3 ms·
> The only thing that brought them to the table was the idea that their enemy possessed a weapon where a single bomb could level a city Utterly wrong. This has
by ekianjo 12y ago
> The only thing that brought them to the table was the idea that their enemy possessed a weapon where a single bomb could level a city
Utterly wrong. This has been shown many times that the A-bomb was not the decisive part. It was the upcoming involvement of Russians on the Japanese front. Please stop spreading explanations for 5-years olds.
- Crito 12y agoIt occurs to me that by asserting that the American nuclear bombardment was not justifiable because the Japanese were not sufficiently terrified of it but were sufficiently terrified of a Russian invasion, we are saying something quite extreme about the nature of an invading Russian army. Does anybody know what narrative is taught in Russian schools to Russian children?
- tanzam75 12y agoJapan had been allied to Germany. The Wehrmacht had been one of the most effective fighting forces the world has ever known. The Imperial Japanese Army had been formed on the Prussian model back in the 19th century. The German Wehrmacht had just been defeated by the Soviet Army three months earlier. Also, the Japanese army had already tried and failed to defeat the Soviet army in 1939. In fact, that's how Zhukov got his first Hero of the Soviet Union award. That was in 1939, before the massive Soviet arms buildup, before the dissipation of Japanese strength in the Pacific. A Japanese general would have to be delusional to think that he could hold out against the Soviets in 1945.
- woodman 12y agoSo Japan's surrender, six days later, was just a coincidence? Maybe if you shared one of the "many" demonstrations that the "A-bomb was not the decisive part", we could weigh that against the strange timing of the whole thing.
- ekianjo 12y ago> So Japan's surrender, six days later, was just a coincidence? Japan had been already utterly destroyed by that time, the bombings in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were far from the most deadly bombings at that time. Let me remind that most large cities had been already razed to the ground. You are completely missing out the context of the time and giving way too much importance to the nukes.
- woodman 12y ago> ... the bombings in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were far from the most deadly bombings at that time. That is my point exactly. Those cities were selected for the purpose of a technological demonstration, not body count. I thought I made it clear in mentioning the time span between firebombing and surrender that Japan was not super concerned about body count, it was more about maintaining sovereignty following eventual defeat. The US demonstrated a technology that would allow it to annihilate Japan without having to shoot every child holding a stick. That would make total war, and the hope of war weariness in your enemy, completely pointless.
- JeremyNT 12y agoMy understanding has always been that the bombings were a "tech demo," but unlike your claim they were not designed to force Japan to surrender (which was already assumed). Rather, they demonstrated not only this new capability of the United States, but perhaps more importantly they demonstrated the country's willingness to inflict massive civilian casualties in an ostentatious display of the capability. Ultimately, the bombings were intended to frighten the entire world in submission, providing leverage that was used to construct the United States empire following the war.
- ekianjo 12y agoThey were indeeded a "tech demo", not intended to scare Japan which was already on the edge of capitulation, but to the Russians to show them that the US would have the upper hand for the post-war negotiations.
- deleted 12y ago[deleted]
- nolok 12y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted, this is widely accepted that both the bomb and the soviet invasion had equivalent weight in their surrender, with some historians saying the soviet declaration of war was more important. To add on that, at the time of the surrender, the long term effect of the bomb was not known to the japanese and as such the nuclear bombing wasn't the worst city bombing they suffered, neither in terms of infrastructure damage or loss of life. Some more information for those interested http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/u6qqo/there_has_been_some_controversy_on_the_true/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/u6qqo/there_h... http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2y98yc/did_the_soviet_union_have_a_large_impact_on_the/ http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/2y98yc/did_th...
- Crito 12y ago> "Not sure why you're being downvoted" The "5 year old" comment probably has something to do with it. HN doesn't tend to downvote people into the gray just because they are saying something that other people disagree with, unless the comment is also not particularly civil.
- FeeTinesAMady 12y agoYes, they do. See my comment near the top. Nothing disrespectful about it, just opinionated.
- Crito 12y agoI see only two of your comments in recent history are downvoted into the gray: This one is not civil, as it personally attacks another commenter: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169613 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169613 "That says a lot about you." This one is in defense of the less-than-civil comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169781 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169781 I say things that many people disagree with all the time on HN, but pretty much the only times that I am downvoted into the gray are when I am not civil. For instance, the only comment of mine that has been grayed in this discussion is this one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9169426 That comment is little more than a personal attack, and was therefore downvoted.
- ryanhuff 12y agoPerhaps you can provide the authoritative reference that substantiates your view. From what I have read, some historians believe that the soviet invasion was partly responsible for the timing of the surrender, but it's contribution is difficult to know. These events happened in short order. Unless you have a source from the Imperial Army or government that documents the decision making, it's all speculation. Also, I find it interesting that the soviet military waited for the second bomb before invading. Were they being opportunistic?
- InTheArena 12y agoAlso incorrect. The Atomic bomb and the Soviet invasion of Japan held China where both devestating. But as D.M Giangreco documents in "Hell to Pay", at the time, the "Peace Party" in the cabinet, most notably Kido, felt that the Atomic bomb was exactly what they needed to end the war. Kido and others in the peace party literally described it as "a gift from heaven".