4 ms·
I wouldn't say socialism has been 'dealt with', modern representative democracy in the European mould is heavily informed by socialist principles. I think you m
by simonh 12y ago
I wouldn't say socialism has been 'dealt with', modern representative democracy in the European mould is heavily informed by socialist principles. I think you mean communism, evidenced by the article's mentions of Engels and Marx, which has pretty clearly failed in spectacular fashion everywhere it's been tried. I found the point that building out the infrastructure for industrialisation was incredibly capital intensive and so labour wage rises weren't really an option interesting, because of course that's exactly how it played out in industrialising communist countries as well. It's just that the state held on to the capital instead of industrialists (or rather the industrialists holding the capital were part of the state).
Interestingly, China now seems to be going through the equivalent of the late 19th century phase where labour wages begin to rise roughly in line with productivity. They've largely built out their core infrastructure and mopped up most of the spare labour pool. China's development has been a huge factor in the economic conditions in the west. I'm wondering how the balancing out of the Chinese economy with ours will affect us.
- kokey 12y agoIf you look at average wages in China, I think they have a long way to go to mop up labour slack. The problem is it's reaching a point where it's becoming more complex to mop up the rest by growing their more productive and experienced workforce, which is the new, growing, more powerful middle class. This can work out well, or not, and will impact us greatly either way.
- crdoconnor 12y ago>If you look at average wages in China, I think they have a long way to go to mop up labour slack. Average wages in the Pearl River Delta don't seem to reflect this. Skilled wages are skyrocketing and even unskilled wages have upward pressure on them. The seemingly endless flow of cheap migrant labor is drying up.
- greenrd 12y agoIsn't this because China has had internal migration controls for over 70 years, which are unheard of outside communist countries? Actually I think it's unheard of outside China.
- simonh 12y agoNot really. The controlls are there to protect municipalities from having obligations to provide welfare and services to migrants. It doesn't actually prevent the migrants from travelling for work.
- roel_v 12y ago"They've largely built out their core infrastructure and mopped up most of the spare labour pool." What? There are 750 million (that is twice the population of the US, or 1.5 times the population of the EU) subsistence farmers in China. And that's only counting subsistence farmers as spare labor.