14 ms·
What happens to your brain when you stop eating sugar
- ilija139 12y agoSo what happens?
- Selfcommit 12y ago>These are extreme experiments, of course. We humans aren’t depriving ourselves of food for 12 hours and then allowing ourselves to binge on soda and doughnuts at the end of the day. I guess the author is completely unaware of the lifestyle of many Americans? (Myself included). 12 hours is not a short span at all, when you consider time between going to bed and first meal. Plenty of sugar to be found in all American meal options, doubly so if you add soda to any meal / throughout the day.
- draugadrotten 12y agoThe author may have been making an attempt at irony.
- cheepin 12y agoWhy are there no referenced human experiments? Low/No carb diets have been around for ages. Surely it wouldn't be that hard to get good data on something this basic. The claims made in this article are pretty significant, why do we only have rat behavior to observe?
- ddebernardy 12y agoBest I'm aware, all diets, whether low carb or high carb, cut down on sugar sources if followed properly. Also, there is [data for humans](http://www.uctv.tv/shows/Sugar-The-Bitter-Truth-16717 http://www.uctv.tv/shows/Sugar-The-Bitter-Truth-16717) but nutritionists are only slowly coming to conclusions.
- static_noise 12y agoMost of all they are cutting down on total calories. It seems that for most people total calories are more important than the carbohydrate/fat-ratio.
- ripb 12y ago>It seems that for most people total calories are more important than the carbohydrate/fat-ratio. It's also relatively easier to track. It's easy to say "Well, I can consume about 2000 calories per day, this donut has about 300 so I'll have roughly 1700 calories left", but it's quite difficult to know the breakdown of how much carbs/protein/fat should be consumed within those 2000 calories and more difficult again to plan and monitor for those values.
- wutbrodo 12y ago> [Total calorie intake] is also relatively easier to track [than carb/fat ratio]. I'm not sure about that...knowing total calories is not quite that simple (without fairly-sized error bars), due to differences in basal metabolic rate, efficiency of absorption of calories, determining calorie counts in general (particularly for restaurant food), etc etc. On the flipside, it's much easier to understand the level of fats and carbs in a given item of food; hell once you start paying attention, you can even get a good rough guess just by the taste. On top of that, your body gives you some pretty nuanced signals related to hunger: without having put in any extra research or effort, I can definitely tell when I'm hungry for protein/fats vs carbs. I doubt it's just me, but IME at least, the feelings are completely different (this is also supported to some degree by nutritional science, in that protein and fats are known to provide satiety in a way that carbs don't).
- dragonwriter 12y ago> due to differences in basal metabolic rate Not relevant to calorie intake (relevant to calorie expenditure, which is a different issue.) > efficiency of absorption of calories differences here are the aggregate of differences in the efficiency of absorption of particular nutrients, so while this is a real source of challenges in measuring total calorie intake, its also a challenge in measuring carb/fat ratio of intake. > determining calorie counts in general (particularly for restaurant food) Again, the same problem with calorie counts here applies to carb/fat ratios.
- iopq 12y agoThere are actual studies. For example, there is no negative effect on health eating 100g of sugar a day. But above a certain amount you do start to run into problems with the amount of fructose your liver has to deal with.
- pestaa 12y agoReference intake for sugar is about 90g. http://www.foodlabel.org.uk/label/reference-intakes.aspx http://www.foodlabel.org.uk/label/reference-intakes.aspx I find it difficult (but also fun) to resist all the treats.
- ribs 12y agoMy guess is because it's bullshit. Detoxing off sugar. Give me a break.
- pjbrunet 12y agoI thought the article was going to show brain scans ;-) I gave up sugar in high school because nothing else was working on my acne. It was difficult but you can replace sugar with maple syrup, honey and fruit. After a while the craving goes away and the effect for me was pretty much permanent.
- tlarkworthy 12y agothose are all sugary replacements for sugar. That's not going to affect your brain chemistry at all. The 'difficulty' was a nocebo.
- TTPrograms 12y agoI can't see how honey, fruit, or maple syrup would be much different from any other simple carbs. As far as I've seen there's not been much difference determined between sucrose and fructose metabolism, for example. The big difference would be in cutting out all simple carbs, I would think, and then in cutting out carbs in general and going full ketogenic.
