3 ms·
> The definition of biological advantage is having a large number of offspring rather than a small one! (Simplifying a bit; said offspring should also reproduce
by mseebach 17y ago
> The definition of biological advantage is having a large number of offspring rather than a small one! (Simplifying a bit; said offspring should also reproduce, recursively, but it's a decent approximation to just consider offspring.) What kind of weird question is that?
In animals, yes. Humans, especially in affluent societies have more sophisticated goals. Obviously, reproduction is important, but we will also pursue irrational goals, such as self-realization, quality of life, love, ethics and so on. The idea that we consider it a virtue to raise a child with Asbergers syndrome or other genetic defects is evidence to that, and in an evolutionary context decidedly self-destructive. In fact, I feel queasy even writing this, so strong is our opposition to applying our intelligence to raising the quality of our gene pool = eugenics.
My point is, although ill-articulated in a biological context, how does having a large family further any of the goals that a affluent individual in a wealthy society has? I'm not talking material wealth, even though that applies as well, but also the "soft" goals of contributing great ideas, science, arts, all the jazz, to the greater good of humanity. My point is; is a family with 10 kids more likely to foster a Miles Davis, Ernest Hemingway, Obama, Reagan, whatever floats your boat, than a family with one or two?
- jerf 17y agoAnd my point is that your point doesn't matter. Evolution doesn't care about your "goals". If any chunk of a population reproduces more than others, consistently, it will eventually form the majority, in a fairly short period of time. You seem to be trying to prevent this from being true by sheer volume of analysis. Evolution doesn't care about your analysis, either. It doesn't matter why some people have more children than others in an affluent society. It doesn't even have to be an integer number of children like "3" vs. "2", it only has to be a trend. If you want to have a separate debate about how children impact your quality of life, than say so and have at it. It is from my reading of your other messages that I get the sense that you are almost willfully denying what other people are saying. Perhaps that is not true. But step one is to agree that in the end, it simply doesn't matter what the reasons are, only the actions and their results.
- mseebach 17y agoYes, I was wrong to get this tangled up with evolution. Obviously, if it's a hereditary trait, it will spread and become prevalent. What I was trying to argue, clouded by my lack of understanding of the exact biological meaning of the word trait (i.e. something hereditary rather than a preference a person might have), was that there seems to be little evidence, which is backed by the statistics in the article, that a preference towards many children is hereditary.
- donaldc 17y agoMy point is; is a family with 10 kids more likely to foster a Miles Davis, Ernest Hemingway, Obama, Reagan, whatever floats your boat, than a family with one or two? Unless the ten kids are near starvation or are very restricted in how they are allowed to spend their time, the answer is that the family with ten kids is more likely to foster a notable person. Each child in the ten-kid family may have a somewhat reduced chance of being notable, but that family gets ten rolls of the dice instead of only one or two.