5 ms·
And if this is the kind of problem they're wielding that power/money/prestige/knowledge to solve at 40, imagine what they could be working on at 400. If you're
by JoshTriplett 12y ago
And if this is the kind of problem they're wielding that power/money/prestige/knowledge to solve at 40, imagine what they could be working on at 400.
If you're going to say that people ought to keep dying, by the billions, as they are today, go ahead and say that; don't dance around it.
- puranjay 12y agoFor every Sergey Brin, don't forget that there is also a Rupert Murdoch and a Donald Trump. Do you really want an immortal Rupert Murdoch running around in 2550?
- aetherson 12y agoIf it means that I can also be running around in 2550? Fuck yeah I do. If I'm going to be long dead? Well, I guess that'll be someone else's problem. I agree that radical life extension will result in increased inequality and an ageless aristocracy. And that would be a problem. It's just much less of a problem than "everyone I know and love (and me) dying."
- noir_lord 12y agoI don't really want a mortal Rupert Murdoch running around now. That dude is so close to evil they based a bond villain on him.
- rsync 12y ago"If you're going to say that people ought to keep dying, by the billions, as they are today, go ahead and say that; don't dance around it." People ought to keep dying, by the billions, if that is required to keep the organism of humanity alive and healthy. Cells in your body have programmed senescence - when that mechanism fails (cancer, etc.) the entire organism (you) is at risk. What if the species-level analogy is true ? I hope that's not the case because I, personally, would like to live a few hundred extra years. However it is ill conceived to frame the debate as a simple dichotomy between bright shiny extropians and grumpy luddites who are happy to die.
- JoshTriplett 12y ago> People ought to keep dying, by the billions, if that is required to keep the organism of humanity alive and healthy. Until we have a widely available means of curing mortality, such statements are idle speculation (though it does detract from efforts to come up with such a cure). Once we do, however, attempting to suppress that cure would be nothing less than mass murder. So if that is a problem we end up needing to solve, let's find a better solution that doesn't involve mass murder. And let's not stop efforts to find such a cure because we're afraid of such a problem. I think you have a more reasonable outlook on this than most; it's good to approach this as a problem that legitimately needs evaluation, rather than being completely dismissive of it. > I hope that's not the case because I, personally, would like to live a few hundred extra years. That'd be a good start, especially if it gets us to the point where further fixes become available. A few billion would be better, though. :)
- eli_gottlieb 12y agoMass murder is what our society does to the poor, albeit slowly, on an everyday basis today, if "mass murder" can be defined as simply allowing people to die when we could help them.
- JoshTriplett 12y agoI wasn't referring to lack of action, but to actively preventing people from taking advantage of a means available to them to avoid death, out of some belief that death was necessary.