- doctorcroc 12y agoThe complex sugars in fruits and honey are different from table sugars because of the way they are metabolized by your body. They don't spike your insulin as much, and can also add essential nutrients to your diet. Nothing in dieting (and life for that matter) needs to be done on the extremes, oftentimes common sense and moderation prevail.
- iopq 12y agoFruits and honey do not have complex sugars. They have simple sugars like fructose, glucose and maltose. Fructose doesn't spike your insulin as much, but it's also 50% of table sugar. So honey is chemically almost the same as diluted sugar. Most of the nurtients in honey is small bee pieces. The rest of it is sugars and water.
- 12y ago
- peteretep 12y agoAnecdata: I've stopped drinking alcohol (3 years), and I've stopped smoking (~10 years), but giving up candy, sweet pastry, or anything that's got significant refined sugar in was too much. I managed it for six months, and then broke down, then three months, and really I haven't tried again. Interestingly, when I came at it from a slightly different angle ("mindful eating") and allowed myself as much of anything I wanted eaten mindfully, my natural desire tapered off, and I eat a lot less sweet stuff these days.
- chrismealy 12y agoNine months ago I quit sugar to see if that would help my chronic sinus congestion (it did). I had a killer headache for about two weeks, then I was fine. After my pants started falling down I noticed I'd lost a ton of weight. I lost 25 pounds and I still eat a ton of carbs.
- peteretep 12y agoYeah, I lost a ton of weight too. Felt great. Just wish I could have stuck to it.
- radicalbyte 12y agoDid you guys just drop sugar (i.e. sugar, honey, cake, biscuits, candy etc), all high-GI carbs or all carbs?
- peteretep 12y agoJust sugar for me, carbs were fine (although I wasn't eating very many high GI carbs anyway)
- doctorfoo 12y agoThat's interesting - I have chronic congestion. How much sugar did you eat before you quit? What did "quitting" mean to you? (Just no sweets/cakes/biscuits, or did you go more extreme - no chinese food!?)
- ekianjo 12y ago> Most of us prefer sweets over sour and bitter foods because, evolutionarily, our mesolimbic pathway reinforces that sweet things provide a healthy source of carbohydrates for our bodies. When our ancestors went scavenging for berries, for example, sour meant “not yet ripe,” while bitter meant “alert—poison!” There is absolutely no basis/source for this. There are in nature a number of foods that are palatable and even taste good and which are extremely toxic/lethal to humans. I rather think the association between taste and proper food is largely coincidental more than anything else.
- iopq 12y agoActually it's because our taste is not a perfect poison detector, it's SUPPOSED to filter out foods that are good for you and those that aren't, but it's a heuristic model, it's not perfect.
- GeneralMayhem 12y agoPitcher plants are also brightly colored and, I'm sure, look delicious to the insects they eat. Evolved heuristics aren't perfect.
- adrianN 12y agoToxic berries are not toxic because they want to be eaten (by the species for whom they're toxic), whereas pitcher plants look tasty because they want insects to land on them.
- guelo 12y agoIt's all so confusing since sugar and carbs are in all fruits and vegetables and grains. What are we supposed to eat? I think all the "sugar is toxic and always bad" stuff is too simplistic and a better understanding will hopefully emerge.
- onewaystreet 12y agoWhen it comes to food it's a good bet to assume that all absolutes are wrong.
- pyre 12y agoIsn't that statement itself an absolute?
- onewaystreet 12y agoNo, because "a good bet" is not an absolute. If I had said "When it comes to food all absolutes are wrong." you would be right.
- mg1982 12y agoDo you want an ice pack, 'cause you just got burned...
- vlasev 12y agoActually, thermodynamics is absolute and adhering to the laws of thermodynamics is a certainty. You can estimate your daily caloric needs on your basal metabolic rate combined with a multiplication factor based on your daily activities. Then you can estimate how much you eat. Within a small error you will be consuming and expending known amounts of energy. Eat less than you use and you'll end up losing mass whether it's fat if you are more active or muscles and fat if you are inactive. It won't be reflected 1-to-1 in the scale measurements and your size but over the long run you'll lose weight.
