5 ms·
While he is correct that slow walking doesn't burn many calories in itself, there is also evidence[1] that even mild levels of exercise act to increase your met
by nl 12y ago
While he is correct that slow walking doesn't burn many calories in itself, there is also evidence[1] that even mild levels of exercise act to increase your metabolism significantly.
This means that the benefits outweigh the simple measurement of calories burnt, especially for people who are otherwise sedentary.
[1] http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0013022 http://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal....
- jader201 12y agoA lot of contradictory comments on this thread: > This means that the benefits outweigh the simple measurement of calories burnt, especially for people who are otherwise sedentary. > It was my understanding that if you're largely sedentary, no amount of exercise can "make up" for that, and that the correlation with increased morbidity and mortality remains. Some say that even a little helps, some say that even large amounts of exercise still isn't enough. As a largely sedentary person, I wish there were more concrete studies done to show how to mitigate the risks of long-term problems for those of us that are sedentary for a (relatively) big part of the day.
- Swizec 12y ago> Some say that even a little helps, some say that even large amounts of exercise still isn't enough. Something is always better than nothing. It might not increase your long-term longevity, but will be of great help in an altercation or simply playing with a child. And here's the kicker: IF YOU DO LARGE AMOUNTS OF EXERCISE YOU ARE NO LONGER LARGELY SEDENTARY.
- mod 12y agoWouldn't largely sedentary refer to the amount of hours sedentary? I spend 8 hours in a chair, minimum. It's unlikely that I spend 100% of the remaining waking hours standing, so I'm already largely sedentary. Factor in sleep and it's not even close.
- Swizec 12y agoWould you call a professional athlete who works out for two to three hours a day sedentary? They spend 21 hours a day resting and recuperating from working out. "It has been established that the average world class athlete trains approximately 23 hours a week. Interestingly, the average athlete in America trains approximately 12 hours a week." (3h/day) Source: google first result
- nitrogen 12y agoOut of curiosity, could you provide a link to your search terms or to the result you used?
- Swizec 12y agohttps://www.google.si/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&espv=2&es_th=1&ie=UTF-8#q=how%20much%20does%20the%20average%20athlete%20train&es_th=1 https://www.google.si/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ion=1&es...
- mod 12y agoI'm really not sure, and was hoping someone had some good insight. I don't know if there's a specific medical definition, or if sitting for 21 hours but being very active for 3 cancels out. I just took the meaning to be "sitting/non-moving," which I do for nearly my entire 24h lately. (I used to be very active, before programming, but I have work and side projects and...youtube...lately keeping me in a chair). Anyway, to specifically answer your question, I would describe the athlete's day as "largely sedentary." Again, I'm not making medical judgments or saying that person is harming their body. I'm in this thread gain insight into how badly I'm damaging my body and how likely it is I can mitigate that damage.
- stevenwei 12y agoI don't think these are contradictory at all. If you're largely sedentary, getting an hour of exercise per day doesn't counteract the fact that you've been sitting for 12 hours per day. [1] Simultaneously, walking slowly all day does not burn many calories compared to a proper workout. But that's fine, because the goal of walking slowly all day is not to burn calories, but simply to keep you from sitting all day. It seems to me the best approach is to simply do both. [1] http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2091327 http://annals.org/article.aspx?articleid=2091327
- Someone 12y agoSo, this guy isn't doing much good, with 2.5-3 miles walking a day at 1.8 miles/hour (1h25m to 1h40m of walking)? I expect that, in 10 years or so, we will SE more nuanced publications about the health effects of sitting less. Looking at chimps in nature, I expect the optimum will be something where you don't sit in the same position for hours at an end, but hobble a few meters every half hour or so and grab some fruit or groom a colleague (the latter would require significant changes in workplace ethics and law)
- VLM 12y ago"hobble a few meters every half hour or so" I get up every hour almost without fail, and walk all the way across the building to get a drink, or bathroom break, or any excuse, sometimes I do nothing at all. Often I walk to a different floor. This was on dr advice a long time ago WRT back probs and general health. I'm a heck of a lot more productive in the 10 minutes after I get back than the 10 minutes before, so its almost certainly a substantial net gain to my employer. I do the same daily mileage as the author but compressed into my lunch hour, in addition to the above, weather permitting. I'd be interested to see shoe wear stats. When I slack off in the depths of winter or the peak of summer I can see my shoe soles not wear when I don't do a couple miles of pavement at lunch hour. Its also interesting to look at financially, I can only get a couple hundred miles out of a pair of shoes, and I need to buy decent walking shoes not cheap junk solely based on appearance. I would guess shoe wear on a rubber belt is very low compared to concrete... then again I don't pay for whatever wear I cause to the concrete sidewalk and someone is paying for his treadmill wear directly or indirectly. When I worked in a suburban office building I walked the nature trails and shoe wear on shredded bark was approximately zero, and it was more emotionally satisfying than dodging panhandlers in the city. Related to above I tried wearing trail hiking boots and the wear was high on pavement. Lunch hour walks would probably be a good strategy for breaking in new boots, but it doesn't work long term for exercise. It was an interesting article although there's plenty of space for further study.
