet onramp? I mean, come on!" OK, not exactly a reaction on people's deaths, but people react to deaths in a more or less similar way whether it's on a government-managed railway or privately operated 747...
- baddox 12y agoThe payment system is a completely separate discussion, and not one at all relevant to my point. I disagree with your claim that the reactions are similar. It's my impression that the reactions to the dangers of public road systems is not remotely close to the reactions toward the dangers of private transportation systems, especially when normalized for the scale of the dangers.
- Frondo 12y agoThen get involved. It's easy to sit back and act like government's all corrupt, hur hur, but guess what--you can talk to your elected officials and try and shape government more to how you think it should work. If your elected officials don't give you access to them, work to put in office, some who do.
- shit_parade 12y agoWow. Do you even know how much time an elected official spends fund raising? Many members of congress fund raise every day, every day they are walking out of capitol hill and across the street to be glorified phone bank monkeys begging some rich guy for money. Do you know what gerrymandering is? Have you looked, actually looked at gerrymandered districts? They're like something Escher would draw, they certainly don't reflect communities, geographical constraints, or anything besides the best statistical slicing to ensure the status quo prevails. I'm all for Ghandi's "be the change you wish to see", but being critical to someone who points out the ills in the world is shooting the messenger. You recall what platform Obama ran on? Hope and Change, how did that work out? The political process in America is broken and voting will not solve the problem of corruption.
- Frondo 12y agoHey, that's great. You stay home. I'm going to keep going out and being involved. We'll see who gets more done.
- innguest 12y agoYou're only getting "involved" by voting according to the government's definition of "getting involved". Your parent post just put forward an argument which you did not address: "You recall what platform Obama ran on? Hope and Change, how did that work out? The political process in America is broken and voting will not solve the problem of corruption." Please address this argument. No need for "we'll see who gets more done" future arguments, this is a present-day argument. What should we do when, after people go out and "get involved" and "get more done" to elect the right representative, they don't follow through on their promises? What should we do?
- zwily 12y agoIn that case, wouldn't you think Oregon shouldn't have a lottery at all?
- eli 12y agoI'd be OK with that. IF the state needs more money they should raise taxes.
- automatthew 12y agoPaging David Hume. David Hume. Has anyone seen David Hume?
- DonHopkins 12y agoHe's out consuming Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel.
- jff 12y agoYou really want to hyphenate "out-consuming", unless David Hume is now a cannibal :)
- DonHopkins 12y agoThat is a delicious thought. If God hadn't meant people to eat other people, he wouldn't have made us of meat. ;) David Hume bites the invisible hand that feeds him.
- ploxiln 12y agoIt similarly struck me as strange that many US states decide gambling should be illegal because it's a vice, or because it's taking advantage of people, but then turn around and give themselves a monopoly on offering it. And in some places, like New York, they advertise it very heavily - TV ads, billboards in the subway and on bus stations, quirky upbeat characters and themes ... But still, it's a bad thing and thus illegal for private companies to offer. So weird.
- baddox 12y ago> It similarly struck me as strange that many US states decide gambling should be illegal because it's a vice, or because it's taking advantage of people, but then turn around and give themselves a monopoly on offering it. That describes a huge portion of what government does. Heck, that's essentially the basic definition of government in political science.
- shit_parade 12y agoMany States deflect criticisms of for profit lotteries by advertising that some of the proceeds go toward schools and other 'public' goods. It is well known that lotteries pray upon the poor and uneducated, ironic really. Instead of monopolizing gambling, or giving sweet-heart deals to those close to the government, or trying to outlaw it completely so we can see tragedies like cops shooting people over playing fantasy sports, the state should get out of the way, maybe provide counseling and treatment, and gasp let people do what they want with their property. It's always about power, and ensuring most people don't have any.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- Gustomaximus 12y agoHumans have weaknesses that can be abused. This is clearly the case in gambling. The government must protect in some areas. For example with financial advice, there are countless cases of people giving inappropriate financial advice to the elderly, even getting them to sign away their property while dying in hospitals. Sure it easy to say 'and gasp let people do what they want with their property'. But what about this scenario? Would you be OK if that was your relatives being manipulated on their deathbed to give money to a previous stranger cause it is what they want to do with their property at that moment in their life. Or, back to gambling, is it fair on the children of the father/mother who gamble away their pay check each month leaving the family destitute? Above is more extreme but real examples to clarify a point. In my mind saying people can do what they want with their property is overly simplistic and assumes a more perfect world than the reality.
- bmmayer1 12y agoThe government is in a much better position to protect people from fraud if it isn't the one perpetrating the fraud in the first place.
- SilasX 12y ago>Or, back to gambling, is it fair on the children of the father/mother who gamble away their pay check each month leaving the family destitute? However bad it might be to prey on people by trying to trick them into gambling, it's a trillion times better than just taking their money (the other way of raising revenues).
- joosters 12y agoWhy does 'government' come into it? Do you really believe that it would be acceptable if a private company was doing the same thing?
- Shivetya 12y agoall government lotteries should be banned. they exploit the poor. its really depressing to see how much money some spend on these tickets. In Georgia less than a third is actually reaching the designated programs, it was by law 35% but terms in there let it fluctuate to payout to instant tickets.
- zf00002 12y agoNot sure about other states but MN even has online "virtual" scratch-offs that you can buy. They even have "subscriptions" to this crap. It's disgusting.
- coldpie 12y agoYeah, it's really ugly in MN. The MN leg even plans for gambling proceeds for future funding. They planned for video gambling in bars to pay for their $500MM donation to billionaire Zygi Wilf's sports team, and fell all over themselves when it didn't[1]. http://www.twincities.com/politics/ci_26579002/vikings-stadium-gaming-revenues-still-projected-pay-large http://www.twincities.com/politics/ci_26579002/vikings-stadi...
- refurb 12y agoDo you really think banning lotteries would stop people from gambling? It certainly doesn't work for alcohol or drugs.
- runjake 12y agoI remember when the Oregon and California Lottery were passed in the early 80s. I was highly controversial, but advocates really pitched the "more funds for schools!!!" angle. What legislators didn't tell the public is that after the bills passed, the existing education budget would be cannibalized for other expenditures, thereby not actually improving the education situation and in fact, making funding more volatile.