- kaitai 12y ago
- ssijak 12y agoMy personal experience is that cravings are gone after about 2-3 weeks after I cut simple sugars out (that includes all types of "healthy" sugars and even fruits). After that period I can watch people who gorge on cakes just like I watched people smoking after I quit and see that with different eyes and different thought process then when you are hooked too. It is pure addiction. Also, for me, if I fail and eat one portion of sweets after some time, my brain goes to the swirling path of explanation why it is ok to eat one more and tomorrow again and again... One more fix, and another... Also when I do not eat sweets and junk for a few months your taste changes and can feel stuff you could not feel before. Once after a few month I ate one bag of small chips and almost puked from it how it tasted then after my taste "cleared". Simple sugar is really more poisonous and addictive than some of the banned drugs, but the problem is that the most people do not think that way and most people know next to nothing about foods which is sad. Also when you go in to the shop there is almost not one thing without sugar in it, food industry is sick today, excpecially in USA where they are using high fructose corn syrup in every item they produce.
- tspiteri 12y agoSimple sugar is really more poisonous and addictive than some of the banned drugs Saying that eating large amounts of simple sugar is worse than small amounts of some of the banned drugs is one thing. But saying that sugar is poisonous, or simply worse than banned drugs, is a little too much.
- shiggerino 12y agoThis, I can't imagine anyone reaching toxic levels of glucose in their bloodstream by oral means, as nausea and vomiting are symptoms of hyperglycemia, preventing further intake. Though I might underestimate people's addiction, maybe there are IV glucose junkies out there now?
- ssijak 12y agoGoogle "glucose toxicity" and you will get many papers describing it under certain conditions or in excess amounts.
- signa11 12y agomy personal experience in this regard has been that after i took up running (3 times a week, approx 3-4 miles each), my sugar intake has dropped to very close to zero (with an occasional once-month-type deal of a single candy). even those colas with 'zero-sugar' appear too sweet, and the regular ones are just bleh... overall, a good thing i hope :)
- sfjailbird 12y agoSame experience. When I run regularly (one to two times a week) I have no desire for sugary or fatty foods. Instead I crave fresh fruit and vegetables. I am sure this is a type of hibernation reflex, where, with inactivity, the body wants stuff that packs a lot of energy for storage (dense with fat and/or sugar). Consequently, I focus only on getting exercise and let my diet take care of itself - it always does.
- withdavidli 12y ago>Sugar withdrawl is real So true. It happens to me within 1-2 days of cutting out refined sugar. Headaches and sluggishness, but goes away within the week. My dad tried it and got bone/joint aches. He got into a habit of eating a bowl of ice cream every night, I think it's better now, but when eating ice cream helps your bones not ache... Withdrawls to certain foods happen so quickly. Middle of last year I switched from water to tea, was drinking like 6 bottles a day and didn't think anything of it. Weekend hit, didn't have tea in the house and got headaches the entire time. Caffiene withdrawl x_X. I don't even depend on caffiene (no coffee kind of guy).
- johnward 12y agoI don't really notice withdrawal. I do have cravings for about a week then they go away. What I really notice when I'm on a keto diet is if I have a cheat meal with carbs I get a kind of high feeling in my brain. Seems like some kind of dopamine response because I equate the feeling to how I felt taking Wellbutrin once (which has a dopamine effect). Drinking alcohol has even a worse effect. Where I could normally drink 4-5 rum and coke before really feeling drunk. Now two of them will make me drunk enough that I wouldn't drive.
- static_noise 12y agoCarbohdyrates like starches are polymeric sugars. They are easily broken down by enzymes. They don't taste very sweet unless they are very short. Between white flour and glucose powder there is little difference except for the taste. Demonizing sugar is of little use when the other carbohydrates are ignored. If you have cravings you should limit your intake of total carbohydrates per hour (starting with sugars and simple carbohydrates). Complex carbohydrates should also be kept low. Protein and fat are not too bad. The body can use both sugar and fat for fuel. Everybody has a different body and different needs depending on genes and activities. Don't demonize food. Sugar as such is not evil. Try a fruit - but not more than a handfull at a time. Drink a glass of soda - but not more than once a week and preferably before doing exercise. Eat a bag of chips - on friday with a group of friends.
- vlasev 12y ago> Between white flour and glucose powder there is little difference except for the taste. That's not the only difference. Simpler carbs are processed faster than more complex ones. This plays a big role in the body's chemistry after eating.
