5 ms·
The worst suggestion in the world: make one of these look like one of those USB dead-drops.
by derefr 12y ago
The worst suggestion in the world: make one of these look like one of those USB dead-drops.
- TeMPOraL 12y agoI think it's the best idea ever. I mean, seriously, with all those USB-based attack vectors do anyone thinks plugging your computer to a random USB port sticking out of a wall is a good idea?
- derefr 12y agoIt's kind of a snide thing to do, though; every physical interchange medium, or object you might put in proximity to your computer, has physical attack vectors. Optical disks can be weakened so as to become shrapnel inside a disk drive. Magnetic tapes can be replaced with sandpaper and scratch the reader to death. Any cassette media (e.g. floppy disks) can simply be filled with glue—or, better yet, contain a small explosive. So, there's nothing about USB that makes people especially deserving of punishment if they go using strange ones; there's a base level of societal trust required for the abstraction of a "side-effect-free data storage object" to exist in the first place. To say otherwise is similar to purposefully driving the wrong way down the road and getting into a 28-car pile-up, and then saying that this is a lesson in how cars are inherently dangerous and people should avoid driving near strangers. The security mindset can only make you so safe; at some point, you have to trust that strangers aren't trying to kill you in order to be able to live your life. (Though, in this case, you could just avoid all physical peripherals and ask the person to email you the file instead. At least all you can get from that is a virus.)
- TeMPOraL 12y agoIt's not like that. USB drives are a popular vector for transfering malware both ways. Which means a perfectly good dead drop can become infected when someone who didn't know he had malware plugs his computer in. USB dead drops are not like cars - they're like a bottle of juice chained to a wall, that anyone can drink from and refill it with whatever they want. You don't have to assume malice to expect such a bottle to be a health risk - not everyone who deposits a disease knows he is ill. Of course I'm joking with my approval for installing boobytrapped dead drops - but the point is, connecting to a random thumbdrive sticking out of a wall sounds like a dumbest computer-related idea ever.