6 ms·
I've worked in the adtech industry for years and now run a new company focused on content/native ads. Online advertising is a vast and complicated ecosystem wi
by manigandham 12y ago
I've worked in the adtech industry for years and now run a new company focused on content/native ads.
Online advertising is a vast and complicated ecosystem with hundreds of companies and lots of politics but all this is to say that sites like Gigaom failing are almost never just down to simple factors as "ads pay less". Some points on online advertising itself though, in random order:
- Overall pageviews online are up, a lot. More people are online now and with more devices (desktops, laptops, tablets, phones, even tvs).
- Ad blockers (depending on the site) can be anywhere from 10-50% of users.
- Desktop is now the minority, usually about 35% of traffic.
- Ad blockers are mostly on desktop, so while they are making an impact, it's somewhat minimized by the shift to mobile.
- Ad blockers are also mostly run by corporations that make money and most allow companies to buy exceptions (Google does this, along with all those recommended links guys like Outbrain, Taboola and dozens of others. To be perfectly honest, we're trying to get on this list as well.)
- There's a difference between branding/awareness campaigns (like for GE) vs performance campaigns (like for Newegg). Awareness is about getting you to recognize, remember, engage with and otherwise think about the brand. Especially important for B2B/enterprise and other companies that don't have things for consumers to buy, or even cheap enough for mainstream. Performance is all about getting a click, or these days even a signup, purchase or some other "action".
- The ability of digital advertising to track things to such a granular level has made everything more efficient, driving down prices to a few cents per click in some cases. The ads you see on a webpage have gone through an entire auction process with dozens of bidders in about 100 milliseconds before you ever see anything.
- Fraud is a huge issue along with viewability (whether an ad actually shows up inside the browser window vs. never being scrolled into view, inactive tab, etc). Early studies have pegged fraud/viewability problems at almost 50% although this is rapidly going down with new companies and standards. Nobody wants fraud and it's a constant arms race.
- There are lots of ad types, everything from display (banners) to rich media (interstitials, popups, expanding/moving/interactive stuff), to native ads, to video, to email, and more. They all work on different parts of the "sales funnel" and there are different strategies in place. One of the biggest is called retargeting. It's when you visit a site then see ads for that same company across the web, even days or weeks later. It's all about making you remember and come back to learn more, buy something, etc. And it works really well.
- Display ads do work. While everyone seems to think that they won't ever click on a banner, Google sees hundreds of millions of clicks a day. Those recommended widgets get tens of millions of clicks a day. Ads work, whether you want to believe it or not, otherwise this industry wouldn't exist. Those billboards on the side of a freeway are far more expensive than small campaigns online but they're still bought because you can measure the effect before and after and see a measurable increase in whatever you're interested in.
- People complain that they get crappy ads, unfortunately they also complain about being tracked. Trust me, ad networks want to get you the best ads as possible. Showing you what you're interested helps everyone. But we can't know who you are, what you've seen or anything else if we can't track you in some way. And for those who are worried about privacy, for all the legit ad platforms, you're nothing more than a randomized id number. Not personal information. If you're worried about that, then stay off Facebook where most people willingly give all their info.
- Most advertising is being shifted to be bought on audiences rather than sites. Native ads are shifting this back somewhat but most modern platforms work by selling audience segments primarily, so as an advertiser you would run a campaign targeting 18-25 males interested in sports for example. Doesn't matter what site, as long as the audience matches and this is facilitated by the efficiency of running the aforementioned auctions (called RTB for Real-Time Bidding).
- While privacy is important, there's an arms race with tracking because advertisers want this audience access. The recent issue with cookies has only made tech companies even better at tracking and there are entire sub-industries dedicated to tracking people across all of their devices. We can do this today. And it will only get better. Again the intentions are to get you better ads but if you're worried about privacy, just be aware that it's not that easy to "hide".
---
If you've read this far, I hope that helped give some insight into online ads. I'm sorry I can't give exact sources as this is data that comes our ad network and it's not published anywhere, but we do have global coverage and this is very accurate in the US/European region. Disclaimer again: I run https://instinctive.io https://instinctive.io but feel free to email/message if you want more info.
- 616c 12y ago> Again the intentions are to get you better ads but if you're worried about privacy, just be aware that it's not that easy to "hide". I like the very balanced and technical nature of your analysis, but I am sure I am not the only one you rubbed the wrong way with this. Since you seem to be tied into the industry, how can we impart to you and your colleagues in adtech it should be the right of us "ad blockers in the desktop minority" people to leave us the hell alone? Do insiders, like yourself, casually write us off in meetings as the enemy or is there more nuance? I am curious of the perception of us and how industry members address it in day-to-day operations. I know you cannot personally invert the system bc I whine on HN. Also, is running a privacy-centric proxy blocking ad services (Privoxy or hostsblock) enough anymore? I have considered moving to Privoxy as an extreme, in addition to NoScript on FF, specifically to address ETag and cache busting and all this other stuff I have been warned about at the cost of slowing down my browsing. Do your analytics go even lower than that and waste my time? I know you will probably not be comfortable answering this, but I would love to hear from you and others in the industry.
- 20150310 12y agoGoogle ads eng here: you're not the enemy. As the parent said, "Trust me, ad networks want to get you the best ads as possible." We don't want you to feel hate and resentment while looking at an ad. So, we try to accommodate your adblocker (as we update our UI we go out of our way to avoid confusing your adblocker), we try to serve you fewer ads, and we work on alternative ways to fund web development, such as Consumer Surveys and Contributor.
- manigandham 12y agoHey, didn't mean to be brash about it, just being honest so you know how it works. Ad blockers are always considered bad. You're either breaking terms of service or, in some cases, the law by using them. The content you consume is free in exchange for showing you ads. By only consuming without seeing the ads, you're effectively stealing directly from the publishers (site owners). I'll just leave it at that, however you deal with this morally and personally is up to you. The ad networks do care about this since it's still lost revenue, but our effect is minimized because we often have much bigger reach than just a few sites and can still serve plenty of ads across the entire web. There is an arms race and the big companies just pay to play. Remember the adblock plugins are usually made by for-profit corporations who will grant exceptions for cash so take from that what you will. You can run your own plugins or filter lists but there are not that many of you who do this to matter much. So yes, we do keep an eye on adblock usage but it's still small enough for us to just not put too much effort on it now. Also there are plenty of companies with some tech to defeat adblockers so that will happen if the industry does decide to focus on it. As for privacy, I have to ask first, what are you trying to accomplish? Remember you can either have accurate ads best fit for you or have complete privacy. We can't show you stuff that's relevant without tracking, that's just reality. I can't reveal too much but networks usually start tracking with cookies and some more advanced methods by themselves but as they get bigger, we outsource a lot of the tracking to 3rd party companies who are very good at this. There are lots of browser and device fingerprinting technologies and other information that you give off just to visit and render a site that we can use. Even the internet carriers themselves participate in this and you can't really hide from them since most people just have 1 connection. Proxy services will help but again you're sacrificing a lot of convenience and speed for what? To stick it to us? Unless you're running adblockers, we'll just end up serving you generic ads anyway and still tracking as best we can. I think there's a massive misconception on what exactly you're protecting yourself from. Most user profiles are removed after 15-30-60 days as it becomes stale. We don't collect personally identifying information (but facebook does), we don't track searches (but google does), and it's all just anonymized identifiers. Beyond that, we can always just ask the big data collecting agencies for more information to make a decision without actually collecting/storing anything ourselves (stuff like purchase histories) so you're not giving up much there either. I do understand the battle for privacy but in lots of situations, the issues are overblown if you want my honest opinion.