- static_noise 12y agoWhat I wanted to express is that white flour which is usally used in industrial food is a simple carbohydrate and its digestion is so fast that it doesn't really make a difference compared to pure glucose. Complex carbs are less bad - but still, eating too much of them is not good.
- Sammi 12y agoFibers (very long/complex carbonhydrates) actually retard the intestines ability to process simpler carbonhydrates. That's why it's ok to eat a lot of fruit, cause they have the right mix of simple and complex ones.
- static_noise 12y agoYes, I forgot fiber. In Europe they are not counted as carbohydrates because they are indigestible. In the US you can subtract fiber content from total carbohydrates. Yes, fiber helps slowing digestion down and thereby reduces the height of spikes in the blood sugar level. But No, it's not OK for everybody to eat a very high amount of fruit because it may still be too much easily digestable sugar. Fruit as such is no saint - partially because our current crops are optimized for sweet taste.
- cssmoo 12y agoI was fortunate enough to be broken during a tonsilectomy. I woke up and couldn't stand anything sweet at all and it made me feel instantly sick. It has baffled many a doctor but they reckon its down to the anaesthetic and/or oxygen management. Yay to brain damage... Unfortunately I was hooked on sugar at the same time so cue epic battle of addiction vs hatred of what I was addicted to. Took two weeks to get over the cravings. Now the sweetest thing I can eat is a banana. Lost 35kg in six months though which cured a couple of problems I had. Dumping sugar albeit forcibly is one of the best things that happened to me.
- shiggerino 12y agoChocolate capital of the world being in the United States? I take exception to that.
- creepyelemental 12y agoThat made me laugh, too. It isn't like you could even say it's true in a business or evil corporation sense, either. Nestle have that covered.
- saiya-jin 12y agoYeah stroke me too as very US centric view. From european view it's more about Belgium & Switzerland (for me personally Suisse, which has better chocolate, Belgium rules in pralines)
- johnward 12y agoI'm not even sure you can call what hershey makes chocolate.
- vidarh 12y agoI'm pretty sure a lot of what they make can't legally be marketed as chocolate in Europe.
- cylinder 12y agoEspecially Hershey, PA, home of the worst chocolate in the world, Hershey's. Yuck. So tired of Americans proclaiming everything here as the greatest in the world / world champions / best in the world - far from it! And I'm American.
- 205guy 12y agoAnyone with a kid knows that the body's first addiction is sugar.
- dschiptsov 12y agoIt will become even more weak and dull, because the consciousness it produces is to dump to learn how a carbohydrate metabolism works and what are the sources of glucose and other simple sugars. The idea is about the balance - proper ratios - not too much, not too little - just enough. The idea as old as humanity. The problem is not the sugar, it is wrong eating habits, developed due to some methods of the food industry which, of course, tries to maximize its profits, including aggressive marketing of products with to high salt and/or sugar or fat concentration. This is what is wrong - amounts, concentrations and ratios. The more correct answer is - avoid packaged, processed foods in favor of simple cooked raw foods, mostly veg. It is what some Nepalese and Tibetan tribes (actually everywhere around the world) do. Also consumption of carbohydrates or any other substances cannot be considered seriously or studied without taking into account the behavioral patterns. If a typical couch potato is eating high calorie, high fat meals, intended for a docker or a peasant after full day of intense work, well, no matter sugar, he or she will end up in a well-chair. Same would happen to a vegan docker (there is zero of vegan Sherpas in a whole Himalaya). Balance is the key word. It is ancient word. It is a cornerstone of the Yoga (which, surprise! is not about wearing cute yoga pants and forming fingers into mudras). The modern word is homeostasis has the same meaning.
- prostoalex 12y agoObesity is most prevalent in countries without overdeveloped food supply chains and food marketing apparatus. According to http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/01/23/obesity-in-world-countries-map_n_6530896.html http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/2015/01/23/obesity-in-world-... "the top ten most obese nations were overwhelmingly pacific islands, with American Samoa taking the top spot with almost 75% of the population reported as obese and Nauru and the Cook Islands coming in at second and third places with 71.1% and 63.4% obesity respectively." As far as couch potatoes, the closest research that's available is this - http://www.economist.com/node/9527126 http://www.economist.com/node/9527126 and if you look at the list of top "couch potato" countries, some have high obesity rates, and some dates, so the correlation is inconclusive at best.
