2 ms·
I have remarked here multiple times that I regard "the end justifies the means" as the perfect definition of evil, but I'm not sure that is what's going on here
by protomyth 12y ago
I have remarked here multiple times that I regard "the end justifies the means" as the perfect definition of evil, but I'm not sure that is what's going on here.
I don't think Linus or Theo are inherently dicks. They actually seem to be awfully nice guys for the most part. Unfortunately, we seem to have a generation of people that cannot take the hint that their code needs work or they just don't seem to pay attention to what is going on. I'm not sure if its a symptom of rapidly developing code and then fixing it later. Most BDFLs are under stress and need to set clear boundaries. It seems like people only pay attention to the bombastic and not the subtle.
- TeMPOraL 12y ago> I have remarked here multiple times that I regard "the end justifies the means" as the perfect definition of evil I personally disagree with this definition; for me "end justifies the means" sounds like a perfectly rational conclusion, but not for humans - it's too common a failure mode for a man to follow this maxim, and it almost always ends bad; hence we have that saying. > Unfortunately, we seem to have a generation of people that cannot take the hint that their code needs work or they just don't seem to pay attention to what is going on. I agree. Moreover, I think we have a generation of people who like to take offense at anything and everything, mostly for signalling reasons. "I am offended by what you wrote, therefore I am a better person and you are wrong".
- protomyth 12y ago> I personally disagree with this definition; for me "end justifies the means" sounds like a perfectly rational conclusion, but not for humans - it's too common a failure mode for a man to follow this maxim, and it almost always ends bad; hence we have that saying. I have never heard a person use that phrase and not violate the rights of other humans and their own morality. It is the gateway phrase people use to justify some act that they admit, by using that phrase, is not honorable. It's the phrase you say right before walking on that road paved with all those good intentions.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI know. I haven't heard people using this phrase with different results either. http://lesswrong.com/lw/uv/ends_dont_justify_means_among_humans/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/uv/ends_dont_justify_means_among_hum... This post elaborates on the topic a bit more, and after reading it some time ago I ended up agreeing with its conclusion - that the phrase is OK from theoretical standpoint, for perfectly rational actors, but not for humans - hence the heuristic, "end does not justify the means".