4 ms·
This is just what professional disciplines tend to be like, as the author notes. You might just as well say that "the main product of structural engineering is
by foldr 17y ago
This is just what professional disciplines tend to be like, as the author notes. You might just as well say that "the main product of structural engineering is not the production of bridges but the reproduction of structural engineering." It's probably true in the same sense that it's true of academia, but so what?
- Gupie 17y agoStructural engineers produce bridges, even if they are arguably just a side produce. In the worst case academics only produce academics.
- mquander 17y agoAcademics also advance humanity's knowledge in their field through research and writing, so that others may stand on their shoulders and see further. Perhaps you don't believe that things like critical literary analysis are providing us any actual benefit, but I disagree and I'm sure that any humanities professor would disagree too.
- jjs 17y ago> Perhaps you don't believe that things like critical literary analysis are providing us any actual benefit, but I disagree and I'm sure that any humanities professor would disagree too. What they'll profess in public and what they'll admit "off the record" aren't always the same thing.
- foldr 17y agoThe same is true of scientists, though. I know plenty who will say disparaging things about the value of their own research "off the record."
- jjs 17y agoI believe it. Scientists at least have the advantage that, even if they can't see any practical application of their research, other people can (and do!).
- RyanMcGreal 17y agoI'm sincerely curious to hear your case in defence of critical literary analysis.
- foldr 17y agoWhy would it need any defense? Are you seriously suggesting that no-one should be reading literature and analyzing it? It's been an important part of Western culture for a few thousand years. Seems like it would be a bit rash to give it up now.
- nkurz 17y agoDespite the literal intepretation, you might be mistaken in assuming that "critical literary analysis" is the same as "reading literature and analyzing it". Instead, I think the phrase is being used here as a term of the art, referring to something closer to "postmodern critical theory". There are definitely those who wonder if this is useful. I too would be interested in hearing a defense.
- foldr 17y agoMost of the people who whine about postmodern critical theory haven't even read any, so I'm not sure how to give a defense of work which people haven't read. I expect that most of it is rather low in quality, but most of the work done in every discipline is rather low in quality. And in any case, not all literary criticism in the academy is "postmodern" in the invidious sense. >Instead, I think the phrase ["critical literary analysis"] is being used here as a term of the art, There is no such term of art, as a quick google scholar search would tell you, so I see no reason not to interpret the OP literally.
- nkurz 17y agoI see no reason not to interpret the OP literally Well, luckily even a casual adherence to postmodernism gives you that right! But in my old fashioned manner, I still think intentionality counts for something, and I don't think the author intended to say that we should give up on reading. :) Most of the people who whine about postmodern critical theory haven't even read any I actually have read a fair bit, and periodically urge it on others, likely in the same way that some people turn their friends onto LSD. Much of it is junk, but some of it is gold. For example, Michel Foucault's "History of Sexuality Volume 1" and "Discipline and Punish" permanently changed the way I see the world around me. So when I said I'd like to see a defense, I meant only that -- that I'd enjoy it. And, of course, that John F. Kennedy was not a homosexual: http://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/decon.html http://www.info.ucl.ac.be/~pvr/decon.html
- Agathos 17y agoIn the worst case, structural engineers don't produce bridges. I'm sure you could find some poor soul who spent a career drawing up proposals for bridges that were never built.
- btilly 17y agoI knew an architect whose job was designing buildings that never got built. He worked for a company that would buy residential land, he'd design a commercial building for that land, the company would take the plans to the local city council and get it rezoned, then the company would flip the newly rezoned land at a significant profit. I liked him, but not his job or employer.
- rbanffy 17y agoWell... The absolute worst case here is a structural engineer producing something that looks like a bridge for some time, then becomes a very dynamic and contorted structure of concrete, metal, automobiles and mostly dead primates.
- gruseom 17y agoThere's a principle associated with some famous sociologist that says "The purpose of any institution is first to perpetuate itself, and only secondarily to pursue its specified goal." I wish I could remember who said this. It's an idea with explanatory power.
- amichail 17y agoIn a related way, the purpose of a student is to maximize his/her grades and in so doing learn a few things along the way.
- gruseom 17y agoTotally disagree. I had contempt for students like that when I was in school. Probably still do, if I thought about it.
- ejames 17y agoI would call that the pathological case rather than the average one. Maximizing grades against learning as little as possible is the lowest hurdle you can cross while still technically being successful as a student. It's also worth remembering that "student" does not always mean "child currently undergoing mandatory education". I would think that adults who return to complete their diplomas/degrees or add a graduate-level program on top of the undergraduate one are comparatively more likely to choose to maximize knowledge rather than just grades. It's mostly commonly expressed as "now that I'm personally paying for it, I want to get my money's worth".
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou could make the corresponding argument for structural engineering, but it would be harder. The corresponding statement for academia would be: "the main product of academia is not the production of ___ but..." But what do we fill in the blank with? With structural engineering, the answer is obvious. With academia, particularly humanities academia, not so much.
- foldr 17y agoIt's true that research in the humanities tends to have less definite "results" than research in the sciences, but it's daft to use that as a criticism. _Of course_ literary analysis produces less definite results than chemistry. But that doesn't mean it's not worth doing.
- krakensden 17y agoWhy is it worth doing? What are its results?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]