- dschiptsov 12y ago
- roel_v 12y agoDoes anyone know if artificial sweeteners (aspartame etc) have the same effects? Why can't I find any recipes for cooking with aspartame instead of sugar? (I tried but couldn't find any)
- maxerickson 12y agoAspartame is much, much sweeter than sugar (it actually has the same calories/unit mass as sugar) and sugar does more than provide sweetness in recipes (especially chewier things like cookies). Aspartame also degrades at baking temperatures. So it just isn't a good substitute. Maybe try sucralose, which you can just swap in for the same amount of sugar (Splenda is a famous brand).
- taternuts 12y agoSplenda does have a version of the product specifically for cooking - it seems to have a lot of 'filler' to get it to the similar consistency and volume of regular sugar (1 cup of sugar being as sweet as 1 cup of the cooking Splenda). That being said, it's best to just avoid the stuff when you can. I've found eating things with tons of Splenda in it can be pretty gross - I experimented with it a bit years ago when I first started going low carb and had bad sugar cravings, but wouldn't touch that stuff nowadays.
- maxerickson 12y agoYes, I just eat things with normal sugar if I want something sweet. But apparently the commenter I replied to had not considered the potential differences between the substitutes, so I pointed out a way forward. I was confused about sucralose though, I hadn't realized that it required fillers to use as a 1:1 substitute. The fillers also apparently are not very hydroscopic (which is a major role that sugar plays in baking, in addition to being sweet).
- saiya-jin 12y agosimple advice - stay away from that chemical cr*p
- 12y ago
- gabemart 12y agoMy sugar cravings don't feel like cravings, they feel more like hunger. I can eat a delicious meal of whole foods and be full to the point that it's physically uncomfortable, but I still feel ravenously hungry for sugar. It's like I have two separate appetites. I am currently in the process of trying to quit sugar.
- acd 12y agoThe fast food knows this that's why you get free soda refills so you will back to their restaurant and spend more money. I think there is also a similar addiction to fat which would also make evolutionary sense if you were starving. Personally I get addicted to potato chips as long as the bag lasts I wont stop eating.
- UbuntuJon 12y agoSorry to nitpick but I wouldn't call Hershey the "chocolate capital of the world". I don't think anyone outside America really eats Hershey chocolate, and it has a poor reputation. Try visiting Europe if you want good chocolate.
- scaraffe 12y agoIf sugar is bad, why are we wired to eat it more and remember it's taste? Isn't evolution supposed make us live longer?
- AmrMostafa 12y agoI think it's because our ancestors didn't have easy access to food in the way we do now. Our bodies are wired to consume and store energy which are necessary for survival in times of starvation.
- TomGullen 12y agoFirst of all, sugar isn't bad, it's bad in the quantities we generally eat it in modern diets. People also generally don't recognise that sugar you put in your coffee is pretty much the same as the carbohydrates in your pasta. Evolutionary wise, in palaeolithic times sugar was probably very rare (you'd come across a bush of fruit every now and then perhaps but not all the time). Sugar is something extremely beneficial for your body if there's a lack of it in your diet and you're in a daily survival situation, it's pretty much pure energy. So evolutionary wise, when you come across a patch of sugary fruit it's beneficial to eat it all! Nowadays we're surrounded by sugar and our diets are saturated with it. The food industries are advertising lies to us all the time. Seen those green cans of Coke with 'healthy' sugar in them? Pretty much complete bullshit!
- haffi112 12y agoYou could apply this argument to anything addictive, such as smoking...
- socksy 12y agoEvolution is "supposed" to make the genome live longer. Managed to recreate? Cool. You've served your evolutionary purpose.
- ajuc 12y agoIt was scarce, and starvation was more common threat than diabetes. Also evolution doesn't care if you are happy, healthy, live long, etc. It only cares how good are you at spreading your genes. We only live long because grandparents make kids more probable to live long enough to procreate.
