4 ms·
>For some reason, harmonic distortion produced before the 80s is art, and harmonic distortion produced after the 80s is an affront. You're comparing apples to
by TheOtherHobbes 12y ago
>For some reason, harmonic distortion produced before the 80s is art, and harmonic distortion produced after the 80s is an affront.
You're comparing apples to quantum dots.
Tape recording/mixing didn't add distortion in the same way that a bad amp adds distortiion. There certainly is such a thing as cheap transistor sound, and it's both measurable and audible.
There's also such a thing as a high-end studio equipment sound. It's why a good proportion of professional recording and mixing engineers prefer expensive outboard over plugins - even though some of the plug-ins are older than they are now.
There's also such a thing as amplifier sound. Pretty much anyone can hear the difference between a selection of affordable amps on a straight A/B comparison.
There's also such a thing as hifi wankery and outright scamming, especially in the accessories market and at the very high end.
But most people build/buy systems that help them enjoy the music more. If you can't hear the musical differences between - say - music played on a crappy cassette player from the 1980s and music played on a Nakamichi player from the same period, that's fine.
A lot of people could - including all my friends, in various store demos when I was helping them buy music hardware. Quite a few of them had the same reaction I did. Which was 'Wow, I had no idea.'
>If you just want to build high performance electronic equipment, there are much more interesting areas to work in than simply applying gain to a pair of AC signals while preserving their phase relationship.
But audio is completely fascinating because such tiny, subtle changes have such a big effect on the result, and often no one is exactly sure why.
Digital dither is such a small signal it should be completely inaudible. If you play a dither signal on its own, there's nothing to hear.
But the effects are very, very obvious.
Audio is like that all over. Tiny, supposedly trivial distortions change the quality of sound perception in unpredictable ways.
Some make the music sound more enjoyable, some make it sound worse. That's partly why people take an interest.
Competitive consumption is also a thing, but that doesn't change the fact that a lot up-to-mid-price buyers want something they can afford and enjoy. They're not seriously interested in showing it off to their friends or writing about it in hifi magazines.
- mark-r 12y agoFunny you should mention Nakamichi. I had one of their cassette recorders from about 1980, and a Panasonic receiver of the same vintage. I was under the impression that solid-state amplification had progressed to the point where you didn't need to worry about it anymore - until I unplugged my headphones from the receiver and plugged them into the recorder. What a revelation! From that point forward I had the hi-fi bug, although I never went overboard with it.