- nl 12y agoThere are multiple issues and they are closely related, which makes things confusing. 1) In terms of weight management, calories burnt is what is important. Mild exercise won't burn huge numbers of calories, but it can increased your basal metabolic rate which means you burn more calories sitting still. This can be a significant contribution to weight loss. 2) There are other, non-weight related unhealthy effects of sedentary behavior. Current recommendations for managing these involve 15 minutes of non-sedentary behavior every 2 hours (ie, stand and possibly walk for 15 minutes every 2 hours). Realistically, many people can do this by having a standing meeting in the morning, walking at lunch, and a standing meeting in the afternoon.
- kolev 12y agoWhy do you need to "burn" any calories and boost your metabolism? If you care about longevity, you need to actually slow down your metabolism and restrict your caloric intake. Walking 30-45 minutes a day in the park is good enough - most geniuses in the past had the evening walk (30-60 minutes) as a common theme. Also, you don't need a fancy desk. Just take breaks and walk.
- nl 12y agoThis is all true. However, many posting here are interested in the weight-management effects of treadmill desks. If you are doing heavy caloric restriction then you probably don't have a weight management issue. It's worth noting that the longevity-effects of caloric restriction seem to start occurring at very restrictive levels of consumption, and few have the self-control to stay at that level for decades (which seems to be what is needed).
- kolev 12y agoIntermittent Fasting and the 5:2 diets are good compromises. My concern with too much exercise is the tissue wear and the oxidative stress associated with aerobic exercise. There are studies that walking for 2 minutes every 20 minutes negates the negative effect of sitting. I personally tried 25 minute sitting work + walking for 5 minutes (which actually increases productivity when you stop staring at the screen without a break).
- kolev 12y agoHere [0] is a very good podcast that covers the issue. A must-hear! [0] http://thequantifiedbody.net/cancer-as-a-mitochondrial-disease-dr-thomas-seyfried/ http://thequantifiedbody.net/cancer-as-a-mitochondrial-disea...
- hyperbovine 12y agoLiving extra long on a restricted caloric intake sounds like the definition of a lose/lose to me.
- 12y ago
- krakensden 12y agoThere's an awfully optimistic bit in REAMDE about an overweight fantasy author transforming into 'Skeletor' via a treadmill desk.
- fuzzywalrus 12y agoAs I recall, the character in question was constantly at a brisk walking pace and was rather obese with bad eating habits. I agree, Skeletor is an oversale of the health benefits but as common knowledge, the further you are from your ideal weight, the easier to is to lose weight and balanced with proper eating habits, its not unreasonable to suggest that a walking desk is would slim someone down, especially if aided in other exercise outside of work.
- Intermernet 12y agoVery OT, but did you find REAMDE to be a bit weak? I found the plot became more and more contrived, and seemed to miss the imagination and scale of Stephenson's other books. The number of highly unlikely coincidences in the plot is incredible, and I got the feeling that he got bored writing it, and just wrapped everything up neatly in a ridiculously unlikely end-scenario.
- wj 12y agoI really enjoyed it though I thought it ran a bit long. Your point on the plot is valid but he did such a great job developing the characters that I didn't care. Disclaimer: his books are like crack to me. Once I start one I can't put it down and now have carefully choose when to pick one up. Quicksilver is next up over the summer.