- paganel 12y agoI know I'm anthropomorphizing, but quotes like the one below give me new and increased empathy for rats and their cause. I know that without us killing them "for science" lots of drugs and medical treatments wouldn't have been discovered, is just that seeing us, humans, forcing anxiety-related feelings on other beings makes me, well, a little anxious. > Naloxone treatment also appeared to make the rats more anxious, as they spent less time on an elevated apparatus that lacked walls on either side. Monuments dedicated to lab rats like this one (http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/1hhyta/a_monument_to_lab_rats_used_for_dna_research/ http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/1hhyta/a_monument_to_l...) make me just a little bit happier on the inside.
- Lio 12y agoJust to be pedantic, that's a monument to lab mice, not lab rats, for their use in genetic research experiments. If you know what happen to mice used in these experiments then I'm sure you'll agree they deserve their monument. It's a bit worse than anxiety-related feelings but we do need things like cures to cancers, cystic fibrosis, etc. so IMHO ...it has to be done. So we try to do it as little as possible and minimise suffering as much as possible. Again, IMHO, it's also one of the ethical arguments for why all information from sequencing experiments should be in the public domain.
- shamney 12y agowhy the obsession with cutting out a harmless and tasty part of a normal diet?
- spain 12y agoIn my experience I cut out a lot of candy, sugars, and sweets from my diet at a very young age and haven't looked back, so I don't have that much experience with the "cravings" or withdrawal symptoms people describe (I don't drink coffee either). I like to believe the reason for this is that my tongue was a little more sensitive than normal and so I often got "overwhelmed" by sugary foods and simply started avoiding them (I still do). Grownups used to tease me about this whenever candy came up, they were flabbergasted that a child would reject candy as a reward or present for doing something. What? A kid that wouldn't do anything for a candy bar? Impossible. I also avoid soft drinks like Coca-Cola because they produce an almost allergic reaction with my tongue (it aches for the rest of the day) though that might just be the preservatives. As a result I mostly stick to "vanilla" foods and drinks as I like to call them, like plain water and milk. I might be wrong and still be getting too much unhealthy sugars and stuff from other food, but I'd like to think that it's not so severe since I live in Finland and not the US. I'm also slightly underweight so there's that, though I suspect that might be due to my genes. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I'm sort of glad they way things turned out in my case.
- rthomas6 12y agoThere's been some research that suggests that children, unlike adults, have no limit to the amount of sweetness they will tolerate/enjoy in a food. Maybe your sweetness limit just kicked in earlier than your peers.
- oAlbe 12y agoI stopped drinking any kind of fizzy drinks for more than a year now and I don't miss them. Before stopping I used to drink three to six glasses of coke (around 200ml per glass) every day and making two plus two I realized this habit was going to do me harm sooner or later. I wasn't fat nor I had health problems. I just wanted to do something healthy for myself. I remember that it wasn't hard at all for me to stop. For the first week I kind of craved it, but not even that much. Every time it happened I just started thinking "This is going to make you feel bad and guilty" and the craving went away. It must be said that at the time I was on a diet plan and I was practicing running, counting every single calorie I ate and every single calorie I burnt. Thinking that it took me twenty minutes of running to burn 250Kcals and that a single glass could have given me back almost half of them (105Kcal for a glass of Coca-Cola) was a very powerful motivation.
- T3RMINATED 12y agoyou stole this article this has been posted by the scientific journal ... someone ban this guy
- andy_ppp 12y agoI've decided to give up sugar after reading this. I get the feeling a lot of the interest in eating food is down to sugar rewards. I guess I feel that response of boredom after eating a no carb or sugar meal rather than a small feeling of pleasure is something I should get used to - I don't have to have a reward after every item of food I eat and I hope giving up sugar will make the other rewards I get from doing a good piece of work or say accomplishing giving up sugar for 30 days that much more rewarding.
- iriche 12y ago"These are extreme experiments, of course. We humans aren’t depriving ourselves of food for 12 hours and then allowing ourselves to binge on soda and doughnuts at the end of the day." Have they talked to anyone working with IT? ;)
- ujjwal_wadhawan 12y agoI bet this video will make you think - Robert H. Lustig, MD, UCSF Professor of Pediatrics in the Division of Endocrinology, explores the damage caused by sugary foods Sugar: The Bitter Truth https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM
- steveplace 12y agoObligatory rebuttal whenever this video is posted http://www.alanaragonblog.com/2010/01/29/the-bitter-truth-about-fructose-alarmism/ http://www.alanaragonblog.com/2010/01/29/the-bitter-truth-ab...
