7 ms·
In France, a Baby Switch and a Lesson in Maternal Love
- jarjoura 12y agoHow touching. This story gives me hope that I can both deeply love an adopted child and that the child will love me back.
- morbius 12y agoIndeed, it is a gorgeous story. We use the excuse of biological dissimilarities to get around the fact that most archetypes we've constructed have been artificially constructed -- gender, relationships, and socialization all revolve around certain attributes that are very arbitrary and have little, if anything, to do with biological characteristics. The controversial "wire mother" experiment carried out by Harry Harlow[1] proves this to some extent. Another story much like the one in the NYT article, if you're interested: http://www.npr.org/2015/02/20/387309723/pain-but-no-regrets-a-father-remembers-his-adopted-son http://www.npr.org/2015/02/20/387309723/pain-but-no-regrets-... [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Harlow http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harry_Harlow
- smoyer 12y agoI don't have any maternal instincts (by definition) but can assure you that loving a child is actually pretty easy (and natural). My adopted daughter is our fourth child and I've got the same attachment to her that I have to the three I sired.
- fecak 12y agoI had similar questions when we were presented the opportunity to adopt a newborn. She is now 10 days old, and she has felt like mine ever since I first saw her minutes after her birth. Perhaps my experience is unique, but I didn't expect the connection to happen as quickly (instantly) as it did.
- Asparagirl 12y agoMazel Tov!
- ars 12y agoYou love someone if you take care of them (or are taken care of). That's about all it takes. And it is not required that one of the parties be a child. Biology matters, but not as much as care.
- jkot 12y agoIt should be said that parental tests are illegal in France (and some other countries), and parents in this case could face huge fine and jail. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parental_testing#France https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parental_testing#France
- golemotron 12y agoWhy would they be illegal? Shouldn't men be able to know whether they are the biological fathers of their children?
- pervycreeper 12y agoIt's illegal in order to prevent precisely this.
- zodiakzz 12y agoHow is it determined who needs to pay child support then?
- nraynaud 12y agosocial bond
- golemotron 12y agoSocial bond with a woman who cheated?
- m_mueller 12y agoFrench society may in that aspect be a little closer to Japanese, to which I'm more familiar with: Some cultures put more value on harmony than on justice. This was at first not very easy for me to understand, coming from a German speaking culture, and I believe it may be even more difficult for Americans (who according to my impression seem to be even more demanding of 'justice'), but it is what it is. Just as an example, in case of a car accident in Japan, the blame (and thus damages/fines) is almost always shared (even in completely obvious situation where we would see one party 100% at fault), especially so when a passenger other than the driver was hurt - just so the driver in question wouldn't loose his face completely. 'Being there' at the wrong moment is enough to be partially blamed for what happened. There's something to this you know - if an incident is potent enough to destroy someone's social status, it often might be better for society to let it slip, rather than to go the 'nuclear option' (i.e. the American way) of throwing people in jail, make them loose their job, possibly their family, or even take away their children. With marriages it's similar - husbands/wives often rather don't want to know rather than to risk a family's stability.
- MyHypatia 12y ago“After four days, how can you not recognize your baby?” Sophie Chas, the lawyer for the clinic, told the newspaper Le Figaro. “We can believe in it when it’s a second, a day, two days. But 10 years? The mothers may have been involved in creating the damage.” How sad that the lawyer chose to argue that "the mothers may have been involved in creating the damage"... because they trusted the doctors? ...because they didn't possess some "maternal instinct" to recognize a baby they had spent almost no time with? Even after say 2 years or 10 years it's your fault because you didn't call the police to report that your child's skin tone doesn't match your own? How is it even acceptable to make this argument in a court?
- nraynaud 12y agoin France, when the judge is a professional (by opposition to a jury), you can use whatever arguments you want in court. But outrageous arguments are extremely risky, the lawyer might have been in a desperate position to use that.
- infr4long 12y ago> “The nurse said that the lights from the phototherapy treatment made the baby’s hair grow,” > The other mother, also 18 at the time, asked another nurse why her baby lacked hair. She was told that phototherapy could also shorten hair. Unfortunately, this kind of attitude from incompetent employees is damaging to the society, and it is quite commonplace in France.
- swframe 12y agoYou might be interested in this story too: http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/360/switched-at-birth http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/360/s...
- 205guy 12y agoTo summarize, two babies were switched at birth with plausible explanation as to why neither mother acted on her suspicions. Each mother bonded with her non-biological child, and raised her as her own (just like millions of adoptions the world over). 10 years later, when a paternity test finally happened (the delay was better explained in these HN comments) and the families were reunited, differences in parenting and family dynamics (one said to have strict discipline) meant neither family got along with their biological child nor wanted to keep in close touch. They still made about $1 million each from the birth clinic in a civil suit. I'm not really sure what the big deal is here, and whatever cultural significance was missed by the NYT author (surprising given the French-sounding name). Fact is, this was the plot of a hugely successful French movie in back in 1988, thus still entrenched in the memories of many adults. Of course, the movie was more of a white-collar vs blue-collar social satire and very funny. But the real story for the French audience was that of life imitating art. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_Is_a_Long_Quiet_River http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_Is_a_Long_Quiet_River http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_vie_est_un_long_fleuve_tranquille http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/La_vie_est_un_long_fleuve_tranq...