- richardwigley 12y agoThe article summaries as 'we eat too much sugar', 'here's some science that suggests it can be bad in rodents', and finally 'maybe you should swear off sugar'. I agree, we eat too much sugar. However, it is a step to go from rodents to humans and they have not addressed it. We're apes that lived in Africa. We spent a lot of time in trees eating fruit all year around. We have eyes that are adapted to find fruit - so much so that while most of our furry mammal relatives, like rodents tested in the article, are red-green color blind (dichromats) [1] we are mainly trichromatic, color vision. Trichromatic helps you to pick out a red fruit from a green background [2]. So, for some reason, our ancestors that could see fruit, did better than those that didn't, which was not the case with rodents. I suggest we evolved on different diet than what rodents evolved on. Before comparing sugar to an addiction you should reproduce the results on primates - I'd be happy to be in the control group and snack on a Snickers bar ;-) [1] http://www.ratbehavior.org/RatVision.htm http://www.ratbehavior.org/RatVision.htm [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_of_color_vision http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evolution_of_color_vision
- thro1237 12y agoI can't find a source quickly -- but I remember reading that many years back (like when we were apes in Africa), the sweetest fruit was probably as sweet as a carrot. We increased the sweetness of fruits through selective breeding to current levels.
- cylinder 12y agoAnd I imagine the fruits wouldn't be eaten as ripe as they are now - people prefer sweeter fruits, and they sweeten as they ripen. I prefer more sour and tart fruit, so I tend to prefer less ripened fruit.
- wnevets 12y agoNot to mention a lot of fruit are loaded with fiber which reduces the glycemic spike.
- saosebastiao 12y agoThat doesn't explain blackberries which have only been cultivated in the last 100 years, due to more advanced farming techniques. They have been seen as more of a scourge for centuries, because of their knack for strangling other cultivated plants.
- blparker 12y agoAfter reading these comments, I'm more confused than entering. Throughout the years, we've constantly been subjected to advertising from fad diets claiming low-fat or low-carb or no-grain or no-sugar or low-whatever is the magic elixir to being healthy and losing weight. It seems that every nutritionist you talk to has a subjective bias as to the key. I understand that the body is an incredibly complex machine, and it's probably impossible to distill things down into a set of manageable steps, but I would just like to know what to eat, what not to eat, some simple science as to why, and not have bullshit or biases injected into the conversation.
- zemvpferreira 12y agoI think Michael Pollan summed it up best: eat food, not too much, mostly plants.
- tomjen3 12y agoCitation needed. Especially about the mostly plants part. We know humans couldn't have gotten the brains we have without eating meat. Also Aspatarme is likely less dangerous than sugar.
- blparker 12y agoI'm interested in that last statement regarding aspartame. It seems you find extremely polarized opinions on artificial sweeteners. I've often read that, regardless of the health impact (or lack thereof), artificial sweeteners are more-or-less "tricking" your body into thinking it has calories incoming, when in fact, it doesn't. Your body, feeling jipped, tries to compensate by craving more calories. But, again, this is hearsay.
- tomjen3 12y agoThe Mayo clinic disagree with you: http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/diabetes/expert-answers/artificial-sweeteners/faq-20058038 http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/diabetes/exper... The diabetus journal seems to agree with you (I was unable to follow what they had found completely) http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/30/7/e59.long http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/30/7/e59.long Finally (N=1) I drink way more aspartame sweetened soda than any sane person should and I was relatively easily able to shred roughly 1/3 of body weight without serious hunger.
- finnjohnsen2 12y agoI gave up sugar products 3 years. (30 march 2012). I've had no physical cravings or reactions what so ever. Not the first hours, days or weeks, nothing, ever. I don't care about the marginal stuff though. Sugar is added to a lot of non-intuitive products. My rule of thumb is - if it is highly probable that the product wouldn't be around if it weren't for its sugar, I don't eat it. Not everyone has the 'physical addicted' genes I guess. I suspect my "secret" is that I don't allow considering sweets to stay in my brain for even the smallest amount of time. I look away and think about something else. Start a dummy conversation with someone, look at the magazines, pick up my smart phone.